8 ms·
Improving Form Controls in Microsoft Edge and Chromium
- laurensr 7y agoI interpreted that as: "Since we began work on the next version of Microsoft Edge based on Chromium, we’ve been investigating ways to leave Chromium as it is, as much as possible, without re-implementing its features to resemble IE/Edge as it was."
- 131012 7y agoWell that's Microsoft nowadays, kinda improving things so it stays the same or gets slightly worst... with a few more data leaks.
- thrower123 7y agoThank god, all of those IE quirks can go die in a fire. I can't remember ever being so gleeful that something was going extinct.
- DHPersonal 7y agoI don't think the poor HTML rendering and extra Microsoft code was what laurensr meant when they mentioned the lost features in the new Chromium-based edge; rather, it's the loss of Edge-only program features like pen/ink markup on pages. https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/help/4027048/microsoft-edge-add-notes-to-sites https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/help/4027048/microsoft-e...
- microcolonel 7y agoThey're not interested in bringing the inking features over? Did they fire the team or something? Is there something about their code which makes it not worth porting on to Chromium or something?
- WorldMaker 7y agoAll the inking stuff (and also the PDF/EPUB stuff that old Edge was really good at) is in UWP (WinRT/XAML) controls. At the moment it looks like the Edgmium team is entirely avoiding UWP controls. It seems like they are avoiding them for maximum cross-platform ease, but it's still not hard to wonder why they don't just use XAML Islands for nice stuff like Inking on Windows 10+ at least.
- Santosh83 7y agoThe colour swatch honestly seems much more functional in the old version, with the ability to store custom colours, specify hue, saturation and luminosity etc. The new swatch is frankly neutered down. Apart from that the other changes seem okay.
- cytzol 7y agoI agree — I prefer the old colour picker, too. Not only is it more functional, but it's the standard colour picker! If you've used any other Windows program that uses it, even if it was Paint in Windows 95, you already know how it works. I don't mind people trying to re-invent the wheel, but I'm getting tired of having to use a dozen different interfaces for the same task.
- 52-6F-62 7y agoI generally agree. I think the only thing I do like is that the new picker appears to be locally attached instead of a separate dialog that is called out and not closed once a selection is made (at least that's the behaviour on mac. I'm not sure if that's been the same recently on Windows)
- einr 7y agoFun fact: the old colour picker is literally unchanged since Windows 95 (https://guidebookgallery.org/pics/gui/interface/dialogs/colourselector/win95.png https://guidebookgallery.org/pics/gui/interface/dialogs/colo...), complete with the really awkward use of a pipe character as separator between "color" and "solid" (which was used for the closest non-dithered colour match back when we had 4- and 8-bit displays) And to this day, 24 years later, adding custom colours is bugged. It does not "add" colours, it overwrites the first colour in the list. EDIT: to clarify, the above is only true if you exit the dialog and then return to it. It has no concept of previously defined custom colors, it just overwrites whatever you had before, instead of appending to the list. All that having been said, yes, it does appear to be better and more functional than the new proposal.
- Jaruzel 7y ago
- akersten 7y agoMost of them look better than they did. The combobox is still a mess though. It's always been one of my least favorite controls, mostly because of the UI. Now, the flyout menu is detached from the base control, making it worse. It would be good for the design team here to take a look at how popular web frameworks have implemented dropdowns/combos, and take some inspiration. Things like the button morphing into the overall list, and losing the dividing line between the bottom of the entry field and the list of options. The focus highlighting is excessive in my opinion and will lead more designers to disable it - not a great step for accessibility. Maybe put the high contrast version behind a browser option/high contrast mode for the system, so it's a little quieter. In any case, happy to see progress on modernizing native form elements. But I hope these don't make it upstream without some significant UI polish.
- Ciantic 7y agoI wish the calendar widget would be improved in standard Chrome too. Looks like though they are not making the slashes optional, it's not usable for Europeans as we tend to use dots. Part of the problem is that it assumes browser wide setting of language, where as it is very common here to install browser and OS with US locals, but still want to have European inputs.
