3 ms·
The portion with the trolley problem doesn't make sense as described. > “A trolley is barreling down the tracks to which five people have been tied,” I explain
by gnicholas 7y ago
The portion with the trolley problem doesn't make sense as described.
> “A trolley is barreling down the tracks to which five people have been tied,” I explain during our second meeting. “You can flip a switch and divert the trolley, but you’d kill someone else who’s been tied to the sidetrack.”
I ask a young woman named Kierstin Davis what she would do. (It’s her real name—all of the students quoted here consented to participate in this article.) “I probably would flip the switch because I know less people would be killed,” she says. Almost all of her fellow students concur, albeit reluctantly. The notable exception is Jackson.
“You kill the one person,” he says without hesitation.
I don't understand — aren't the students all saying the same thing? Kierstin would flip the switch (which means divert the trolley and kill the one person), and Jackson would kill the one person. Am I missing something?
- nkurz 7y agoI took the author to mean that that Jackson was an exception because he was not reluctant, and instead spoke without hesitation. All reached the same conclusion, but only one seemed confident in the answer.
- shantly 7y agoProbably just more used to those sorts of discussions. May've been in certain clubs earlier in life, or just had the kind of friends who debate ethical hypotheticals when chilling.
- stickfigure 7y agoI probably would flip the switch because I know less people would be killed Fewer.
- Pfhreak 7y agoIt's interesting also that Jackson takes the active voice and Kierstin takes the passive voice. The people are killed vs I kill the person. Difference in perspective? Maybe nothing?
- theelous3 7y agoThat's presuming it's a verbatim quote. Also, your language around a topic changes if you have experience with it too. When you discuss something you're familiar with, your speech becomes optimised through previous communication failures. If you answer "I flip the switch" - in order to be assured I have understood you correctly and that you understood the question correctly, I have to follow up with something like "So you'd kill the one?". Saying "I kill the one" shortcuts some clarification and gives your answer directly and without ambiguity. Of course, if you're just a good communicator, you could give this clear answer without having experienced the question before.