12 ms·
It isn’t just Samsung making crappy biometrics: take a look at the face unlock marketing copy on the Pixel 4. It just says “simply look at your phone to secure
by dangus 7y ago
It isn’t just Samsung making crappy biometrics: take a look at the face unlock marketing copy on the Pixel 4.
It just says “simply look at your phone to securely unlock it.” They make no claims about how secure it is.
In fact there are already articles showing how the unlock feature works while you’re asleep: https://9to5google.com/2019/10/16/pixel-4-tidbits-face-unlock-security/ https://9to5google.com/2019/10/16/pixel-4-tidbits-face-unloc...
To my knowledge, Apple is the only vendor that actually made in-depth claims about the security of their face unlock solution. They’re the only vendor that assumed anyone cared.
Android OEMs are working off a feature checklist and that’s about it.
- ahbyb 7y agoA fingerprint reader can also be operated while the victim is asleep, unconscious, and even after you sever the thumb off (remote attack!!). Does that mean a fingerprint reader cannot be ever be called secure?
- petschge 7y agoA fingerprint is never a secure password. It is a username at best.
- ses1984 7y agoI think you mean the worst case scenario for a fingerprint is that it's a username.
- nolok 7y agoI think what he means is that you leave your fingerprint everywhere without even realizing it so it's the biometric equivalent of asking for your email; a random attacker won't know it but any one with a wee bit of motivation can get it.
- ses1984 7y agoA wee bit of motivation, hah, are you James Bond or something? Usernames can be guessed remotely, fingerprints can't really. Please demonstrate an attack that takes "a wee bit" of effort where you can use a fingerprint you found in the wild to auth.
- josefx 7y agoThe CCC went after a German politician to show just how easily you could copy a fingerprint even without access to an object touched by the target[1]. A few pictures of the finger are more than enough. [1] https://www.macrumors.com/2014/12/29/ccc-reproduce-fingerprints-public-photos/ https://www.macrumors.com/2014/12/29/ccc-reproduce-fingerpri...
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoHow do you actually use the picture of the fingerprint to get into a phone? It doesn’t accept pictures, only fingers.
- et-al 7y agoFrom the NewScientist article Laforet linked above: > fake fingerprints can be created by imprinting copies in rubbery gels or silicone plastic, says Marcela Espinoza of the Institute of Police Science in Lausanne, Switzerland. Replace silicone with some other flesh-like material that's conductive.
- ses1984 7y agoOk but isn't that significantly more trouble than seeing or guessing a username? Does this take just a "wee bit of motivation"?
- petschge 7y agoPrint with a laserjet onto overhead projector foil, spread a suitable kind of wood glue, dry, peel and apply to own finger tip. It is actually very straight forward.
- xoa 7y agoNo. It is a biometric identifier. That is what it is. A username is a human language convenient symbolic pointer that is meant to be public and used socially. I am still confused about why this particular incorrect meme is so persistent. "Something you know, something you have, something you are" all are simply different classes of authentication factor, and all are distinct from names, or UIDs, or any other bit of meta-information that isn't for authentication. Just like "something you know" can have different strengths, "something you are" can too and changes in technology and threats will enable new options alongside new attacks as we go along. It's a process.
- djsumdog 7y agoI've only heard the "something you know" and "Something you have" from my old graduate level security class. This is the first I've heard of "something you ARE" and I like this distinction. It makes sense. Not only can "something you are" change (in some instances), it can also be something that can be difficult for technology to not recognize correctly. A username or password must be correct (unless you're Facebook and do that goofy thing where you allow both the upper and lower case versions) but a biometric is more fudgable.
