5 ms·
Manufactured consent can be similar to fabrication. But, it cuts both ways. People think of this manufacture as big gov or big biz pushing their agenda trough
by mc32 7y ago
Manufactured consent can be similar to fabrication. But, it cuts both ways. People think of this manufacture as big gov or big biz pushing their agenda trough their lapdog media. But the same process happens with social causes. Let’s say vegetarianism or the anti-fur movement (very few people would disagree with the latter), but this took manufactured consent to achieve. The same with environmental and social causes. People don’t just wake up and change their minds. These opinions are filtered down to them.
- late2part 7y agoI remember in high school I used to say "I believe I speak for the class when I say..." And if folks didn't disagree it was consent by silence. Not the same thing but an allegory, when "fake news" parrots an absurd line, if we don't step it, it stands.
- justin66 7y ago> Let’s say vegetarianism or the anti-fur movement (very few people would disagree with the latter), but this took manufactured consent to achieve. The concept of "consent" as it's used in Manufacturing Consent does not apply to those movements at all. It means more than "some people agree with x because of information that was presented to them."
- mc32 7y agoI think it does. These movements start out small but have vocal sympathizers who have some kind of gravitas via popularity or due to some other characteristic people grant some “authority”. Then media carry water for it, etc. The mechanism is exactly the same. If the media didn’t carry the message and others wouldn’t grab in to that, it wouldn’t happen. Why aren’t social causes not as prevalent in China? Because the media is controlled. Lots of feminists in CN lament that they are not allowed to influence people. And it’s true. The gov will not allow subversion of their power no matter how just a cause is. It will only happen on their terms.
- justin66 7y agoIt's not that what you're saying is uninteresting, but the "consent" in Manufacturing Consent is a reference to the concept of the "consent of the governed." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent_of_the_governed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent_of_the_governed
- mAEStro-paNDa 7y agoI don't fully agree with the comment you're replying to in that Manufacturing Consent has nothing to do with those movements. However, I completely disagree with your statements that: >The mechanism is exactly the same. >People don’t just wake up and change their minds. These opinions are filtered down to them. People do in fact change their minds, for various reasons. These mechanisms are not the same because of power. Large institutions in the media that have lots of reach and authority act as gatekeepers to what is or isn't discussed. This idea that movements are propelled from sympathizers who are popular or have authority just misses how movements form and grow to begin with. Yes they start out small, but they aren't cleared by the media or any figure before they grow. Movements grow with pressure through direct action to a point where the media cannot ignore it anymore. It is a challenge for every movement that exists.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoIt's a very unusual view that equates a spontaneous shift towards vegetarianism in the face of corporate lobbying and advertising on behalf of the meat industries with an institutional refusal to question Israel's nuclear arsenal.
- mc32 7y agoExcept that shift isn’t spontaneous. Someone has to propose it, someone has to promote it, someone has to popularize it, etc. Manufacturing consent isn’t by default bad. Manufacturing convent to built pubic transit, manufacturing consent to have people vaccinated, etc., in the face of other interests is still manufacturing consent.
- pytester 7y ago
- zzzcpan 7y ago> But the same process happens with social causes. Let’s say vegetarianism or the anti-fur movement Those are not "social causes" and they do exist within the same system. Some corporation hires PR firm to redirect consumption away from expensive fur things, because it sells non-fur things and wants to get in on some of those spending money or another corporation that sells processed vegetable-based foods wants you to buy it, instead of meat and so on. There are lots of forces at play that create and support those movements, it's pretty hard to find truly honest social movements and even if some start that way they will be mostly supported by those who share the same enemies. The government itself wants to divide and marginalize people to make it easier to control them.
- kiririkk99n 7y agoThat’s not really his attack though. His attack is what causes we’re driven to consent to. Elsewhere Chomsky has quipped along the lines of “oh no how horrible if we had world peace” via organic filtering among neighbors. He’s not challenging that such a process exists. But how the organic process is bent toward disposable consumerism, imperialist conquering, not much different than in the old days of Napoleon and Alexander the Great, even though we call ourselves “civilized”. And we consent via manufactured apathy. Every option the public may want is explicitly bad, m4a, reducing military spending, higher taxes. Every option the elites want is just the right balance, citizens united, lower taxes, binding arbitration, etc etc
- fit2rule 7y agoThere is a collective mind, a thoughtform or egregor, which can formulate around any particular subject. Mass media is about the industrialised manifestation of these entities, in an effort to create 'godhead', or "everyone knows _ about _" conditions. "Everyone knows that the _'s did it", is pretty much the epitome of such a substance. Mass, collective 'reality' is basically a function of the things we can get as many people to agree to, as possible. Alas, our individual instincts are not always aligned with the truth, nor the righteous, nor the just. Often-times our individual personalities, as functional components, mixed in certain ways into egregor, become vile creatures, nearly unstoppable power. This is why we do it. There is no such thing as "America". This is a device invented, manifested, and maintained by an entity so large it seems undefeatable to an individual. These powers are manufacturable. We can fabricate collective reality. What we can't do too well, is allow our collective minds to become too self-aware. This seems to collapse it in on itself. Thus, a measure of ones prowess might be, how many lies can you get others to believe, and then: how many can you get them to repeat, in order that it eventually becomes a 'truth'?
- jancsika 7y agoFunctional programming also cuts both ways. People think of it as a practical application of category theory, but it can also be about declaring and defining functions in something like the C programming language. However, if everyone is talking about Haskell and you come in and try to shift the conversation to "programming languages that use functions" you are likely not adding anything of interest to the conversation. Similarly, "Manufacturing Consent" posited a set of specific filters and measured column inches as evidence for the existence of that set of filters. While you are certainly correct that all forms of human social interaction involve filtering information in order for people to have ideas and follow causes in the first place, it's a broad truism that sheds little light on the topic the book discusses.
- Joeri 7y agoIt's the narrative though. You cannot deny that western media has a narrative structure that is organized around conflict. They will always seek out and exaggerate conflicts because strife lures more viewers than harmony. If it bleeds, it leads. Even ad-free media like publicly funded institutions are prey to this in a race for eyeballs. This creates a certain kind of filter that prevents an informed populace. As someone who leans left I notice this strongly with all those "left wing" causes. They will choose a variation of that to carry that is least likely to be informing and most likely to exaggerate conflict. For example, they will put the anger and tears of Greta Thunberg and voices like hers front and center again and again, while ignoring the literally thousands of climate experts who could come and explain the facts in a sober and non-polarizing way. This is no accident, it is by design, because it gets more viewers. The end result of this is that media makes it easy to misinform and lie, hard to inform and tell the truth. This makes it easy for "the powers that be" to push a false narrative to get what they want. All they have to do is set up a conflict and the media laps it up.