- wildebaard 7y ago> it's not usable for Europeans as we tend to use dots. We do? As a fellow European, I hardly see dots: mostly slashes or dashes.
- aspaviento 7y agoGerman people use the dot notation for example
- Ciantic 7y agoThere could be some east west divide. But is seems to be widely used, for instance Germany seems to prefer dots. Someone has compiled a table here https://gist.github.com/mlconnor/1887156 https://gist.github.com/mlconnor/1887156 not sure about it's accuracy.
- Jaruzel 7y agoImho, everyone should use ISO8601[1] as standard. Then there'd be none of this 'it's an american who wrote it so it's the month first for some reason' rubbish. -- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_8601 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_8601
- swebs 7y ago>YYYY-MM-DD Saved you a click
- BuckRogers 7y agoI'm an American that prefers YYYYMMDD and has used it exclusively in my career. As a developer with a lengthy deployment background and it's simply the superior way to go for dates for readability and sorting. Many like myself have 2 modes of operation, the 2nd being what business owners and executives are expecting. We couldn't force it on them if we wanted to. This often extends into English vs metric as well. I default on metric for everything I can. It may not be the American developer to blame but the average person around him. It's very surprising to me that after the American Revolution, we weren't eager and early adopters of the Metric system considering animosity towards the British was still lingering for some time.
- yoz-y 7y agoNot a fan of most of these: - They are all extremely inconsistent - Checkbox is the only one with 2pt outline - Padding is all over the place between color/time/date - What is a button? A grey rectangle with an outline? A black glyph? A blue text without outline or underline? - Up/Down to switch months does not make intuitive sense. Time could go either way. - The color picker looks seriously unfinished. It's like somebody threw some controls on a dialog in a RAD and let them where they first landed.
- akersten 7y agoInconsistency seems to be the name of the game here: depending on which webserver the loadbalancer sends me to (I can only speculate that this is the case?), I get a different favicon for this webpage! [0] [0] https://i.imgur.com/GdAmNUt.png https://i.imgur.com/GdAmNUt.png
- ummonk 7y agoProbably an A/B test?
- dhritzkiv 7y agoI wonder what metrics they're measuring for the favicon A/B split.
- foota 7y agoOk... how did you notice this?
- akersten 7y agoI have a habit of opening the same link multiple times, since it's sometimes easier to click the link in the thread than to Ctrl+PageDown to switch tabs. In this case, I had it open, came back to the HN thread to leave a comment, opened the site again to look some more (twice?), came back to the thread and read someone else's comment about consistency, went back to look at what they were saying, and that's when I noticed the icon was different compared to the other three tabs of it I already had open.
- Apofis 7y agoShmucks. That's all. Shmucks.
- iaml 7y agoDoes it support the same css selectors as chrome though? Or is it a bunch of new selectors, old microsoft style?
- kire456 7y agoI really don't get the time picker design that basically works as two long comboboxes side by side. Especially the minute picker requires far too much scrolling/swiping for what it's worth. I much prefer the Android dialog, with a clock face that allows me to select the right time with two clicks [1]. Am I alone in this, and is it hated by all and thus ignored in other OSes? Is it patented and thus unavailable for anyone but Google? I don't get it. [1] https://en.proft.me/media/android/android_time_picker_dialog1.png https://en.proft.me/media/android/android_time_picker_dialog...
- tolqen 7y agoI'm fairly sure even Android has abandoned this type of time picker
- aaronax 7y agoIt doesn't have two rings anymore, you choose the hours and then it changes the ring to minutes for you to choose that. Functionally the same I would say, for all but the most pedantic person. And I believe it has been that way for several years...I don't recall ever seeing hours and minutes rings visible at the same time.
- throwaway744678 7y agoWell, no, that is still the current time picker. I find it the fastest and easiest way if picking a time on a touchscreen. Not sure if it would work as well with a mouse, though. And it takes a lot of space.
