8 ms·
I disagree. Dark matter is form of matter (matter is any substance that has rest mass) and it's dark (implying we can't see it and don't know what it is made o
by nabla9 7y ago
I disagree.
Dark matter is form of matter (matter is any substance that has rest mass) and it's dark (implying we can't see it and don't know what it is made of). Most hypotheses around the dark matter assume it's either new kinds of particles, or macroscopic objects.
Dark energy is also good name for hypothesis for unknown form of energy.
- simonh 7y ago"Dark matter is a form of matter..." is a definitive statement, but you can't point to a single example of a direct detection of dark matter. It's quite possible the hypothesis is wrong. The article, and the OPs aren't saying we shouldn't explore these hypotheses. They're just pointing out that they are, well, hypothetical. We should be cautious of talking about these things definitively as though we know they exist.
- nabla9 7y agoHypothesis should be named correctly. If the hypothesis is it's matter, it should be called matter. Primary evidence makes it look like it's matter even before any hypothesis. Practically all hypotheses looking the evidence assume it is form of matter. Not calling it dark matter just because there is small change it would be something else would be misdirection.
- ailideex 7y ago> "Dark matter is a form of matter..." is a definitive statement, but you can't point to a single example of a direct detection of dark matter. Are these not all cases of direct detection: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter#Observational_evidence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter#Observational_evid...
- rpedela 7y agoDirect detection would be detecting/trapping the dark matter particle(s). Those observations are indirect and it may turn out that there is another explanation other than dark matter such as we are using GR equations incorrectly as suggested in the post.
- snowwrestler 7y agoWhat kind of detecting/trapping? We have to be specific. If we hypothesize a kind of matter that does not interact electromagnetically (only gravitationally), then it's kind of nonsensical to say that only direct electromagnetic interactions with such matter will count to confirm its existence.
- rpedela 7y agoWell that is the crux isn't it? How do we directly detect gravitational particles?
- snowwrestler 7y agoMaybe we don't. The evidence for general relativity is all indirect--we can't directly detect space-time. But plenty of people seem to think it's a solid theory anyway.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- simonh 7y agoThere is a significant difference in that GR made numerous very testable claims about all sorts of phenomena, which would not be at all expected without GR to explain them. It also depends what is consider direct detection, which I accept is a matter of opinion. For example I'd consider comparing the times on atomic clocks inside and outside a gravity well to be direct measurement of time dilation.
- simonh 7y agoThis is exactly why the hypothesis is weak. At the moment it postulates a particle that only ever manifests in such a way that it explains gravitational behaviour at a microscopic scale, in certain observations, and has no other detectable interactions or properties whatsoever. There’s no theory of how it forms, no theory of how it might be created or annihilated, no evidence for it in any particle physics experiments. We just have this one class of equations that produce unexpected results, so we put in an extra term and say were done. That’s just not good enough to say anything definitive about what it is. Physicists know that’s not good enough, and that it’s a major problem. I hope we do make progress, do come up with further experimental evidence or ideas for experiments we can test. For dark matter I think that’s actually likely, but I’m not so convinced about dark energy, there the evidence is a lot thinner.
- gpderetta 7y ago> Dark matter is form of matter (matter is any substance that has rest mass) There are many bosons that are massive (Z bosons for example) but are not considered matter. I think that normally fermions are considered matter. Edit: s/barion/fermion/ bah, I know nothing. Edit2: and of course gluons are not massive. super pedantic and of course IANAP.
- tremon 7y agoIt doesn't appear to be dark, but transparent, AFAIU. For an object to be "dark", it has to be actually absorbing light, and I think dark matter doesn't actually absorb it, it just doesn't interact with it (except for gravitational lensing). Or at least, that's what I've always understood. Not a physicist though.
- mapcars 7y agoI would say "dark" here is more like "unknown" than a color reference, while both obviously have a connection in how we experience.
- denton-scratch 7y ago"Unknown form of energy" is not a hypothesis. It just means "we have a problem here; we don't have a solution, so we'll just rename the problem as a hypothesis". I think it's a clever sort of cheating (and you probably have to be very good at writing cosmology papers to get away with it).
- superqd 7y agoSo, there is large quantity of matter permeating the universe with unknown properties? Doesn't that imply that our understanding, i.e., theories/models, are inconsistent with observation? All the the term 'dark matter' really implies is that there are observational anomalies caused by something that could be matter-like in its nature, but which we have not observed. It isn't necessarily at all like the matter we have observed, but could be matter-like. Or we could just be wrong in our models.