4 ms·
> All I really want is an OS facility that only executes code that has been installed explicitly by me, and always in a sandbox. Androids app sandbox is pretty
by londons_explore 7y ago
> All I really want is an OS facility that only executes code that has been installed explicitly by me, and always in a sandbox.
Androids app sandbox is pretty leaky. It has a massive surface area, and the chances of finding exploits to get out of it to find root are high. Also, even from within the sandbox, there are lots of evil things you can do (for example, start on boot, and go fullscreen and use all the ram so the back and home button SystemUI process gets killed and your app is unkillable.).
The 'badness' of the android app model is a big chunk of the reason Google wants to be gatekeeper - otherwise android apps could just load and unload like webpages do. That and profit.
- UncleMeat 7y agoYou say this, but rooting attempts for flagship Android phones have failed at many recent pwn2owns. The grey market price for a root exploit on flagship Android is comparable to iPhone. The most popular third party rooting services don't seem to support past Android 8. Clearly it isn't easy to root these things.
- Operyl 7y agoI wonder if part of that is that a lot of flagships seem to have unlockable boot loafers now, with a force wipe to do so. Does that have a measurable impact on the number of people trying?
- UncleMeat 7y agoIt doesn't seem that way. There are still people attempting pwn2owns. The grey market value of a root exploit is still in six figures and likely higher on the black market.