6 ms·
I am not sure why it needs to be called a donation. Just let the in-app purchase unlock some cosmetics in the app like games do. You weren't going to deduct t
by jrockway 7y ago
I am not sure why it needs to be called a donation. Just let the in-app purchase unlock some cosmetics in the app like games do. You weren't going to deduct the donation from your taxes anyway.
I am curious how this ends up working out. Google takes a cut of the donations now... but the process of buying is probably easier. So maybe it will increase donation revenue, and make it easier to support free software.
(Taking a step back; it is pretty weird to have apps opening links to web pages that take your credit card number. The app store operators are right to view that with suspicion because I'm sure that for every legitimate open source project, there are a million phishing scams.)
- dessant 7y agoOpen source developers shouldn't be forced to lock away additional functionality in their apps, or resort to special tricks just to be able to receive donations for their projects. Google could make a positive impact by introducing new features that help users seamlessly fund their favourite open source apps, right from their Google accounts. GitHub has recently introduced a similar initiative called GitHub Sponsors [1]. > Taking a step back; it is pretty weird to have apps opening links to web pages that take your credit card number. There is nothing weird about accepting payments outside of Google Play, and it is allowed if the payment does not result in buying a product that is used within the app. Buying a movie ticket, or operating an online store with a third-party payment processor are perfectly fine use cases which are allowed on Google Play. [1] https://github.com/sponsors https://github.com/sponsors
- kbenson 7y ago>> Just let the in-app purchase unlock some cosmetics in the app like games do. > Open source developers shouldn't be forced to lock away additional functionality in their apps I don't think functionality was what was suggested. Literally cosmetics. A nice banner that says thanks for supporting the project would likely be sufficient. Edit: Although I agree it shouldn't be required. As a workaround it doesn't seem too bad though.
- helpPeople 7y agoCompletely agree. I do not want to restrict any users. Annoying how hard it is to be independent of FAANG control.
- anchpop 7y agoWould it be acceptable to Google if the only perk of buying an IAP was a little icon on the screen saying "contributor" or something? Do they ban all donation verbiage or just IAPs that do nothing?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- LoSboccacc 7y agoit's not the verbiage it's the 30% cut that google is missing when using a donation link
- anchpop 7y agoOh, I see, thanks
- briandear 7y agoI don’t know much about Android, but is the Play store necessary? If it isn’t, then isn’t that independence from FAANG control?
- black_puppydog 7y agoThat's like telling a convenience store owner that they're "independent" of Visa and Mastercard. Yeah sure, good luck with that.
- sm4rk0 7y agoIt isn't [1] but an average Joe doesn't know about alternatives and what's worse doesn't care about them because he's not affected by Google's foul play (or at least he thinks he isn't). 1: https://f-droid.org/ https://f-droid.org/
- im3w1l 7y agoWhile I see what you are saying, it doesn't need to be "locked away functionality". You could like "sell" badges. $10 """buys""" a bronze badge, $30 a silver etc, whose only functionality is to be listed in some irrelevant "thanks for your support" view.
- gojomo 7y ago> …are allowed on Google Play. Until some morning when suddenly, they're not!
- _-david-_ 7y ago>Open source developers shouldn't be forced to lock away additional functionality in their app The additional feature can just be text that says thanks for the money, feel free to give us more money in the future.
- benj111 7y agoIs that still technically open source compatible? Edit: I'm referring to https://opensource.org/osd https://opensource.org/osd Edit2: Having read round some more, it seems you possibly could sell a different version, of course you would have to offer the source code which others would be free to give away, (this is for the gpl). I don't know if the discrimination clause of the Open Source Definition would come into play though.
- phkahler 7y agoBetter yet, just charge a dollar for the app. Link from the primary website to the app store, so people can buy the right one.
- dTal 7y agoNo thanks. If I'm donating to a good cause, I don't want the App Mafia taking a 30% cut. That just reinforces this bad behavior.
- ndarwincorn 7y agoIt's sort of a convenience fee. I agree with your App Mafia take but my guess is folks that can't be troubled to use F-Droid probably weren't going to donate in the first place. For instance, D-Sub is available for free on F-Droid but costs something like ~$4 on Google Play. AndOTP is available on F-Droid, not sure about Wireguard but I'd assume so.
- imhoguy 7y ago> For instance, D-Sub is available for free on F-Droid but costs something like ~$4 on Google Play. This is great solution to sustain the app developmant and spread the word about F-Droid!
- ThrowawayR2 7y ago> "Just let the in-app purchase unlock some cosmetics in the app like games do." Doesn't Google take a whopping 30% cut of the purchase price for both in-app purchases or direct purchase of the app itself? That's a pretty big bite out of the donation.
- amscanne 7y ago> You weren't going to deduct the donation from your taxes anyway. Unless I’m mistaken, this is only possible if you’re donating to a registered charity. Many view open source as more noble, but OSS developers don’t magically get a different rule book :) (I don’t disagree with your perspective here, but the prevailing sentiment in this thread seems to be that OSS developers should get a different rule book.)
- tylerhou 7y agoAnd also, if you receive goods or services in exchange for your donation, you need to discount your deduction by the fair market value of those goods and services. This is not tax advice; consult a tax professional for your own personal situation.
- lallysingh 7y agoAsking consideration from a platform based heavily on OSS isn't unreasonable. Especially considering Google would benefit from the improvements those donations could spur.
- franga2000 7y agoConsidering they have absolutely no problem putting restrictions, designed to give their closed solutions an advantage, into that same OSS base, I'd say expecting them to make such an exception for developers that (often quite explicitly) compete with their products would be highly unreasonable.
- heavyset_go 7y ago> Just let the in-app purchase unlock some cosmetics in the app like games do. I contribute to projects that are committed to never locking away features behind licenses or in-app purchases, because most open-source projects in that space eventually went down that route.
- strken 7y agoYou might not have to actually lock anything away. It might be acceptable to "unlock" a theme that you could otherwise just install in some other way, or there might be some other workaround.
- greiskul 7y agoLike another poster said, unlock a text box, in the settings, or about page, or wherever, saying: "Thank you for your support!"
- ryanmercer 7y ago>I am not sure why it needs to be called a donation. Just let the in-app purchase unlock some cosmetics in the app like games do. You weren't going to deduct the donation from your taxes anyway. My immediate thought at reading the title "So sell a supporter animation that plays in an about menu".
- siruncledrew 7y agoAn easy way to let people know how to donate without links is just use plaintext on a page. At the bottom of an “About” page: Paypal: email-adress Venmo: open-source-proj-maker BTC/ETH: <address> If someone is not a 501(c)3 org and just a solo person, why do donations have to go through a particular website link? It seems like the same thing (getting money) can be accomplished without needing to use links from an app.