7 ms·
Data as a Property Right
- peter_d_sherman 7y agoDisclaimer: I am neither for nor against Andrew Yang as President; I merely find affinity with the idea of data as a property right. In other words, I think it's a good idea.
- closeparen 7y agoYou can enter into binding contracts to sell, rent, or donate your property under pretty much any terms. This makes “data as property” a lot weaker than GDPR, which treats it more like your person in constraining what you can give up.
- prepend 7y agoSort of. I think it falls apart quickly. If I draw a picture of you, is it your data or mine? If you walk through my house and I store the pattern you leave in my WiFi signal, is it your data or mine. I think we’d have to narrowly define what belongs to an individual and it would be too narrow to address the problem. Also data as property would get signed away for nothing like how arbitration clauses are in practically every contract with no added benefit to the signer.
- umvi 7y ago> If I draw a picture of you, is it your data or mine? Clearly mine. You recorded information about me without my consent.
- MR4D 7y agoAnd when you use a Visa card? Is it yours, visa’s, the store’s, or the bank’s? Or all of the above?
- prepend 7y agoIf you’re in a public place, why would I need your consent? Does TNG’s Geordi La Forge need consent from every being in sight because his visor is recording them and relaying images to his brain? There should be no expectation of privacy in public places. Commercialization is a different story, I think.
- MR4D 7y agoThank you for posting this! I had the same thought using a Visa card transaction, but you saved me the work! Second order effects from this crazy policy are nearly infinite. Note that I’m not talking about the intent of the regulation, but rather the issues of implementing it.
- wefarrell 7y agoI appreciate Yang as a candidate and I hope his ideas gain traction. That having been said, implementing these rights is a huge task. For example: "The right to download all data in a standardized format to port to another platform" Just deciding on a standardized format for all data will involve significant political effort and technical effort. I don't think it's even possible to apply these as blanket rights to all data. Focusing on certain domains (healthcare, finance, etc...) will help.
- phiresky 7y agoAll of those rights or stronger are already in effect in the EU since last year, which means most companies doing online business already have to comply with them. In fact it's pretty clear that Yang mostly just copied GDPR with this whole proposal. I'm not complaining, it's a great law if you're for consumer protection. Many companies already provide the option to download all data, and I've written GDPR data request mails to multiple US based companies with success. Mostly you get the data in JSON files (without schema). Right now, many companies are trying as hard as they can to skirt the law, but there's land mark cases happening already that will hopefully put an and to that soon [1]. [1]: https://techcrunch.com/2019/10/01/europes-top-court-says-active-consent-is-needed-for-tracking-cookies/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/10/01/europes-top-court-says-act... ironically, techcrunch is a prime example of a "tracking cookie consent" popup that is absolutely illegal and will hopefully get them huge fines once the data protection agencies have their hands less full with bigger fish (google, facebook, etc).
- RenRav 7y agoSome control over this stuff would be nice.
- ihinsdale 7y agoThe cost of complying with such regulations would effectively fall on companies as a regressive tax. Which companies benefit in relative terms from a regressive tax? The already-large ones.
- nostrademons 7y agoYang is also fairly pro-blockchain. One of the key innovations of blockchains is being able to encode data as a property right and enforce it through software, moving the cost of compliance from the legal system (expensive) to the CPU (cheap).
- schoen 7y agoHow do blockchains help you "enforce" restrictions on downstream uses of personal data?
- nostrademons 7y agoEncrypt your data; publish to public blockchain. Instead of ever giving out the data itself, you give out the right to do something with that data, in the form of signing a method call on a smart contract platform. This is basically the capability security model applied to data in the cloud. Capabilities have well-known patterns for things like revoking access over time (see eg. the Membrane Pattern). To prevent cases where the "something" that the smart contract does is "copy all your data bit-for-bit and upload it to my evil masters", you could perhaps apply information entropy, on a platform level, to the source and output data, and only allow the transaction if the output data contains many fewer bits than the input. So say you have all of your location data and review history on the blockchain, encrypted with a private key known only to you, and you want to grant an application the ability to recommend nearby restaurants that you might like. You authorize the transaction, and expect that the contract will release ~1K to you (a restaurant name, description, menu, reviews, and geocode) and will increase the data stored within its own data ownership by 0 bytes. If it does something otherwise, it's broken the contract, and can be automatically penalized financially (because this is a blockchain, it inherently needs a cryptocurrency). I've had an idea for something like this since hearing about Google's Federated Machine Learning research paper and reading the Ethereum spec, but have other more pressing projects right now and don't have time to implement it. If anyone feels it's interesting, feel free to steal - I'd still love to work on it at some point in the future, but there're still some holes in the idea (notably around the information theory & federated learning aspects) and another speculative research project isn't really what I'm looking for now.
