How does "even if you just give the software to your client and never upload it to Github or release it publicly online" in any way conflict with what I said? I

How does "even if you just give the software to your client and never upload it to Github or release it publicly online" in any way conflict with what I said? I said "It's like giving it away" - I never said the size of the audience. I didn't say anything about widespread distribution. And your point...is identical to the one I was making, that licensing something as open source is not volunteering to do anything from here on out, but instead just giving away the work you've already done. You're nit picking where there are no nits.