4 ms·
In fact, if you haven't tried to recover from a backup, it probably doesn't work. Like most recovery/data integrity hardware/software, if it isn't being (regula
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
In fact, if you haven't tried to recover from a backup, it probably doesn't work. Like most recovery/data integrity hardware/software, if it isn't being (regularly) tested, it probably is misconfigured, not running or broken. Like all software.
I've seen many PC-raid hardware solutions that simply didn't work. A drive fails, and the machine becomes unusable, fail to recover when a good drive is inserted, or crashes/hangs and the data is lost.
Yet people keep buying raid solutions for PCs. I recommend: pull a drive from your raid hardware and see what happens. If you're afraid to do that, then you need a different solution.
- bluGill 7y agoI used to work at a RAID hardware company (since bought by SUN, now Oracle though I have no idea if that model is still sold). Salesmen were told to demonstrate the system by pulling a random drive from the production disk and put it on top. 15 minutes latter someone from support showed up with a new disk (not IT, support), the salesmen made sure they were still next to the machine to show off that support knew about the failure and could replace it quickly. If you don't have the same confidence in your systems you need to fix that.
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoWhat kind of protection layer was in place? I've been using ZFS for years and this type of functionality is standard.
- bluGill 7y agoThis was hardware raid. There were two parity disks per stripe as I recall. This was about 20 years ago and I didn't work on that system: my memory of the details is probably wrong.
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoThanks!
- sliken 7y agoHeh. I visited a colleague and they had a fancy new netapp and he demonstrated pulling a drive, status light change and notification, reinserting it, status light change and notification. The next morning he got a fedex from netapp... a replacement drive.
- fortran77 7y agoNow at my 3-person startup, we test our backups once a week! Really. I once took over management of a startup that was just acquired (this was back in 1999). The people there never did backups. Ever. They told me with a straight face: "We have a RAID. It doesn't need to be backed up."
- rhinoceraptor 7y agoHardware RAID is a declaration of war on humanity by firmware. Use ZFS!