5 ms·
Not all cities can ban cars at this point for multiple reasons. I live for several years in a medium sized wealthy Western European city that's clogged with tr
by ChuckNorris89 7y ago
Not all cities can ban cars at this point for multiple reasons.
I live for several years in a medium sized wealthy Western European city that's clogged with traffic. Why?
Well, rich Europeans don't like living in cities with tall ugly blocks a so they grow outwards by developing cozy low density suburbs.
1) This suburban expansion was possible due to the cheap automobiles that permitted pretty much everyone to move outside of the cities and away from their jobs, where they could find properties they could afford, outside of the coverage of the rail network. It's almost impossible now, when everyone outside of the city is dependent on their cars to get to work/supermarket/city, to get them to leave their cars without first implementing a massive public transport network that would be too expensive to run profitably so it's much cheaper for the cities to just let people have their cars as they're the ones bearing the cost instead of the city.
2) It's also heavily political. The party that so much as dares to touch drivers and their cars will commit political suicide. Especially since my city is wealthy due to the extensive automotive industry nearby (R&D and manufacturing). Whenever politicians here propose less cars on the road, the auto industry threatens with lost jobs and jobs are way more important for a politician's career than people in the city dying prematurely of air pollution. And not to mention all the dealerships and service centers that contribute to political campaigns and public events especially in smaller cities.
I'd love to see cars banned from this beautiful city, but seeing how culturally attached the locals are to their cars and suburban lifestyle, I'm afraid it's just a pipe dream at this point.
- jacquesm 7y agoIf Bogota can do it then rich European cities can do it. Think of it this way: whatever the cost to society of cheap and plentiful public transport it will be a small fraction of the cost of car based transportation. Parking, the cost of producing and maintaining the vehicles themselves, the pollution , the accidents, it all really adds up.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoSorry, but there's no way you can convince Herr Schmidt who lives in the suburbs and just bought a 80.000 Euro Mercedes to take the bus to the city. At least the inner city center is car free on some shopping streets so we got that.
- pwinnski 7y agoGenerally it start with charging a high daily congestion fee to drive into the city center. From there you expand the area. An 80k car that costs another 2-3k per year to drive into the city center, and maybe another 2-3k per year to park, at some point most people find it worthwhile to save the car for driving outside the city center.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoCan't do that. The low and middle class here are also dependent on their banged up hatckbacks to get to work as they live very far from their jobs. If you make parking super expensive it's gonna hurt the Volkswagen man first and way harder than the Mercedes man.
- pwinnski 7y agoCan't do what other cities have already done? How did those other cities do it, then? If parking starts to carry its cost, rather than being subsidized by government regulation, then it quite likely becomes more economical to rely on mass transit than banged-up hatchbacks. But yes, changing from horribly-designed cities spread out over vast areas that depend on cars to navigate to human-oriented cities with effective mass transit is a huge project, and would require thinking about solutions that take into account the currently-hidden costs of the current designs.
- adrianN 7y agoCities change on decades long timelines. That's enough time for people to adjust.
- bluGill 7y agoBut Herr Schmidt lives next to a more frugal neighbor who doesn't car about the nice car and will take transit, currently the neighbor is driving a Toyota or some such practical car and wouldn't care in the least if he didn't have to drive again.
- bjourne 7y ago
- vinceguidry 7y agoWhat exactly did Bogota do? Was pretty car-heavy last two times I was there.
- jacquesm 7y agoThis: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TransMilenio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TransMilenio Every two to five minutes a bus.
- vinceguidry 7y agoTransMilenio is definitely a nice system, but they built it because they felt it would be cheaper than a traditional metro system, like Medellin's. I definitely preferred Medellin's system over TM. But TM is definitely novel.
- jacquesm 7y agoTM cost a very small fraction of what a metro system would have cost, it is not that they 'felt' that way, it simply is like that. They also did it pretty quickly and are expanding all over the city. What drawbacks there are are mostly due to its success, overcrowding and so on. It's also not the safest place, but it being Colombia that not exactly news. Still, something like the TM would work just fine in many West European and American cities.
- bkor 7y agoSome of the most highly paid people at my office take public transport. This despite having their "VIP" parking place, living in suburbs, etc. Your example seems to be pretty unique in that it's really close to car industry. Some of your assumptions are completely off though. In Netherlands our Prime minister takes a bicycle to work. He has way more influence than the top paid people in my office. If you look at the history in The Netherlands it wasn't always a bicycle friendly country. Even in the last 10 years there's been many changes to make things different. For e.g. Utrecht a lot of work only happened in the last 2 years, see e.g. https://vimeo.com/344373585 https://vimeo.com/344373585. Other changes are to reduce the speed for cars. Basically: road near a lot of other houses? 30km/h, then 50km/h for inner city roads. Outside of the city 80km/h. Safer for pedestrians, nicer for the people living there (the road is way less dangerous), plus immediately makes some alternative forms of transport a better alternative.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoI understand your point but countries like The Netherlands and Denmark are totally different animals. They build their bike infrastructure for decades and never adopted a car culture. The rest of mainland Europe is totally different. Getting people now to bike everywhere isn't easy when all the jobs and homes have been built around driving distances for decades.
- magduf 7y ago> The Netherlands and Denmark are totally different animals. They build their bike infrastructure for decades and never adopted a car culture. That's not true at all; Netherlands was more of a car culture several decades ago, and had to work at bringing cycling back.