4 ms·
Set and setting. The drug just rattles your cage. I quoted Leary on 'set and setting' the other day on an LSD history thread and mentioned Leonard Orr used to
by carapace 7y ago
Set and setting. The drug just rattles your cage.
I quoted Leary on 'set and setting' the other day on an LSD history thread and mentioned Leonard Orr used to get great results with nothing more exotic than oxygen, so rather than repeat that ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21264919 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21264919 ) I'll say this:
If you have a modality of therapy that works, it will work without the drug (which, at best, serves as an amplifier and a "convincer".)
If you don't have a modality of therapy that works reliably, then it's irresponsible to add drugs and hope for the best. You're banging on the side of the box hoping to reseat the vacuum tubes.
The "convincer" effect can be achieved without drugs. Not to be too mysterious but I mean hypnosis. You can e.g. quit smoking using hypnosis. It's not even hard.
I'm not against drugs per se I'm just against using them in therapy. It's irresponsible. It's like advocating zeppelins over bikes for personal transport.
(I'm great friends with Mushroom, and a little 'shroom tea can be great fun. But cramming 'im into a wee lil pill and then claiming "quit smoking" magic is in it... That's bad science and lousy magick.)
- Matticus_Rex 7y agoExcept initial trials of MDMA, LSD, and psilocybin in combination with guided therapy show outcomes that the therapy alone just isn't getting.
- edoo 7y agoAnd if they work it is a whole lot safer than taking symptom management medication.
- carapace 7y agoI never said that drugs don't work. I said they do work as amplifiers and "convincers". Combined with a good set and setting lots of people, myself included, have had "good trips" that include mental emotional and spiritual healing. My concern is when people get confused and think that the "magic" is in the mushroom.
- bromuro 7y agoSure! The olotrophic breathwork developed by Grof for example is a great substitute to LSD therapy.
- monktastic1 7y agoIf hypnosis is so effective for quitting smoking, how do you explain that studies fail to find much effect? E.g., this 2019 meta-analysis: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31198991 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31198991 From the conclusion: "If a benefit is present, current evidence suggests the benefit is small at most." The effect size and certainty with mushrooms seem much greater.
- carapace 7y agoYeah, I have no idea what those folks were doing. I know I can get the result because I did, back in the day. I'm not a licensed hypnotherapist but I went through an exploratory phase in my 20's which included experimentation with hypnosis. It was easy to develop "profound" hypnotic phenomenon like arm catalepsy (your arm is basically asleep, if you feel it with your other hand it feels like someone else's arm, etc.) I don't know what to tell you. I actually only ever tried smoking cessation once, at a party, to demonstrate hypnosis. A friend of a friend went from two packs a day to two cigarettes a day, and a month later she was still barely smoking. YMMV. Oh man! I just remembered what happened: I went into an online quit-smoking chatroom and offered to help people quit and they tore me a new one. People were howling for my blood! That's why I never went into business as a therapist. (That and I'm kind of an anti-social curmudgeon.)
- tudelo 7y agoYou seem to have a supreme self confidence that most people do not. So you think that you 'hypnotized' the person to gradually stop smoking over a month from a sort session? You have some 'magical' powers. Sorry for the skepticism...
- carapace 7y ago> You seem to have a supreme self confidence that most people do not. Only in certain areas. > So you think that you 'hypnotized' the person to gradually stop smoking over a month from a sort session? No. The change in rate of smoking (2 packs a day to 2 cigs a day) was immediate and durable (at least up to a month, I didn't talk to her again beyond that.) Interestingly, at the very end of the session there was a momentary unconscious movement of the hand in a holding-cigarette gesture. I think the reason that she didn't stop smoking entirely was somehow connected to that gesture, FWIW. > You have some 'magical' powers. Maybe..? Certainly, to myself I seem nondescript. > Sorry for the skepticism... It's fine. You're nicer than most. I sometimes think I should write an autobiography, but then I think, who would believe it?
