8 ms·
America has an attitude problem. It thinks it is already developed. Like, there is nothing left to do. That is the single biggest difference between the America
by dr_dshiv 7y ago
America has an attitude problem. It thinks it is already developed. Like, there is nothing left to do. That is the single biggest difference between the America of today and the America of the last century.
The Netherlands feels more like India, in that everything is under a state of continual improvement all the time. The Netherlands is fantastically futuristic, though, and super nice (much more developed than most of America). That's because they don't think they are "done".
Here is a map of the parts of the Netherlands that are under water. https://images.app.goo.gl/c5E11LJfLETAFFBy9 https://images.app.goo.gl/c5E11LJfLETAFFBy9
- davidw 7y agoYour comment reminds me of the Strong Towns concept of "built to a finished state". The idea that, say, a suburb gets built and it must stay in the form it was built in forever and ever, rather than, say, gradually gaining a few businesses, or some denser housing in more desirable locations.
- beerandt 7y agoI mean, this is basically what zoning was designed to do. For the most part, it's working as intended.
- davidw 7y agoYeah, unfortunately, for values of 'working' that signify huge costs for people, cities and the environment.
- gowld 7y ago"Working as intended" is often a euphemism for "broken as designed"
- beerandt 7y agoWhat do you suggest? Houston has its own set of problems.
- davidw 7y agoHouston, like many American cities, massively subsidizes sprawl and an auto-centric (or auto-only) lifestyle. They may not have zoning, but they do have things like parking minimums throughout much of the city. And in their favor, it is a place where many people can afford to live, something that can't be said of places like the San Francisco bay area. Where I lived in Italy, I could walk to: * My kids' schools * A small grocery store * A cafe * A takeout pizza place * Our doctor * A tram stop * A small park With a bike, many more places were within easy reach. How many places in the US allow so many different things so close together?
- taurath 7y agoMost towns downtown area, and most major metro areas. The real problem - they were seen for over 50 years by white americans as an undesirable place to live (high amount of minorities, crime), and are just now catching up and moving in. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight Its a big part of racial politics in the US - and now as all the current tech workers move back into the cities, there's a problem of gentrification where minorities are being pushed out of their neighborhoods due to cost increases. Affordable, with a nice walkable downtown, low crime, and access to well paying jobs is the holy grail for almost any town - there are very few that achieve it. Generally as downtown gets nicer it gets less affordable. If we had a good way to actually spread out wealth and jobs, the smaller towns could improve and there would be many desirable local places to live. Until then, people will enclave themselves away in their suburbs. There will also always be those who want to live in more rural, large spaces.
- bwanab 7y agoI'm looking out my window at Boston's seaport. It has been under heavy development for over 10 years that continues. It's like a new city within a city. You may find that attitude in some places, but here in America's oldest city, it doesn't appear to exist.
- CapitalistCartr 7y ago" . . . America's oldest city . . ." Santa Fe, Newport News, Hampton, Albany, and Jersey City would disagree.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoAnd Saint Augustine.
- ska 7y agoSan Juan has these beat by a hundred years or so. Saint Augustine is about 50 years younger (so also has these beat) and I think the oldest on continental soil.
- nostrademons 7y agoHe could mean that in the sense of "first to declare independence from European colonists and fall under control of the political body that would become the United States."
- ska 7y agoThat would be a pretty idiosyncratic use.
- xefer 7y agoOn the subjects of Boston, its new-ish Seaport District and "Make more land": was it ever under discussion to simply fill in the Fort Point Channel completely? That could have potentially knitted the Seaport development into the city itself. If I recall correctly, during the "Big Dig" work they had to jump through all sorts of hoops to run the new harbor tunnel road under the channel and deal with the water, and mud, etc. The entire South Bay has already been almost entirely filled in as can be seen on the map at the top of the linked article. Why not just finish it off entirely? Does it serve any actual purpose at this point? I always feel like a bit of a wet blanket when it comes to the Seaport. Sure, it's nice to see the development happening, but it still feels very car-centric and cut off from the rest of the city. Just looking at a satellite image shows that there's a lot more roads and parking than actual buildings. It also feels very disconnected from the city center. Getting into town requires a fairly long walk across one of several windy, car-filled bridges.
