5 ms·
I really don't understand why I have to file my taxes to begin with. I have a W2 job, and my employer presumably has sent my paystubs and tax information to th
by tombert 7y ago
I really don't understand why I have to file my taxes to begin with.
I have a W2 job, and my employer presumably has sent my paystubs and tax information to the government already. I then have to copy down the information from my W2 into some kind of tax filing software, and then they have to check to make sure that what I typed matches what they have, presumably paying someone to do that if I make any kind of serious mistake. Why do I have to do anything?
I'd understand if I have a lot of complex deductions or if I were running my own business, but as it stands I do the basic standard deduction (or whatever the default options on TurboTax are).
I'm genuinely asking this...is there some utility that I'm missing here to me doing the taxes myself?
- pwinnski 7y agoYou are dealing with a consequence of TurboTax's 20-Year Fight to Stop Americans from Filing Taxes for Free. There have been proposals to mail cards to taxpayers with their financial information (as known to the government) pre-printed, and if everything is accurate, the recipient does nothing at all. TurboTax (and a few others) lobbied heavily to make sure such efforts were defeated, and so you have to keep doing your own taxes. But please, stop using TurboTax to do so!
- 0xffff2 7y agoIt's not terribly difficult to construct circumstances in which the government doesn't know how much you owe them. It's simpler to have a single policy for everyone. Therefore, everyone has to do their own taxes. I really don't think it's more complicated than that.
- Chris_Chambers 7y agoPointing out the problem is the first step toward creating pressure to solve it. I don’t understand why people like you always side with the bad guys to push back against progress. Pretending there’s some innocent angle to their conduct is even worse.
- pm215 7y agoSimpler for who? It's not simpler for the vast bulk of people whose only significant income is from their employer. It's not simpler for the tax authorities either, who now have to process a lot more tax returns rather than just doing something more straightforward for the common-case.
- 0xffff2 7y agoOf course it's simpler for the IRS. Simpler does not imply less work.
- ryandrake 7y agoI wonder what percent of taxpayers actually owe a different amount than the IRS can compute on its own. My guess is it’s not much more than 30% (the percentage who itemize deductions). Is it really worth making 100% of taxpayers do their own just to handle the edge case of people who actually have to?
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoCapital gains, gambling winnings, and state use taxes aren't completely accounted for.
- djsumdog 7y agoNope. In New Zealand you log into a website and it shows all your employers filings. You can send in requests for corrections if things are wrong, but it shows you taxes paid and anything you owe the IRD. It has an interface for transferring money to/from your bank account for payments/returns. It's a little more complex if you own a business, but I think you can file and maintain all your business taxes throughout the year using an IRD website as well. The US IRS has all the information to do the exact same thing. It's lobbying from the tax software companies that's kept them from doing so.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe US does too, you can login to social security administration and see all your earnings history.
- crisnoble 7y agoThink of it like a high school test, you submit your test to the IRS, who has the answers, and they tell you if you are correct. Also, the US is the only class who's teacher doesn't either show them the key or skip the test entirely. When I realized that some other countries have no concept of a tax day and don't understand the yearly hype train of US taxes, that's when I got really bummed out on how broken our system is.