15 ms·
“You had a raging climate of eugenics which did not directly target preemies, but did directly target children who had severe disabilities. It was an environmen
by Animats 7y ago
“You had a raging climate of eugenics which did not directly target preemies, but did directly target children who had severe disabilities. It was an environment where we only wanted to produce the fittest babies. That was a very strong cultural undercurrent. People just felt like these children were not worth saving.”
Yes, the US used to have quality control on people. Ellis Island was a quality control checkpoint for immigrants. The sick were rejected and sent back where they came from.
- Alex3917 7y ago> The sick were rejected and sent back where they came from. Only if they were also poor. First class passengers on the boats didn’t go through medical screening.
- ltbarcly3 7y agoThat's probably because of injustice, it goes without saying that people who lived 'back then' didn't have functional brains and they were all racist automatons. Most steerage passengers spent about 3 hours being screened at Ellis Island, and most of that was waiting in line. This is not dramatically worse than a typical wait at customs at any international airport at a peak hour. To this day they still let First Class passengers off the airplane first so they get to be the first in line at customs.
- isostatic 7y ago> To this day they still let First Class passengers off the airplane first so they get to be the first in line at customs. Doesn't really help at large airports as that just means you're first in the queue behind the previous 5 planes. Some airports do have a faster immigration line for first/business passengers though. I don't recall any in the U.S, but Heathrow does for example.
- zerr 7y agoIsn't it the same nowadays? And for many countries in general.
- Rapzid 7y agoIt's the same but even more stringent due to modern medicine. Good luck immigrating into a country with universal health care if you have any number of chronic conditions..
- arcticbull 7y agoUsually once residency is granted in a place that has socialized medicine, there's a waiting period during which you're responsible for your own care.
- Mathnerd314 7y agoCanada and New Zealand have entry visa requirements that there not be an undue burden on the health care system, with cost thresholds around $20,000 CAD and $41,000 NZD.
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoIIRC, for Canada, it depends on why you are there. There are exceptions for spouses, for example. It seems a lot of countries view family immigration a bit differently.
- hef19898 7y agoNo guarantees, but in Germany as long as you are registered (resident from an other EU country, refugee, asylum seeker) as opposed to a tourist you are covered. Access to health care is, unfortunately, a different story for people in refugee centers. But you are covered. No strings attached. There is no way to be a legal resident without public heath insurance here. Which route you choose, public insurance, public as part of your spouse, private is up to you. If you cannot afford it because you are, say, unemployed the state covers the costs for the public model. Also worth noting, the public model doesn't exclude pre-existing conditions which can make private solutions prohibitively expensive.
- opwieurposiu 7y agoYou have left the meat of your position unstated. Are you arguing that states should admit all applicants, regardless of the threat to public health(ebola, smallpox etc)?
- arcticbull 7y agoCurrently the test is primarily for Tuberculosis (I-693). Once you arrive you are still responsible for your own healthcare costs because America doesn't have socialized medicine. Further, no medical exams are required for tourist visas, and many folks such as myself have lived in America for almost a decade, and still have to submit to asinine medical examinations. If I had Ebola everyone around me would have died many times over in the literally ten years I've lived here without an immigration-type medical exam.
- ekianjo 7y agoEbola is not transmitted as easily as you seem to believe. It is much less contagious than many other disease, but it is a lot more deadly once contracted.
- paulmd 7y agoebola is much less dangerous than 5 years ago now that medical protocols and vaccines/post-exposure prophylaxis have been established
- User23 7y agoThe USA has a socialized healthcare system, it's called Medicaid and expanding it was a big part of the Affordable Care Act. In some states, such as California, Medi-Cal (the state's name for Medicaid) is fully available to legal immigrants and practically fully available to illegal aliens as well, the latter just have to use the emergency department rather than schedule a physician's appointment. Our system does however assume that highly capable persons such as yourself are able to not only able to afford medical care, but also to pay for the socialized programs for those who can't.
- cdev_gl 7y agoI'm always impressed by the way a simple turn of phrase can hide disproportionate impact on human lives. Specifically interesting in this context is that the turn of the 20th century, and the 1920s in particular, is really the birth place of modern immigration policy. Of note is the fact that the requirement of visas for entry and quotas on point of origin appeared around this time- if you read newspaper op-eds for the immigration act of 1924 (or the earlier chinese exclusion act), these measures are specifically pointed out as a way to maintain the racial makeup of the country. Prior to that point, visitors could just turn up at Ellis island for entry. Afterwards, the island itself served more as an offshore detention center for what were then classified as radicals, anarchists, and those "likely to become a public charge"— awaiting deportation. Citizenship, too, could once be had for as little as the price of a dozen eggs-- check out this booklet published 1921: https://archive.org/details/howtotakeoutyour00metrrich/page/5 https://archive.org/details/howtotakeoutyour00metrrich/page/... "All it costs is $1, not a penny more. No witnesses, no examination, no pull required." -- 2 years of residence later, another set of papers (also on Archive.org) and a short literacy test (added in 1917) and you could be a citizen-- but this rapidly changed as additional quotas and restrictions were added. The history of immigration law is a fascinating topic, and there's a lot of interesting primary sources available.
- teraflop 7y agoThat booklet is fascinating reading. It's a little bit wild to see these on opposite sides of the same sheet of paper: > The true American believes in Liberty, Equality, Justice, Humanity. [...] The true American believes that "All men are created free and equal." [...] The true American believes in his own ability, but holds that the other fellow is as good as he and should have the same chance to life and happiness. He believes in equality of opportunity. > Persons not belonging to the White or Black Race, Anarchists, Polygamists, Criminals, Insane, cannot become Citizens; they will not get First Papers.
- ido 7y agoAnd also that Africans were considered more desirable immigrants than Asians!
- 77pt77 7y agoThis still exists. To get a green card for example you need to undergo an exhaustive medical exam and can be rejected due to the results.
- QualityReboot 7y agoYeah but it's mostly about immunizations. You can still immigrate if you're disabled but have a caretaker.
- nsomaru 7y agoWhat’s that, about the top 1% of disabled people?
- isoskeles 7y agoIndeed, what should we do about the other 99%?
- lazyasciiart 7y agoNo - if you are considered likely to become dependant on state or federal aid you can be denied. https://www.uscis.gov/greencard/public-charge https://www.uscis.gov/greencard/public-charge
- aaron695 7y ago> Yes, the US used to have quality control on people. Ellis Island This is misleading at best. Today more are rejected around the world in level 4 income countries for sickness than then. "Between 1892 and 1924, the percentage of immigrants rejected for a medical condition, including psychiatric, chronic as well as infectious diseases, was miniscule, less than 1 percent." https://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/october-15-1965-remembering-ellis-island https://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/october-15-1965-remember...
- throwaway744678 7y agoFor a bit of perspective, it seems about 2% of immigrants were rejected [1]. I believe most sick people were quarantined, then admitted on the territory. [1] https://www.history.com/news/9-things-you-may-not-know-about-ellis-island https://www.history.com/news/9-things-you-may-not-know-about...
- qaq 7y agoIt still does health exam for Green Card still works like that +/-
- refurb 7y agoWe still do that. People looking to get a green card need a medical exam. Certain conditions will disqualify you from immigrating although those have been scaled back. Other countries do it too, but also for financial reasons. Canada will disqualify people from immigrating if they will put an undue burden on the healthcare system.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]