- justinzollars 7y ago> America has an attitude problem The older I get, the less it feels like America.
- nostromo 7y agoThe Netherlands is futuristic? Now I'm wondering if there's another Netherlands somewhere I haven't yet visited. I love the Netherlands in part because it feels like it was frozen in time in the 1800s.
- thewarrior 7y agoDisclaimer : I have only seen SF and NY in the US. Netherlands is one of the best countries I've been to. Its squeaky clean throughout with excellent infrastructure. Most of the roads, public transport systems look spanking new and are not overloaded. Its also quite green. The long distance trains are also pretty fantastic compared to the ones you might find in the UK or US. Amsterdam is one of the most liberal cities in the world with a good startup eco system. It definitely is one of the best countries in the world. The USA honestly feels like a downgrade compared to it.
- tasuki 7y agoFuturistic, why not. Squeaky clean throughout - now that must be a different Netherlands than the Amsterdam I lived in! Particularly after Koninginnedag or the New Year's Eve it would take days of wading through a thick layer of mush before it got cleaned. I've never seen such a mess anywhere else! (And I kind of enjoyed it. It felt... alive?)
- thewarrior 7y agoWell generally it’s not like that Atleast whenever I’ve been there. Or try comparing the Caltrain or buses in the US with ones in the Netherlands.
- ricardobeat 7y agoAre you japanese by any chance? Amsterdam is considered a messy place even by the Dutch themselves, especially inside the canal ring, but compared to most european capitals it is as clean as a shopping mall. Those festivities are special days, and there aren't many throughout the year.
- 7y ago
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoamerica has 350 million people. california, for example, has 40 million people. netherlands has 17 million people. india has 1300 million people. population density of netherlands is 488 people/km2. population density of india is 416 people/km2. usa is 98 people/km2. we are not netherlands or india. https://countryeconomy.com/countries/compare/netherlands/india https://countryeconomy.com/countries/compare/netherlands/ind... : netherlands and india country comparison. https://countryeconomy.com/countries/compare/netherlands/usa https://countryeconomy.com/countries/compare/netherlands/usa : netherlands and usa country comparison https://countryeconomy.com/countries/compare/india/usa https://countryeconomy.com/countries/compare/india/usa : india and usa country comparison continual improvement is aka constant readjustments for optimal function. america functions just fine because of our less than highly dense population/km2. stability is not a negative point. change and progress occurs with stability too. perhaps india and netherlands ought to consider stability and aim for lesser population density.
- IanDrake 7y ago>America has an attitude problem Yup. >Like, there is nothing left to do. Nope. That's not it. More like: There is nothing you're allowed to do. In my town, we tried to get a town only beach, since most of the beaches in town are owned and controlled by CCNS and fill up with tourists in the summer. But our town owned undeveloped beach-front land, so we tried to get a parking lot approved. Sounds easy right? Environmental impact study, traffic study, land use issues, etc... The final reason why we couldn't make this happen was a MOTH...an insect. That is why we don't do much any more. They want you to spend $50K on studies...just so they can tell you no.
- tathougies 7y agoYeah, America thinks that, because it's already developed, it can go ahead and impose ridiculous limitations on development -- because we have to be 'enlightened' about growing more.
- rayiner 7y agoMy daughter's school spent years in litigation to turn a failing golf course it had purchased into: 2/3 nature reserve and 1/3 athletic fields (for a small artsy school that hardly draws crowds to sporting events).
- LeifCarrotson 7y agoNo, that's a map of the parts of the Netherlands which were underwater. Here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Oceans_and_seas_boundaries_map-en.svg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Oceans_and_seas_boun... is a map of the parts of the Netherlands that are under water (highlighted in blue). They haven't colonized those parts yet. But as you say, they don't think they are done. Or you may prefer the map at the bottom of the page on https://what-if.xkcd.com/53/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/53/ depending on how you think global warming will play out.
- mrfusion 7y agoThat’s exactly our problem. Even on hacker news, check out the top comment on any new proposal or technology. It’s always negatively mentioning the downsides and unintended consequences.
- jrumbut 7y agoI think a big part of that is the limited upside of unambitious projects. I doubt too many people became engineers or entrepreneurs because they were pessimistic luddites. I don't see a lot of people here poo-pooing public space programs or other truly horizon expanding projects.