- anon192831 7y agoIt's not just hitting the vacuum tube. If one just trips for the sake of tripping, then there is not much to be gained except for several hours of happy serotonin hits in the brain. However, what we know about psychs is that there is a huge release of BDNF (brain derived neurotrophic factor) and a shutdown of the DMN. The BDNF enables a ton of new neural connections to be built. It's like you have about 6-8 hours of a period where your brain plasticity goes back to that of an infant, just absorbing everything. So in this accelerated learning state, it's possible to work through one's emotions. So it makes sense to prepare for several weeks to receive therapy and to outline goals and memories to revisit to process them during this heightened period. Then when the drug wears off, you're still left with the new neural connectivity and perspectives and the other benefits that were derived from the session. Rather than hitting the vacuum tube, this is more like re-running the radio scanner in your car to find radio stations when you've moved over to a new city and the old radio stations are now out of range while one isn't tuned to the current set of radio stations.
- cc81 7y ago>If one just trips for the sake of tripping, then there is not much to be gained except for several hours of happy serotonin hits in the brain. Which is perfectly ok and probably preferable for most who waste trips by thinking that you must think deep and just get uncomfortable. And while obviously there are results where people make large changes my own experience about those people is that a lot of insights are like New Years Eves resolutions said when drunk and happy; the change or insight goes away when a short time has passed.
- carapace 7y ago> So it makes sense to prepare for several weeks to receive therapy and to outline goals and memories to revisit to process them during this heightened period. Then when the drug wears off, you're still left with the new neural connectivity and perspectives and the other benefits that were derived from the session. The you're describing sounds great. All I'm saying is, a sweat lodge (for example) can take the place of the drug. The "magic" is in the "set and setting" not the pill.
- 7y ago
- taurath 7y ago> I'm not against drugs per se I'm just against using them in therapy. It's irresponsible. I think it’s appropriate to try something else when you’ve tried therapy, support groups, etc. Sometimes the best thing one needs especially when they’ve been focused on changing their mind and habits for a long while is something to open up all the calcified pathways.
- carapace 7y agoYes, absolutely. If you have exhausted the better options, get high.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dwaltrip 7y agoThat's a lot of words without much analysis. Can you please explain precisely how these studies are bad science?
- carapace 7y agoIt would take too long to do the subject justice, but I'll try to sketch it: The idea that psilocybin "cures" smoking addiction is like the "Virtus dormitiua" > I am asked by the learned doctor the cause and reason why opium causes sleep. To which I reply, because it has a dormitive property, whose nature is to lull the senses to sleep. We have no idea why magic mushroom do what they do, nor any solid scientific idea of how they do what they do. The best we can say is, "By breaking down those networks, there's a chance they won't re-form." and "It seemed to work..." A neuroscientist friend of mine likes to say, "Psychiatry is not a branch of medicine." This still isn't it. For example: at any point were the subjects of the study given a blood test?
- dwaltrip 7y agoNot fully understanding the mechanisms doesn't mean we shouldn't use it. If that was the case, anaesthesia should have already been abandoned quite emphatically. Of course, caution is certainly warranted with such powerful tools, especially as we try to understand them better. But if they are effective and can be used safely in the right context, then we should use them. And we have indications that this is the case. So we must proceed carefully forward. I'm so glad that the multi-decade blockade on research is finally lifting.