- xoa 7y ago>I've only heard the "something you know" and "Something you have" from my old graduate level security class. This is the first I've heard of "something you ARE" and I like this distinction. It makes sense. I'm somewhat surprised because it's definitely not new, I don't know what the exact genesis of that particular cryptographer's verse is but my vague recollection is I first heard it the late 90s, and the idea of extracting bits showing identity from physical qualities unique to a person certainly dates back a long ways. "Something you are" can cover a lot of possibilities too, and with vastly more variety and subtlety than I think a lot of people consider even in security fields. For example, there was recently a genuinely very interesting idea of measuring bottoms. As in, your actual behind/ass, via sensors in chairs. It should be unsurprising if you consider it, but of course the patterns of musculature/fat/bone structure are fairly unique to you for any part of your body if you have sensitive enough tools. It's a transparent measure for certain use cases like a workstation or the like since you're sitting down anyway, and hard to clone from afar since our butts are typically covered and subdermal is challenging without near contact. Another place if you want to look for cutting edge possibilities is advertising/surveillance. Near anything used for tracking fingerprinting could in principle be used for authentication too, and again there are potentially a lot of bits of entropy to be found there. Our gaits as we walk, our patterns of typing, our micro muscle movements, all sorts of things aren't so generic to a powerful enough system. "Biometrics" is to some extent at the stage of 80s or early 90s passwords, something to keep in mind in these discussions when people complain about them. 8-character alphanumeric passwords protected by crypt aren't exactly good these days either, but auth tech moved on even as tech benefitted attackers. In the future biometrics will undoubtedly consider far more than our current early generation systems, up to and including implants. FWIW, I have (more rarely) seen a few other classes of factor suggested that do make sense, and are arguably distinct categories. One is spatiotemporal, ie., "somewhere/somewhen you are". This is used de facto by any sort of air gapping or "this system can only be accessed from this one place and console" or the like. It could though be taken advantage of far more thanks to more ubiquitous high resolution GPS and the like in our systems. Having certain kinds of data only become accessible in the right place/time could be very useful. Another fuzzier category is "something you do", as-in observing the actions you take. I felt at one point that this was merely another way of measuring "something you are", but I can see the idea that it'd be distinct because it's about revealing your direct state of mind, whereas at least for the foreseeable future "something you are" tends to focus on more bulk matter aspects of your being. Technically state of mind is physical too, there is a specific vector state of axons and neurons and firing patterns that represent it, but it might make sense still to distinguish that from physical body structure or even implants. Whatever the case though it's still an interesting consideration, and makes a lot of sense in old school counterops. Sometimes the first sign of someone who "shouldn't be authenticated to use this" has been "they were 'acting funny'" after all.
- invalidusernam3 7y agoI can read your username once and remember it. I can't do the same with a fingerprint
- jcranberry 7y agoDepends on the username. And you don't have your username written on your body.
- pennaMan 7y agoI'm sure you can produce a hash from fingerprint model data for your reading pleasure
- djsumdog 7y agoOpenSSH does that thing now where it can visually display ASCII art of your key fingerprint.
- rhizome 7y agoThat's not dispositive, you also can't dust for names.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- TheLML 7y agoModern fingerprint readers rely on the conductivity of your finger, so a cut off finger (or the finger of a dead person) can't per se unlock a phone.
- immad 7y agoA dead persons skin is still conductive.
- Laforet 7y agoThere are better ways to detect whether the finger is still attached to a live person. https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21128225-100-fingerprint-scanner-to-spot-the-living-dead/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21128225-100-fingerpr... Nevertheless it probably won't ever be completely reliable short of installing a hypodermic needle with the sensor to take a blood sample every time :)
- war1025 7y agoWas it GATTACA where the main character used a prosthetic thumb add-on to fool the blood check every day on his way in to work?
- botwriter 7y agofound this out the hard way with a paranoid ex. now I just use the 8 digit pin to login
- rpmisms 7y agoI'm slightly curious as to which of the GP's options you found out the hard way. I truly hope you still have your fingers.
- botwriter 7y agoPassed out and the ex-girlfriend used my finger on my phone to unlock it.
- kd913 7y agoWhat makes you think a ex-girlfriend wouldn't be paranoid enough to look over at an 8-digit passcode or pattern?
- rpmisms 7y agoPersonally, I don't date anyone I don't trust with my passwords, work excluded, of course. Works out pretty well for me.
- PostPost 7y agoHow do you know if you can trust someone that way without dating them in the first place? Only date people you've been friends with for several years?
- rpmisms 7y agoYes, actually.
- idoh 7y agoI'm curious about this - is there some formal unveiling of passwords as a relationship milestone? Or does it just come up naturally, like, "I need to log into your gmail account, what's your password?"
- floatinthecloud 7y agoYes
- nolok 7y agoReally depends on your threat model and what kind of access you want to prevent. Random person tries to get in (eg phone was stolen in the subway, ...): biometrics work, password works. Close person tries to get in (significant other, coworker, ...): biometrics is flawed, password works. Government respecting your rights tries to get in: biometrics is completly broken, password works. Government that don't respect your rights tries to get in: https://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/ Although in that last case, as-in the case of Government respecting your rights but the court order you to give access, password still allows you to have the ability to block/brick/wipe the phone. All of this of course is if you have a good password hygiene, but if you don't I don't think you have a claim to complain about weak security models.