- duxup 7y agoWhy does the button look "pushed in"? That doesn't make sense to me as far as a button goes. Flatter fine but it looks pushed in to me.
- microcolonel 7y agoIndeed, it seems like they have no idea what conventions are, and just wanted to change everything for whatever reason. The default low contrast gray "button" is garbage. Also, I get switching to a black outline on the focused text element, but now you have two colours signifying that something is focused.
- dawnerd 7y agoMicrosoft seriously needs to hire designers. Say what you will about Apple, but that’s something they understand. Windows has gotten a little better but everything look developer designed.
- sebazzz 7y agoThat is all determined by culture. The ones in charge, the ones not down hill.
- taf2 7y agoI just wish MS would release Edgium already... we can drop so many hacks and finally stop supporting IE11 once Edgium is released because we can just tell customers on IE11 to use Edge.
- ygra 7y agoHow well does that work in corporate environments (which I'd guess would be the last vestiges of IE 11 use)? If you can't tell them to use a different browser now, why would it be different after Edge is Chromium-based?
- mantap 7y agoPeople said the same thing about IE6, then IE7, then IE8, then IE9, then IE10. At some point you have to pull the plug on your customers or they will bleed you to death with technical debt and wasted productivity.
- zamalek 7y agoIt doesn't support NTLM/Kerberos yet, so it's definitely not ready for corporate environments.
- WorldMaker 7y agoI guess the theory is that Windows 7 can run Edgmium, but not Edge Classic, so at least Windows 7 users could upgrade from IE11 to Edgmium. But the problem with that theory is that Windows 7 expires from security support in April and if those users aren't already contemplating their next Windows upgrade then yes, why would they bother upgrading IE11 to Edgmium? Especially because wouldn't they already just be using Chrome in that case? Yes, I know that Edgmium will also have the ~crutch~ ability to run IE11 in specific tabs on Windows 7 (and 10) so corporations stuck in IE11 for "reasons" can have their cake and eat it too, but that's still doesn't mean corporate developers can stop supporting IE11, that means corporate developers will be asked to continue to support IE11 because GPO-ing the entire LAN to use IE11 "compatibility tabs" is easier than picking and choosing individual intranet sites that require IE11 because of bad vendors. (If your corporation or client is stuck with supporting IE11, it is likely stuck forever. IE11 will never die, because corporations won't let it.)
- duxup 7y ago>Just click the smiley face in the top-right to Send Feedback, and let us know what you think! It's telling that when I wanted to provide feedback I did a ctrl-f to find some sort of feedback link and it took me a while to figure out they meant to download the actual build and then submit feedback... that feels as wonky as some of the choices.
- pedrocx486 7y agoUh, the point is to provide feedback about the builds, why provide feedback for something you're not using or even have installed?
- duxup 7y agoThe web article seems to invite feedback.
- coldtea 7y agoBecause the build is not (and should not be) necessary to provide feedback for new visual widgets. You can see their design and provide feedback directly from the screenshots. If I wanted to provide feedback for how they work, I could download the build too. But there's plenty of feedback where just the screenshot of the new design is enough...
- WorldMaker 7y agoI know we're getting dangerously close to "Ceci n'est pas une pipe" post-modernism art theory land here, but a screenshot of a widget isn't the widget, and how they look in a screenshot is still bereft of other context. It's not unreasonable to ask that even "purely visual/aesthetic" feedback deal with the widgets in the direct context of running in a browser, and used inside web forms.
- duxup 7y agoTo be more specific I was thinking of that button. It looks "pressed in". That seems like the opposite of every button. Maybe the context would help, but that would raise all sorts of other questions IMO.
- hortense 7y agoAre these changes only for Windows?
- WorldMaker 7y agoSounds like they are pushing them upstream to Chromium and every platform Chromium supports.