- AnthonBerg 7y agoIn MAPS’ completed Phase 2 trials with 107 participants, 61% no longer qualified for PTSD after three sessions of MDMA-assisted psychotherapy two months following treatment. At the 12-month follow-up, 68% no longer had PTSD. All participants had chronic, treatment-resistant PTSD, and had suffered from PTSD for an average of 17.8 years. https://maps.org/research/mdma/ptsd/phase3 https://maps.org/research/mdma/ptsd/phase3 Drugs used in therapy can resolve decades of treatment-resistant PTSD. Would you reconsider your position against drugs in therapy? Would you be willing to look at the scientific results? Would you take a chance on closing your eyes momentarily to the word "drug"? This is therapy. Therapy is scientific results applied to the betterment of mankind. To me, it would be deeply unethical to stop or ignore this work. I've actually seen the results of "street therapy" for PTSD using MDMA by responsible adults. It was ... staggering. It's hard to express the boundless privilege of seeing PTSD melt off a person you love in an evening. And stay gone. Treatment-resistant PTSD. Decades of it. Gone. Because a substance was ingested. After endless therapy and doing all the right things. Sure, therapy worked. Glacially. There was constant pain. Constant anxiety. Gone. Just like in the studies. Rigorous, careful studies, taking decades of careful preparation in all spheres, political and medical. But the anecdote doesn't matter. We have the studies.
- carapace 7y agoI'm not an anti-drug puritan. (That would be so so hypocritical.) I think the criminalization of e.g. MDMA and the others is deeply foolish and has done a lot of harm. (To make an understatement. Frankly, I think you should be able to get clean liquid acid or MDMA at the local pharmacy. Why not? "Who the fuck are you to tell me what to do with my brain chemistry if I'm not hurting anyone?", eh?) I don't want to take anything away from people, I just want us to think clearly about what's really going on when these kind of excellent results occur. In the excitement over the successes with MDMA we shouldn't overlook things like Emotional Freedom Technique or Feldenkrais Technique that have also had wonderful successes with PTSD and yet don't involve ingesting substances. If we do, we risk missing out on the essential aspects of effective therapy.
- AnthonBerg 7y ago
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoIt’s true that claiming the pill will cure smoking is a lie. That’s no more true than saying the tires on your car will get you to work. The scientific studies of late depend on the use of the pill and a specially trained therapist through multiple sessions. Several drug free sessions to discuss deep issues and get to know one another, an introductory session with the equivalent of 2g of dried mushrooms, and two weeks later a full session with the equivalent of 5-6g dried mushrooms. All of this is with the trained therapist who knows the patient. And the results are undeniable. Of course it may be possible to find these benefits without the therapist, but certainly with the therapist the drug can enable deeply valuable medical treatment. Anyone who claims the drug fixes the problem by itself is either a quack or is speaking slightly incorrectly and really trying to say the drug was an important part of their solution.
- halleonard 7y ago> (I'm great friends with Mushroom, and a little 'shroom tea can be great fun. But cramming 'im into a wee lil pill and then claiming "quit smoking" magic is in it... That's bad science and lousy magick.) Fortunately that's not what they're finding for these classes of drugs. See the incredible stats coming out around MDMA + PTSD + therapy.
- defterGoose 7y ago>a little 'shroom tea can be great fun. You go out of your way to say you're not against drugs per se, but based on this statement and I can say that your attitude towards psychedelics is probably antithetical to their therapeutic potential. Having used mushrooms only once (admittedly in a larger-than-probably-responsible dose), I can say that viewing the trip as a recreational experience is misguided at best and damaging or dangerous at worst.
- carapace 7y agoWith that statement I was merely acknowledging a fact. Many people have had a fine old time with the aid of the "Magic" Mushroom. It can't be denied. However, personally, I agree with you that "viewing the trip as a recreational experience is misguided at best and damaging or dangerous at worst."
- WhompingWindows 7y agoI'm sorry, I have to disagree friend. You're overlooking the basic neurochemistry of these substances. If you take Psilocybin or LSD, it will cause actual, scientifically observable changes in the brain. These actual changes can be of great benefit even if there is not necessarily an official therapy employed. The whole recreational, non-study-able drug use phenomenon, the societal wave of recognition of the value of these experiences, it's all due to the fact that these have a real positive impact on the neurochemistry of the majority of people. Set and setting is important in all branches of medicine and self-improvement, but it's undeniable that these drugs will do wonders even with loosely structured goals at the outset, given proper set and setting as a baseline.