4 ms·
Hm that's been a big issue for maybe 200 years. Should the government start its own companies? What happened to the free market? How does a 'free' government co
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Hm that's been a big issue for maybe 200 years. Should the government start its own companies? What happened to the free market? How does a 'free' government company respond to competition (since they have no pressure to be profitable)?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIt seems to be working fine in every other country mentioned in this thread where government is free to provide free tax filing services. We do not need bullshit jobs at rent seeking companies that are glorified PDF generators. This is a government feature, not a product.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoSo maybe this one should be allowed. Other government competition with private enterprise is not so clear. Paving roads? Providing medicine? Delivering packages? Its been a rocky road.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI'm going to say probably not. I've been pretty disappointed by the attempts of private industry to deliver what should be government infra (tax prep, healthcare, prisons, etc), while I'm super happy with my roads, police, fire, water, sewer, muni fiber, and the USPS (all government provided or backed).
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI have 'volunteer' fire service out here in the country. And installed my own sewer. Police are essentially non-existent out here - I see a patrol car maybe once a year go by. And the USPS has been going broke for decades now. Not a good example of a well-run service.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoUSPS requires Congressional approval to set rates (as well as pension funding requirements). Your complaint is with your representatives, not USPS itself.
- pfranz 7y agoIt reminds me of the demonization of the IRS, they just carry out Congress' laws and funding. It's disingenuous when Congresspeople complain as they reduce their funding.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoPlays well to the uneducated unfortunately.
- scarejunba 7y agoPlays well to everyone because most people hate representatives but like their representative.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoMy complaint is with 'government-run businesses', which will always have such issues. It stems from not being responsible for efficiency or profitability.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThis is a strawman argument. Being "government run" does not automatically equate to being irresponsible or inefficient. Your complaint holds no water: Social Security and Medicare are incredibly efficient programs for their scale, and both wildly popular with their participants (per Pew Research as well as direct survey data from SSA and HHS). If they can achieve such results, why would other large orgs such as the IRS not? Rhetorical of course! They can, with proper political and logistical support (as has been seen with USDS/18F executing at the IRS, DHS, and VA).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- andrekandre 7y agobut if private enterprise is more efficient than govt, what do they have to fear?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoA breakdown of a belief system.
- lutorm 7y agoIt's not a right to be free from competition from the government. The reason we allow corporations is so they can serve the public good, but if the public good would be better served by the government providing that service then there's no reason society shouldn't do that.
- kerkeslager 7y ago> How does a 'free' government company respond to competition (since they have no pressure to be profitable)? The leadership of government organizations has pressure to get re-elected, or to get someone from their party elected. I'm not sure whether you are simply ignorant how representative democracy is supposed to work, or whether you're feigning ignorance. Is it really so unfathomable that people might be motivated by something other than financial gain? Are we expected to take anything else you say seriously if this is the starting point of your ideology?
- isaacgreyed 7y agoIs the vote of the election ever: "Can you make this one website that is messy better?". People are more focused on big issues and annoying software won't often make the platform.
- kerkeslager 7y agoThe vote of the election isn't "Can you make this one website that is messy better?" because the politicians are incentivized to never let it get that bad. One only has to take a look at the Obama administration's apparent panic over healthcare.gov to see this at work. When it wasn't going well, it very much was a political issue at the forefront of political conversation.
- Spooky23 7y agoI worked for a self-sustaining government entity for a few years. There was no direct appropriation, all funds re recovered via fees. We were able to compete successfully with commercial entities in a variety of ways. A big advantage is overhead. If the work scales out, government employees get paid less, especially executives. The disadvantage was that you couldn’t make money to re-invest, and capitalizing new services was difficult. .gov orgs get a lot of grief, but if you compare them to an average large company, they aren’t as awful as most people think.
- perl4ever 7y agoI've worked in a private sector (publicly traded) fortune 500 company, a large government contractor, a non-profit state government subsidiary that was quasi-independent, and now for a state government. My experience is that in the public sector, things often move slower, but the range of productivity seems to have a significant overlap with an average large company. I think the cost of nobody believing in what they are doing is an underappreciated drag on many private sector workplaces. The fact that failure is not an option in the public sector has several oft repeated negative consequences, but it also means that you have a reason for coming to work and making an effort, (other than not starving) even if nobody appreciates it, management is terrible, working conditions are lousy, pay is poor, co-workers are idiots, etc. That counts for something towards effectiveness, if there is a core group that hasn't descended into nihilism.
- mars4rp 7y agoGovernment is forcing people to pay their taxes, so Government needs to provide a free and easy way for people to pay their taxes.