- flyingswift 7y agoCan someone explain to me why they would spend effort on this kind of thing? Other than minimalist websites like HN, I can't remember the last time I saw completely unstyled form inputs in the wild. If every web developer is going to immediately reach for CSS/JS to style these things, who cares what the default style is?
- mwcampbell 7y agoIf I could use unstyled controls and know that most browsers would have reasonable defaults, I would. I think a lot of line-of-business developers would agree. I see an opportunity to eliminate one thing that adds bloat to web applications.
- flyingswift 7y agoI tend to agree with you but I can also tell you that 100% of web designers will not and would rather redesign them. Even with these 'improvements' I would not use these in a line of business app
- throwaway_bad 7y agoI often do use the unstyled input for say range sliders and color pickers. Most component libraries don't include them but they are complicated enough to make you not want to reimplement them. Even if you choose another external library it will be thematically incompatible anyway so you might as well go barebones and accept the OS style. In general, it's definitely possible to go too far with styling. Sometimes the look and feel of your app does add value but for the vast majority of apps, how your scrollbars and file pickers look doesn't ever matter.
- flyingswift 7y agoI guess one area where I see custom styling as important is visual consistency between browsers. These updates only apply to Chromium browsers, so a sufficiently visually complicated UI might look good in Chrome, but bad in Firefox for instance. I don't feel super strongly either way, but I think it is important to call out
- jchw 7y agoThis is a cool collaboration. I would love to be able to use unstyled controls again, especially for things like date and time!
- hudo 7y agoThe whole Metro/Modern UI is in like 90% cases much much uglier than whatever was before, and even after years of using them, I just can't get used to them. Every time I see a dropdown, text box or check box of new Modern UI, I think there's some CSS missing or page didn't render correctly. Looks cheap and ugly. Then google comes and do some version of Modern UI on web and Android, which looks and feel miles better than MSFT!
- dmix 7y agoThe input/select boxes are certainly a step backwards visually. The double border (thick black + thin white) is good for usability/accessibility but it's just ugly and also draws a ton of attention to itself on whatever page it's on.
- ygra 7y agoI understood it as that the thick border is just the focus highlight.
- shantly 7y agoI agree with your assessment for most of "flat". Apple does it OK but there are still dialogs and such that look entirely lacking design, in the worst way. On the plus side the typical case of design along these trends looks indistinguishable from the sort of thing that used to make people shake their head and go "I see the developer made this UI, we'll send it over to design to make it look nice, typical developer, doesn't get design" which means you can match average modern design quality without... knowing anything. So that's nice. Just claim something design-related in your title or how you introduce yourself or something and people will accept it—they'll still say it's bad if your title and reputation is just as a developer. [EDIT] for example—look at the "upcoming" for the Button element on the linked site. Yeesh.
- nikanj 7y agoHalf the time I see a control on a modern site, I don’t know it’s a control. ”One of these off-gray text labels is a link. Guess which one!”
- 7y ago
- foota 7y agoMany people were crying doom when Edge moved onto chromium. Would be interesting if Microsoft and Google joined forces to improve the browser.
- interlocutor 7y agoCalling these changes "improvements" is a stretch. Still flat, still dreary. They should have at least gone for a "Flat 2.0" look [1]. Flat 2.0 is is mostly flat, but it makes use of subtle shadows, highlights, and layers to create some depth in the UI. This is definitely not Flat 2.0. Look at that button. Looks almost like a disabled text input. Dreadful. [1] https://www.nngroup.com/articles/flat-design/ https://www.nngroup.com/articles/flat-design/
- pndy 7y agoThat's how they present all these meaningless UI changes - as an "improvement". But guess powerusers and professionals aren't the groups they're aiming at anymore - which I'd say is clearly shown in iOS Skype changes log [1]. [1] https://i.imgur.com/PlpipoV.jpg https://i.imgur.com/PlpipoV.jpg
- miohtama 7y agoPassword input peek button is very welcomed improvement.