5 ms·
Not sure what to think about it. Seems awesome at first glance but then the examples are skipping songs and hand waving pokemons. Feels a lot like a solution lo
by lm28469 7y ago
Not sure what to think about it. Seems awesome at first glance but then the examples are skipping songs and hand waving pokemons. Feels a lot like a solution looking for a problem.
- cestith 7y agoIt could be handy for a digital assitant to know when you're near the phone. You could use a particular motion to wake it for audio input rather than a button or having the phone always listening for audio. You could possibly use it for presenting slides, or have it measure a piece of wood or string or fabric or a package for you.
- pas 7y agoBetter speakerphone handling. If the device knows how far the speaker is, or speakers are, it might be able to filter noise better. Or using the chip to try to provide a consistent music playing volume when you do something in a room that involves moving closer and farther from the speakers. That said, I agree, I can't come up with anything that's truly useful and not just some over-engineered comfort thing.
- coldtea 7y agoBeyond a certain level, most of modern computing is...
- lm28469 7y agoYeah, I'm noticing that more and more. I'd even say we're going backward in many ways : jack 3.5 removal, everything glued/soldered, form over function, complete lack of reparability (while advocating for mobilisation against climate change and recycling at the same time)
- gizmo385 7y ago> jack 3.5 removal I think I agree with the rest of your list, except for this one. While the transition to USB-C is painful, I think the world of consumer devices will be better off for it in the end.
- coldtea 7y agoUSB-C for devices sure, but headphones could co-exist with the 3.5 jack.
- andreygrehov 7y agoAgreed. If I'm so close to a phone, why would I swipe in the air? I also believe that making those Soli actions requires more muscle energy compared to tapping the screen with one finger.
- sangnoir 7y ago> If I'm so close to a phone, why would I swipe in the air? Because you don't want to extract it from your backpack/purst first? Or you are lying in the dark avoiding turning the backlight on but you also badly want to skip that terrible song you hate... edit: or you're presenting and using your phone on the podium as a remote without breaking eye contact/physically fiddling with the phone/laptop.
- ckosidows 7y agoOr to keep more smudges off your phone and to not get as many germs on it throughout the day. These are minor, but not negligible. My phone gets very smudged up throughout the day.
- Allower 7y agoI don't think it will work with your phone in your pocket or backpack.. and typically your headphones have controls for volume, skip, back, play/pause, so not really compelling on that front. For presentations a small remote control is superior in every way. The only use case I can see is cooking, and there are probably better solutions (e.g. better UI design).
- rtkwe 7y ago"Requires more muscle energy" seems like such a weird metric to base design decisions around but if we start the phone in similar states for both, ie laying on a table, I have a hard time believing they're going to be that different.
- andreygrehov 7y agoRaise your hand and try to make 10-20 swipes. You will start feeling pressure in your wrist. In contrast, you can swipe for hours holding the phone in your hand.
- fasicle 7y agoWould be useful when cooking with mess on your hands and trying to scroll through a recipe.
- degenerate 7y agoThis is the one and only suggestion so far that makes sense. It would be nice when cooking. If I was sitting in a bus/train/plane/concert/<public space>, there is no chance in hell I am waving my hands at a phone. I would even feel silly doing it at home.
- magnamerc 7y agoYou can extend this to mechanics/technicians. Manipulating a large screen when your hands are full of grease.
- rvnx 7y agobut can't the front camera do that with a simple gestures classifier ?
- lewiseason 7y agoProbably, but that doesn't sell $650 phones
- rvnx 7y agoI like the privacy aspect "it's not a camera, it doesn't take picture" It does send millimetre waves though, could that mean we could hack Soli to view through clothes ? Like a full-body scanner works ?
- pdxandi 7y agoI just spent most of this year rebuilding the engine in my SUV and this would've been an incredible feature. I either greased up my phone when I needed to look something up, or had to take off my latex gloves, which are a pain to get back on when your hands were all sweaty.
- wvenable 7y agoThe main thing it's used for anticipating your movement for face unlock. This makes face unlock a bit faster on the Pixel than on the iPhone. Although that's a lot of tech for such a minor thing.
- ehsankia 7y agoAlso turning of AOD when you're away, potentially saving battery.
- myth_buster 7y agoI believe it's a documented fact that most of breakthrough technology feels like dabbling in triviality. I read somewhere (will look for source when I get time), that when Thomas Edison invented phonograph, he believed there wouldn't be no other use for it than to listen to sermons at home. I believe this __could__ over time revolutionize HCI and perhaps gaming.
- riyadparvez 7y agoExactly! The same thing could be said about touch-screens. We can do all these things with a keyboard, why need a touch screen. As a matter of fact, that was the argument Ballmer made during the launch of iPhone. I am not saying Soli would be the same. But it's hard to tell how things would turn out. Or it might take few iterations (maybe from other companies) to get there.
- 2_listerine_pls 7y agoI believe it's a documented fact that breakthrough technologies involve breakthroughs.
- side_up_down 7y agoVery pithy comment. Breakthroughs are only breakthroughs in hindsight. False positives and negatives abound in breakthrough declarations.
- sixothree 7y agoMore specifically it looks like a new way to capture data without a killer feature.