3 ms·
This is a good explanation, but I'm not so sure the missing piece is so clear in the case of dark matter (and the blog post explained this nicely). Sure, dark
by raverbashing 7y ago
This is a good explanation, but I'm not so sure the missing piece is so clear in the case of dark matter (and the blog post explained this nicely).
Sure, dark matter can explain those, but what if there's some not yet imagined change to the equations that gives the same results.
Maybe gravitational attraction is not r^2 at some non-obvious scale that we failed to measure (meters? mm? Casimir effect on cosmic dust? Solar system sized gravitational anomalies?)
Why relativity makes Mercury's orbit precess is very not obvious (I mean, the two-body problem is already hard without relativity). The bending of light is a more obvious effect for example.
- Tuna-Fish 7y ago> Sure, dark matter can explain those, but what if there's some not yet imagined change to the equations that gives the same results. How do you propose for a modified equation to explain the bullet cluster? That is, we have multiple good observations that show situations where the distribution of mass differs substantially from the distribution of visible matter, and good theoretical explanations why this should happen in the case of dark matter. This is not adequately explained by modified gravitation or other such effects.
- raverbashing 7y agoDisclaimer: I do think that the Bullet Cluster is good evidence for dark matter, but we can speculate a bit One is that there's also a possibility that dark matter exists but it's only part of the story. For the Bullet Cluster I wonder how reliable the estimation of gravitational mass is for cluster of objects, as I understand, it is the images of the galaxies behind it that are lensed by mass in front of it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MACS_J0025.4-1222#/media/File:MACS_J0025.4-1222.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MACS_J0025.4-1222#/media/File:... For one heavy object in front of another, it's easy to see how lensing works and estimate masses from there. But with clusters and "fuzzier" mass distributions I'm not so sure.
- wiml 7y agoRight. A lot of "modified gravity" theories have been proposed in recent decades, investigated, and compared to observations; with work they can be made to match up. Dark-matter theories on the other hand do a somewhat better job of matching observations, which is why they have become the best-liked explanation for the galactic rotation curve puzzle. Scientists didn't just jump to dark matter at the start, and no cosmologist will tell you that dark matter is definitely the explanation — it's simply the explanation that currently seems most likely.