3 ms·
> Wasteful compared to what though? How much energy, human capital, and resources are consumed by the banking industry? The article actually answers this to so
by dragontamer 7y ago
> Wasteful compared to what though? How much energy, human capital, and resources are consumed by the banking industry?
The article actually answers this to some degree. See the following graphic: https://i.imgur.com/8TdKevG.png https://i.imgur.com/8TdKevG.png
- WillPostForFood 7y agoHow much energy to mine an ounce of gold?
- easymodex 7y agoWhy is this getting downvoted, I'm curious as well.
- dragontamer 7y agoI don't think any modern currency is really using Gold these days. The cost of creating dollars is basically the cost of the Fed signing a few papers. A lot of modern currency is fully virtual. So I don't think "mining gold" is an appropriate analogy. EDIT: Case in point: how much did it cost for Visa + Bank to increase a credit-card from $500 credit limit to $2000 credit limit? $1500 of credit appeared out of thin air.
- cwkoss 7y agoI think your Edit example actually points to the root of the issue with these comparisons. The first credit limit increase "from scratch" costs hundreds of billions of dollars in creating a system of legal compliance, accounting, communication, internal and external risk management, executive compensation, regulatory oversight, credit ratings, cybersecurity, salaries of millions of workers, building public trust in the credit system, writing and passing legislation, even Fed responsibility of building and maintaining a fiat currency. The second credit limit increase once this system exists is essentially free. To what extent do these costs need to be accounted for in creating an accurately comparable 'per transaction' metric? By replacing much of the logic with 'just math', Bitcoin has the potential for a much higher theoretical efficiency than the current banking system. Whether market penetration will ever reach the current banking systems levels - and function without replicating these same structures - is certainly highly debatable and for many of the above items implausible. Bitcoin transactions in isolation are also essentially free - it's the maintenance of the system which keeps it secure and trustworthy that is expensive.
- jayd16 7y agoThis is a different metric akin to mining a bitcoin. Making a transaction with gold can be carbon neutral, it would seem to me.
- ctdonath 7y agoThis is a good relevant question. Both are easily verified, impossible to duplicate, convenient value density, and (!) production correlates to increase of total world economic value. As such, the question is interesting: how much energy required to produce one new ounce of gold? vs one bitcoin?
- jcranmer 7y agoSince gold bullion isn't legal currency anywhere, I'm not sure it's the most relevant comparison. From the US Mint's financial statement [1]: 2017 cost $13.5 million dollars in "Communications, utilities, and misc charges", which presumably is the bucket that electricity bills falls under. There's no breakdown of overhead between currency coinage production and bullion/numismatic production, but the manufacturing obligation suggests that currency is roughly ⅕ of their total costs, which suggests that we might ascribe about $3 million in utility cost to produce coinage. The coins themselves were worth about $870 million, which suggests about 250 kJ (or 0.07 kWh) per $1 of coinage if we assume the Mint pays $0.05/kWh. I'm not including the energy cost of metal production itself, because I don't want to spend the time to track down that information. [1] https://www.treasury.gov/about/budget-performance/CJ19/23.%20US%20Mint%20FY%202019%20CJ.pdf https://www.treasury.gov/about/budget-performance/CJ19/23.%2...
- Erlich_Bachman 7y ago> Since gold bullion isn't legal currency anywhere Neither is Bitcoin, so it should be a perfectly valid comparison?
- aeternum 7y agoAs others have commented, per-transaction is a very misleading metric. Hashing difficulty is based on the number of other miners and time between blocks, not based on the number of transactions. With something like lightning network, a single Bitcoin transaction can facilitate millions of 'lightning' transactions.
- dragontamer 7y ago> As others have commented, per-transaction is a very misleading metric. Can you name a better metric that we can measure?
- baddox 7y agoWell, what do you actually care about? Why choose, for instance, cost per transaction instead of, say, cost per USD (or equivalent) transferred?
- dragontamer 7y agoI like cost of electricity. While Chinese plants are subsidizing the BTC network right now, we can estimate the cost of "unsubsidized" BTC in the future based off of electricity costs today. -------- With regard to the Lightning Network, it seems that it requires a bit of supervision to be secure. https://themoneymongers.com/lightning-network-watchtowers/ https://themoneymongers.com/lightning-network-watchtowers/ That supervision probably will have a cost of some kind. > You can hire watchtowers nodes for a fee and design the revocation transaction in such a way that the watchtowers will also receive their service fee when you get funds of the other party as a penalty. So we're adding many, many more middlemen to the picture. Not only do we have to pay for the final transaction (which requires a large amount of electricity to be "mined" into the blockchain), we have to hire watchtowers to ensure that our Lightning Network transactions remain correct even if our counterparty tries to screw with our transaction history. (Remember: the full transaction history in the Lightning network is off-chain).
- 7y ago