- danShumway 7y ago>>> - The right to be informed as to what data will be collected, and how it will be used - The right to opt out of data collection or sharing - The right to be told if a website has data on you, and what that data is - The right to be forgotten; to have all data related to you deleted upon request - The right to be informed if ownership of your data changes hands - The right to be informed of any data breaches including your information in a timely manner - The right to download all data in a standardized format to port to another platform >>> The vast majority of these rights only work when applied to commercial entities. They don't protect you from government invasion, and they don't protect you from individual/social invasion. When applied on the individual level, many of them are flat-out unconsitutional (the right to be forgotten is a particularly obvious example). Does this matter? Is it a problem if we specifically target corporations first? I think it does matter. Even though corporations are currently some of the worst privacy offenders, I think there's real harm in orienting the privacy debate around Capitalist terms, and I think it sets a really bad precedent for future conversations. I strongly suspect that a pivot to talking about privacy as a property right being violated will make it easier for the government to dismiss future criticism, and easier for malicious groups to claim that data from public sources should be fair game. My right to privacy is not based on the idea that I am being economically harmed. It's based on the idea that I have a fundamental right to hide my identity, and a fundamental right to choose what I disclose to the people around me. Money has nothing to do with it. This proposal also goes against years of collective advocacy from activists for both an Open web and a private web that no one can own a fact. I firmly believe that the expansion of IP laws are counterproductive, even when expanded ostensibly for the sake of privacy. Andrew Yang may speak for some members of the privacy community, but he doesn't speak for all of them. I really wish the politicians who are just now jumping on the privacy train would spend more time looking at the history behind these debates and the history of the activists that were working before them.
- ethansinjin 7y agoThese rights are strikingly similar to the ones outlined in GDPR.
- jjuel 7y agoHow is the right to be forgotten unconstitutional? I would think me being able to have my data deleted upon my request wouldn't necessarily infringe on my own freedoms, but I could be wrong.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- throwaway13337 7y agoThis is the wrong approach. It doesn't address the biggest privacy concern: the government's collection and use of personal data. No restrictions there, I guess. Information wants to be free - even when it's about you. Putting that genie back in the bottle - the right to be forgotten - creates a world that is less free. We should be really going the other direction and not allowing these corporations to hold this data in private silos to re-enforce their monopolies. They use the force of law to hold these monopolies over the things you've written so that it's their property and not the property of the individual. That's wrong and that's granted by the government.
- umvi 7y agoWell, as we are finding out, freedom results in people being hurt. If you limit the freedom, you can prevent people from getting hurt. Is freedom worth the harm it enables? That is a choice everyone has to make. Most people are willing to give up a lot of freedom in exchange for mitigating harm.
- microcolonel 7y ago> Is freedom worth the harm it enables? Yes.
- velosol 7y agoGenerally yes. When someone says "I give up this freedom" it's often because they don't use it or it doesn't affect them. The problem is that what they are really saying is "I give up this freedom for myself and everyone else." This is bad when you have a large group willing to give up a freedom they already don't use or care about that only affects a minority of people. The problem comes that a different, overlapping large group is willing to give up another freedom and now the minority affected by that loss was part of the first large group. It's easy for this to continue until everyone has lost a freedom they enjoyed because they signed up with some large group, often thinking they were 'right'. TL;DR: The road to hell is paved with good intentions.
- AcerbicZero 7y agoI certainly agree with you, that the larger concern here has to be the government, and its overt, broad, barely regulated, data collection efforts. I'm pretty sure Yang is the best thing to come out of this election season so far, even though I have to disagree with him on a large number of items, at least he's forcing some conversations.
- anigbrowl 7y agoI prefer actual privacy rights that are inalienable than having my life commoditized and made the subject of contractual bargaining for every little thing.