4 ms·
The article mentions eco-tourism and whale watching. I wonder if the carbon footprint of someone flying to an island, staying there for a week, and taking boat
by onion2k 7y ago
The article mentions eco-tourism and whale watching. I wonder if the carbon footprint of someone flying to an island, staying there for a week, and taking boat trips out to whale watch actually results in whales being a net negative on the environment. If we let them die out so that tourism stopped it could be a positive for the planet.
(I'm not suggesting we should actually do this though. Whales are pretty amazing.)
- 11235813213455 7y agoThey should just offer high-resolution virtual tourism or anything. Is Youtube tourism a thing already? Tourism or all those non-vital flights are ruining our planet, along with the high consumerism, which is surely correlated to someone who go visit foreign countries
- abraae 7y agoTourism should be much harder. Make your way to your destination by bike, yacht, even if it takes a year to get there.
- samvher 7y agoI hope you mean sailing yacht :)
- adrianN 7y agoOnce we have UBI we might consider year long "vacations", but before that making vacations much harder is unlikely to be a popular opinion.
- abraae 7y agoIt's a spectrum. Sitting in a cafe yesterday, I overheard some people talking casually about flying the entire family up to Rarotonga to see a concert. A wealthy relative recently flew from the Philippines to Tokyo and then returned again - without leaving the airport - so that she could preserve her super ultra sure miles status. I myself have occasionally flown LHR to SFO to attend a over or two hour meeting. We cannot continue living like this.
- adrianN 7y agoI agree, but people who do things like you listed would be the least affected by making traveling harder.
- truculent 7y agoThat depends how we make it harder. Frequent flier + domestic flight levies, for example, can disproportionately affect the behaviours mentioned
- lawlessone 7y ago>so that she could preserve her super ultra sure miles Ok that is crazy and that's the airlines fault for creating such a situation.
- newnewpdro 7y agoUBI is not going to be a net win for the environment, not by a long shot. Get ready for another baby boom, here we come UBI.
- pjc50 7y agoThat very much depends on how and when children are eligible for it. If you have to pay for it out of your own UBI, not so much. Not to mention that UBI does nothing for the pain of childbirth.
- onion2k 7y agoA lot of people want to give up work to look after a baby but can't afford to because they need the income, so they end up not having children. UBI would mean they could afford to give up work and raise children instead. I actually see that as a positive, but if you're concerned about population growth you might see it as a negative.
- pjc50 7y agoBut would that mean they have more than the replacement rate of children? In the west we're slightly below that already.
- pyrale 7y agoIt is unlikely that any actual outcome of climate change is going to be popular. In terms of making choices, though, it is likely that taking vacations in a place that is close enough not to fly there will be more popular than not having heat in winter, not feeding your kids or abandoning the idea of getting medics.
- nxpnsv 7y agoOn the other hand, aren't there also benefits of people experiencing more than their backyard?
- czechdeveloper 7y agoThere are. But downsides are greater as they lead to destruction of very places they visit for their beauty.
- ip26 7y agoWhat if the benefit is that they vote to protect those places when they wouldn't have before?
- czechdeveloper 7y agoThat is big IF. I can say opposite: what if they do not care anymore as they already saw the place. It has same validity.
- rimliu 7y agoThat's an interesting question. Does traveling to some place helps you to understand and know it better than spending a few hours on Wikipedia and youtube?
- matt_the_bass 7y agoThat begs that question “what does it mean to visit a place”? I’ve been to a lot of places for both fun and work. I’ve thought a lot about this. Does it count as a visit if you only go to tourist places and hang out with other tourists? Does it count as a visit if you spend your time just at the house of a local speaking with locals but never seeing the sites?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Nasrudith 7y agoIt may technically be true initially but ecotourism is generally needed to preserve it economically and from a game theory perspective essentially. * If it isn't human inhabited why not take it? * If it is human inhabited why not try to raise their standard of living by development and exploitation of natural resources? If there was some sort of payment for holding unspoiled environments it would have compliance and inspection issues not to mention funding and distribution. * However if it is an asset with tourism then "poaching" harms future income and they have incentive to keep it beautiful and clean for real. It may lead to some "manicuring" like removing pests and making trails but biodiversity would be far more preserved. * Those who are already developed may also have the local ecosystems as an effective "service" or amenity from quality of life. Needless to say that is a "late game" option only. Environmentalism is always a game of trade offs period.
- rmgraham 7y agoAlternatively... how large would the whale population need to be to counter the carbon footprint of such tourism?
- hinkley 7y agoZoos are very ineffective from a preservation standpoint, if you only consider them as distributed caches of a small amount of viable genetic material. But as someone once put it to me, if you think of the zoo as an embassy, all of the animals as ambassadors, and consider the policy impacts that come from having people carry around these positive experiences involving the animals, then the benefit of zoos is much more compelling. I do some work with plants and diversity. There are some very confused people in my peer group who earnestly believe that changing a few acres of real estate inside of a metropolitan area is going to have a direct effect. Like somehow we could supply the entire city with food or materials on a few acres. In the interests of morale I don't tell them how terrifyingly naive that idea is. Instead I just point out that what we are doing is more like a zoo. We're getting an idea into a lot of people's heads. They may go try to copy some of our strategies, at home or in another city, and that might eventually develop into a measurable change. So. Is the Greater Good served by a few thousand extra tons of carbon going into the atmosphere today? Maybe, maybe not. I do know that we have the rhetoric all kinds of wrong. If your friend is having money problems and his car is breaking down all the time, and his boss is getting agitated about his 'flakiness', do you criticize him for "spending money he doesn't have" to get a reliable car? We've been doing exactly that to politicians for years. "Oh don't fly to Copenhagen to talk about Greenhouse Gases you fuckin' hypocrite" It's bullshit, and what's more it's scaring people into inaction, which basically classifies it as horizontal aggression. Which is exactly what the opposition wants. Stop attacking each other. If you have something to say, educate, don't shame.