3 ms·
So a few different things are going on. Statistics tell one thing. And if we’re reasonable we can reduce unnecessary deaths. Then besides ordinary reason we
by mc32 7y ago
So a few different things are going on.
Statistics tell one thing. And if we’re reasonable we can reduce unnecessary deaths.
Then besides ordinary reason we have hot-button and politicization and polarization issues. If mr O’Rourke were to say, mass shooters and supremacists are statistically unrewarding lines of attack, people would drop support en masse. People would accuse him of being a supremacist himself and someone who doesn’t care about victims of mass shooters.
And then there is the reality of the second amendment and confiscation.
That said, reasonable people can agree in screening people better and discriminating against certain anti social behaviors, etc.
- rayiner 7y ago> That said, reasonable people can agree in screening people better and discriminating against certain anti social behaviors, etc. Yes, but the concern is the unreasonable people. O’Rourke basically blew away the “reasonable compromise” position by making clear (at least in the eyes of second amendment advocates) that there is an end goal, that end goal is confiscation, and that any compromise is just one step toward that end goal.
- mc32 7y agoThat’s true. He was given ample opportunity last night to nuance or walk back his strong response but instead doubled down and insisted he’d basically “make” people turn them in. Pretty much alluding to being ok with having standoffs and shootouts Elliot Ness style, which will not convince any moderates.
- taborj 7y agoIncidentally, it's this exact type of situation that caused the founding fathers to include the second amendment in the first place. "On April 14, 1775, Gage received instructions from Secretary of State William Legge, Earl of Dartmouth, to disarm the rebels..."[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battles_of_Lexington_and_Concord#British_government_preparations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battles_of_Lexington_and_Conco...
- DuskStar 7y agoFor the gun rights people, O'Rourke is just stating what everyone already knew. To illustrate this, there's a lovely 'cake' meme [0] (available in both cartoon and text form!) about how much gun rights have already been eaten away, and every one was sold as a compromise already. At some point, "this is a compromise because it means you get to keep any rights at all" stops being acceptable. (The link itself is from 2017, but the text is from 2010) > Allow me to explain. > I hear a lot about "compromise" from your camp ... except, it's not compromise. > Let's say I have this cake. It is a very nice cake, with "GUN RIGHTS" written across the top in lovely floral icing. Along you come and say, "Give me that cake." > I say, "No, it's my cake." > You say, "Let's compromise. Give me half." I respond by asking what I get out of this compromise, and you reply that I get to keep half of my cake. > Okay, we compromise. Let us call this compromise The National Firearms Act of 1934. > There I am with my half of the cake, and you walk back up and say, "Give me that cake." > I say, "No, it's my cake." > You say, "Let's compromise." What do I get out of this compromise? Why, I get to keep half of what's left of the cake I already own. > So, we have your compromise -- let us call this one the Gun Control Act of 1968 -- and I'm left holding what is now just a quarter of my cake. > And I'm sitting in the corner with my quarter piece of cake, and here you come again. You want my cake. Again. > This time you take several bites -- we'll call this compromise the Clinton Executive Orders -- and I'm left with about a tenth of what has always been MY DAMN CAKE and you've got nine-tenths of it. > Then we compromised with the Lautenberg Act (nibble, nibble), the HUD/Smith and Wesson agreement (nibble, nibble), the Brady Law (NOM NOM NOM), the School Safety and Law Enforcement Improvement Act (sweet tap-dancing Freyja, my finger!) > I'm left holding crumbs of what was once a large and satisfying cake, and you're standing there with most of MY CAKE, making anime eyes and whining about being "reasonable", and wondering "why we won't compromise". > I'm done with being reasonable, and I'm done with compromise. Nothing about gun control in this country has ever been "reasonable" nor a genuine "compromise". > LawDog 0: https://thelawdogfiles.blogspot.com/2017/10/gun-rights-cake-analogy.html https://thelawdogfiles.blogspot.com/2017/10/gun-rights-cake-...