- xoa 7y agoYou're correct about always having to evaluate security in terms of threat models, but you're off about a lot of your examples. >Close person tries to get in (significant other, coworker, ...): biometrics is flawed, password works. >Government respecting your rights tries to get in: biometrics is completly broken, password works. The first is fully incorrect, the second far too generalized and heavily incorrect. PINs/passwords are far, FAR more trivial to skim then biometrics. Even mere shoulder surfing isn't hard, but in a world with approaching ubiquitous hard to notice downward looking cameras if you ever input a password anywhere that isn't physically secure, and with no one looking, you can easily have it compromised. And it of course takes essentially zero resource expenditure and offers zero visibility to merely use the password once it's acquired. If it's at a random incident and a first-world type government wants to look, you can trivially disable biometrics on any decent implementation without even looking. So lack of biometrics buys you nothing. If it's a sting against you specifically then they can shoulder surf/camera it (remember the constant improvements in drones, are you REALLY not being watched well away from buildings even?) or just wait for you to unlock it and then swoop in and try to physically grab you while it's unlocked anyway. The scenario space where it'd make a difference is very, very minimal. Really, you want both: a strong password and biometrics for public usage. And for scenarios like border searches they can lawfully cause you enough inconvenience regardless that standard passcode is still not really the right response anyway. A burner, clean+remote load later, or alt-codes or the like would be the right way to go, though sadly I think only the first two are available right now. >Government that don't respect your rights tries to get in: https://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/ Possibly the dumbest xkcd ever made.
- j45 7y agoBiometrics are not secure to use for both a username and password combined. At best, biometrics are good as a username to identify who you are, but not that you consent to login. At best, todays biometrics are a trade off in security for convenience, partially because most can be faked. I look to modern banking startups for biometrics use because money and personal data are similarly valuable and sensitive. If they aren't using it, it's not secure, or ready. We are somehow ok with touch and faceid without some form of 2FA.
- TheRealSteel 7y agoWell, it's certainly harder to fraudulently use than a PIN, which can be obtained by just looking over the person's shoulder.
- deelowe 7y agoFor the initial compromise, sure, but once a biometric system is compromised, it could conceivably be compromised forever. This is what makes it a bad system for anything except identification (even then, I can imagine a few corner cases where it may be a bad idea).
- alpaca128 7y agoImho the best compromise was the lockscreen on the pre-Android Blackberry smartphones where you have to move a grid of random digits so that the right digit hovers on the right spot of a picture. Safe against onlookers, not reliant on biometrics and still quicker than entering a password. But right now I doubt the fingerprint sensors will go away soon, nothing really beats them in terms of convenience.
- tbrock 7y agoSure but this sounds like a software bug. There isn’t any way the screen protector makes the returned “ultrasounds” look like the one it’s expecting, it just confuses the reader which should result in rejected authentication. Seems sloppy.
- azinman2 7y agoA bug means that authentication can be bypassed easily? And a confused reader authenticates? That’s a total f’n failure, not just “a bug.” You only release such things after super duper thorough testing.
- pennaMan 7y agoLast time I checked the OS actively warns you that a strong password is the only way to actually secure your device. Face unlocks and fingerprint sensors are really just gimmicks, that's why android will sometimes prompt for the full password based on some heuristics.
- bdcravens 7y agoThey should disable those gimmicks and remove them from all advertising, comparison charts, etc.
- vokep 7y agogiven this, it would be nice if a standard emerged of offering biometric+password. The idea being you get both the convenience of biometric, plus the security of a password. Of course a password is inconvenient, but thats only if its a usual password. In this case you could use a simplified password which is quick to enter.
- Bud 7y agoJust because Samsung's sloppy copies of Apple's tech are sucky does not mean that the real technologies are "gimmicks".
- 7y ago
- theclaw 7y ago> In fact there are already articles showing how the unlock feature works while you’re asleep Hah, this was the first thing I tested with Face ID when I got my iphone 10. If you look at it with your eyes closed then it won't unlock. Open your eyes and it instantly unlocks. It spent about five minutes playing peek-a-boo with it.
- zaroth 7y agoActually it’s unlocking while your eyes are closed, it just re-locks really quickly the moment it senses that you are opening your eyes.
- chubbyrabbit 7y agoIf that's true it means others can unlock it as long as my eyes are closed. I'm certain that's not the case.
- saagarjha 7y agoI think the comment you replied to was a joke.
- spectramax 7y agoI got a chuckle out of it but honestly, we don't need to make this place like Reddit where serious topics were mixed with jokes and then it got so bad that its impossible to engage in a serious discussion without a [serious] tag in the headline. Vast number of places on the internet are enteraining, there is no shortage. Let's leave HN for serious discussions. Good joke though.
- mantap 7y agoJokes are OK on HN as long as they are genuinely funny. Unfunny jokes tend to get downvoted. As most 'jokes' are not legitimately funny this system works well to keep a balance. I've been here 10 years and it hasn't become like Reddit yet. Every person saying that HN will become like Reddit has been wrong so far.