3 ms·
That sounds somewhat plausible to me because it fulfills the criterion of something that would mess up our observations of gravitational force but nothing else.
by philwelch 7y ago
That sounds somewhat plausible to me because it fulfills the criterion of something that would mess up our observations of gravitational force but nothing else. Is the n-body problem really so intractable we can't even handwave our way to an approximate answer that accounts for this stuff?
- dodobirdlord 7y agoEveryone has thought "maybe it's just a bad gravity equation?" at some point. It's a fun idea, but it's contrary to observation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster
- andbberger 7y agoOof, a gravitational lensing based result at 8 sigma... so much for this fun little theory
- heavenlyblue 7y ago>> gravitational lensing based result What's wrong with basing your results on gravitational lensing? Is it related somehow to the complexity of inferring on how much the images are wrapped by gravitational lensing?
- andbberger 7y agonothing, I'm talking about OP's theory. A gravitational lensing based result is particularly strong due to it being model independent. OP's theory cannot account for lensing inferred CoM differing from the baryonic CoM in the bullet cluster.
- jiggawatts 7y agoThis always gets trotted out, but it isn't ironclad proof of anything. Everything about the Bullet Cluster is conjecture based on secondary observations. They're not measuring "mass", they're measuring light, from which they're inferring mass. The galaxy collision is an unusual case, being at relatively high velocity, so the models may not even cover it well. They're also assuming that the majority of the mass is in the gas, not the stars or invisible brown dwarvf stars or even black holes. It's layers of assumptions a mile deep being used as irrefutable proof.
- andbberger 7y agoI'm not sure what you mean. The n-body problem has no analytical solution in general. You have to simulate. The author is suggesting that assumptions you make (such as representing the earth moon system as a point mass at their CoM) in order to make simulation feasible might lead to a catastrophic divergence from reality over time. This is all a consequence of n-body dynamics being chaotic [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory
- philwelch 7y agoI don't know a lot about physics, but I do know a little bit about computer science, and it seems to me that--barring some crazy breakthrough in computation--any simulation accurate enough to overcome the chaotic nature of this problem may very well be fundamentally impossible. That in itself would be a pretty fascinating result.
- andbberger 7y agoThe problem isn't the fidelity of the simulation persay, it's that chaotic systems are quite literally infinitely sensitive to initial conditions.
- philwelch 7y agoSure; the possible result that the physical universe is fundamentally uncomputable is the result I find interesting.
- andbberger 7y agoThat is _not_ the result though. This has nothing to do with computability. It's about the behavior of a certain pervasive class of dynamical systems.
- philwelch 7y agoOkay, I’m missing something then.
- sanxiyn 7y agoN-body we can do, for example Illustris Project. To address the concern of this post, one would need non-linear general relativity simulation. That's more challenging.