5 ms·
If "certain ideologies" promote lies and violence, then it's a good thing that Twitter locks them out, don't you agree?
by DonHopkins 7y ago
If "certain ideologies" promote lies and violence, then it's a good thing that Twitter locks them out, don't you agree?
- wolco 7y agoUntil twitter decides to censor something important to you. Perhaps the Hong Kong protesters opinions should be fall under this new rule. Because of violence and everything.
- DonHopkins 7y agoIf their ideology promotes lies and violence, then yes. But what evidence do you have that their ideology promotes doing that, or are you just making a false equivalence?
- wolco 7y agoChina has made these claims. Turkey has called the Kurds terrorists. America may view them differently.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pluma 7y agoI mean, China's influence was enough for companies like Activision Blizzard to clamp down on people expressing support for Hong Kong, so it's entirely credible. Turkey's president literally just ran an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal defending his invasion of Syria and telling tall tales of Turkey's humanitarian mission and unique effort to fix migration, violence and instability. Twitter is swamped with "bots" (be they actual automated accounts, throwaways, state actors or regime-friendly humans) posting and re-posting fraudulent news stories, lies and plain old propaganda in favor of all kinds of national interests and political leanings. I wouldn't be surprised if Twitter in an attempt at "corporate impartiality" would be more inclined to go after the Kurds or Hong Kong protesters than Turkish and Chinese slurs, dehumanisation and calls for violence. After all, there are probably more "people" reporting these accounts than reporting the various propaganda outlets.
- rjf72 7y agoWhat would you suggest is the minimum evidence necessary to support the view that an ideology promotes violence? - Isolated incidents of violence on behalf of the ideology? - A "sufficiently large" number of incidents on behalf of the ideology? If so, could you elaborate on "sufficiently large" as you see it? - A general tacit approval of violence? - An explicit approval of violence? - Something else? The problem I think that many see is there tends to be extensive cognitive dissonance. People apply one set of standards to groups they like, and another to ones that they don't. I think you'll find that in trying to answer my above question it becomes quite difficult to include the groups you don't like, while excluding the groups you do like. That's even when my framing above which is unrealistically softball. For instance I didn't even mention things like harassment, destruction of property, etc which I think we should also generally be intolerant of - even when it's a group we like engaging in such things.
- swebs 7y agoWe can cherry pick a few examples of some of the protestors acting violently, then use that to claim the protestors in general are violent. That's what they've successfully done to claim Pepe the frog is racist after all.
- pluma 7y agoThere's a video from Hong Kong that went somewhat viral showing a protester jump kick a police officer in the face who was trying to drag and arrest another protester lying on the ground. The video was widely shared by protester-friendly accounts celebrating the act because several arrested protesters had recently turned up dead or disappeared. It's very easy to construct a narrative portraying the protesters as violent criminals if you start from the assumption that all police violence is justified and resisting any form of police violence is not. EDIT: Oh and the problem with Pepe wasn't that "Pepe is racist because someone used it that way", it's that Pepe became popular on 4chan and was then co-opted for racist imagery and embraced by actual racists who then used it unironically, so it eventually became a calling card. Likewise the "ok hand" gesture and emote was initially planted as a "hoax" white supremacist symbol by 4chan members but then actual white supremacists started using it, first ironically as a nod to the "hoax", then unironically to demonstrate their affiliations to others. The problem with these "dog whistles" is that they're intentionally ambiguous and can be entirely innocent in the right context. Of course not everyone posting "funny green frog memes" or using the "ok hand" gesture is a nazi, but if someone who's already suspiciously copying far-right rhetoric randomly flashes the ok hand in a photo op, or uses Pepe (or the less subtle NPC meme) they're most likely trying to say something while retaining plausible deniability.
- dragonsngoblins 7y agoI see Pepe used a lot on 4Chan in not racist contexts even now.
- rndgermandude 7y agoI don't agree. I want these ideologies in the open, where I can see them, examine them, fight them. I do not want them to go "underground" where they can fester and grow uninterrupted and unobserved by the larger society, until they have grown enough to burst and soak society in puss. Also, I do not want twitter, a private company, to be the gatekeeper, a gatekeeper we cannot observe or control. Especially not then the Saudis invested $300m in that company (or a reddit which had an $150m investment by essentially China). Freedom of speech is not absolute, but the limits shouldn't be set by some corporation, but by the People.
- wtallis 7y ago> I want these ideologies in the open, where I can see them, examine them, fight them. I do not want them to go "underground" where they can fester and grow uninterrupted and unobserved by the larger society, until they have grown enough to burst and soak society in puss. Keeping hate groups off of Twitter does more to inhibit their growth than your attempts to debate them.
- rndgermandude 7y agoProve it. We saw exactly the opposite in Germany when they tried to ban the neo-nazis. Or the RAF. Or ask the Brits how banning the IRA went for them.
- DonHopkins 7y agoYou prove your point by debating the neo-nazis on twitter, winning the argument with facts, and shutting them up. Report back here when you've solved the problem.
- rndgermandude 7y agoThe point is not to win stupid internet arguments with people so deeply caught in their cognitive dissonance there is no escaping for them anymore anyway. The point is to prevent them feeling victimized and recruiting other people by stating they are victimized and censored. Do not underestimate the underdog effect. The point is to engage them, debunk them, as thoroughly and publicly as possible to disinfect people who are on the verge of being recruited. The point is not to insult and belittle and censor that blue collar worker deplorable because that person voiced some concerns about immigration for example (even misguided or even racist), because when you do, you create another Trump voter who might even go to a White Supremacists rally later, because at least those people take that person "seriously" (or at least pretend they do) instead of throwing a wave of name calling and open hatred. The point is to have give the nazis and also the disenfranchised but usually also very hateful and misguided young, mostly white, mostly male fellow human being some people so eagerly call "incels" a place where they can vent their bullshit instead of venting it on the 8ch clones populated only with like-minded people pushing each other further and further, and also keep to an eye on them. And maybe, just maybe, by not always being a total asshole to them (even tho they are total assholes to other people), not going for the easy "you're an incel nazi scum" kill, you will brick by brick dismantle their wall of mouthfoaming ideology. Like this guy does rather successfully: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daryl_Davis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daryl_Davis You might know him already; he is a the black musician who went out and actually talked to KKK members and now has a nice collection of KKK robes from people he convinced to quit.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIf it gets impartially applied to all such ideologies, then sure, that would be a good thing.
- dragonsngoblins 7y agoHonestly no I don't. Locking them out will just lead to false positives and a forever shifting window of what is acceptable. Obviously acceptability shifts with time but if the response to someone genuinely saying "Wait but what about X? Don't BAD PEOPLE hve a point about X?" gets banned for it they are more likely to side with said BAD PEOPLE