4 ms·
Yeah, maybe. The thing is, there are a lot of independent observations that match up really really well with the hypothesis, "there's a bunch of matter around t
by philwelch 7y ago
Yeah, maybe. The thing is, there are a lot of independent observations that match up really really well with the hypothesis, "there's a bunch of matter around that only interacts with us via gravity". If our models are off, they would have to be off in exactly the right way to affect our observations of gravitational forces but not really anything else. Which may very well be the case--or it may be the case that baryonic matter isn't really the end-all be-all of the universe and we're just a bunch of baryonic chauvinists for thinking so because that's what we're made of ;)
Obviously, nobody knows for sure yet. But I would caution most fellow laymen not to rely too heavily on the intuition that says, "dark matter? pffft!" or even, "but what about all of those observations that didn't match Newtonian dynamics?". Physicists (including the author here!) are generally smart enough to have thought of those objections themselves, which is why they've spent decades trying really hard to disprove the notion of "dark matter" by compiling all of these anomalous observations. Sometimes the universe is just unintuitive, at least to dumb apes like us.
I'm not saying you can't have a hunch that we're just doing the math wrong somehow; I just wouldn't be overly confident that's the case just yet.
- fdsa_1234_999 7y ago> Physicists (including the author here!) are generally smart enough to have thought of those objections themselves Yet we're no closer to a satisfactory answer. It's not that physics has some unresolved problems, it's that physics has a giant hole through its center. Einstein got us closer than Newton, but his work is obviously incomplete. The dogma surrounding Einstein's work borders on religion. But muh experiments! How many times have Newtonian mechanics been proven? Lots and lots. And at one frame of reference (pun not intended) it's absolutely correct. How is Einstein's work any different? It's not. Stop pretending only a chosen few can have meaningful ideas about how the universe works. You might need training to translate that idea into a workable theory, but not to generate the ideas themselves. If I were you (collectively) I'd be taking ideas from everywhere. It's still your job to see if they make sense, so don't worry about the unwashed masses stealing your thunder.
- Ma8ee 7y ago“Match up really really well” is not that impressive if you consider that you deduce the distribution of the dark matter from the observations. So it just means that in most cases you can find a distribution of in all other ways unobserved matter that explains your observation. That leaves you quite many degrees of freedom to play with.
- gmueckl 7y agoNot exactly. Independent experiments that check completely different things find the same total distributions of masss and energy. So the mass-like and energy-like deviations from the observed mass and energy are always pretty much consistent.
- Ma8ee 7y agoThey all observe the effects of gravitation, don't they? Whether it is deviations in lensing or the velocity and density distribution or visible matter, they all seem to have the same source, but it doesn't say anything more about the nature of the source of the deviation.
- ymolodtsov 7y agoBut we also see galaxies whose gravity is much weaker than we’d anticipate based on the objects we can see, impying they have less dark matter.
- Ma8ee 7y agoAre you saying that we observe galaxies whose gravity is weaker than we anticipated from the visible mass? Then that would be very interesting news to me, and something that you can't explain with dark matter. If you are saying that we observe galaxies whose gravity is weaker than your models for the distribution of dark matter, then that is an argument against your models, not for them.
- 7y ago
- slowmovintarget 7y agoIt isn't a hunch, though. Physicists have known since the 1930s that the math is wrong because they are using averages in non-linear equations. The problem is that no one knows how wrong.
- lonelappde 7y agoI think you misread. Sabine is arguing that maybe dark matter is just the error term in our approximations of real matter, and pointing out that no one yet has actually taken the time to disprove that Occam's Razor theory.
- philwelch 7y agoI wouldn't presume to argue against her, because she's a physicist and I'm not. I'm mostly making the case to the peanut gallery here to maintain a state of epistemic noncommittal. It's a very popular intuition to think that "dark matter" is just a weird consequence of modeling things improperly, kind of like how we used to think there was another planet between Mercury and the sun because that was the only way to make Mercury's orbit consistent with Newtonian dynamics. If we are modeling things improperly, I suspect it would have to be a pretty weird bug--and I think the one she's suggesting qualifies as such.
- mirimir 7y agoYes, and she says it quite clearly: > Now, what we do when we want to explain what a galaxy does, or a galaxy cluster, or even the whole universe, is not to plug the matter and energy of every single planet and star into the equations. This would be computationally unfeasible. Instead, we use an average of matter and energy, and use that as the source for gravity. > Needless to say, taking an average on one side of the equation requires that you also take an average on the other side. But since the gravitational part is non-linear, this will not give you the same equations that we use for the solar system: The average of a function of a variable is not the same as the function of the average of the variable. We know it’s not. But whenever we use general relativity on large scales, we assume that this is the case. > So, we know that strictly speaking the equations we use are wrong. The big question is, then, just how wrong are they? [emphasis added] It's not a "hunch". It's just how the math works. average of 0-9 = 4.5 4.5^2 = 20.25 average of squares of 0-9 = 28.5
- andbberger 7y agoThanks for this, that is the best summary I have seen yet in this thread.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Certhas 7y agoHossenfelder is refering to the ongoing discussion in the physicist community on this topic. Some of the giants of the field (Wald, Ellis) semi-regularly exchange papers on this. It's not a hunch. Green and Wald tried to proof that the inhomogeneities don't matter, others disagree that they proofed anything of the sort. It's a fairly robust debate, and I am not qualified to summarize the state of play. Here are some slides: https://cosmoback.sciencesconf.org/data/program/Ostrowski.pdf https://cosmoback.sciencesconf.org/data/program/Ostrowski.pd... Edit: The rebuttal paper to Green-Wald from three years ago already has 100 citations... https://arxiv.org/abs/1505.07800 https://arxiv.org/abs/1505.07800 It's possible that the question will be settled in the next years through numerical simulations: https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.116.251302 https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.11... Edit 2: All of this is for dark energy, for dark matter I don't know if there is a similar discussion on the role of the post-newtonian approximation that is used there.