3 ms·
> The philosophy department of a community college in rural Tennessee was interested until the administration balked at my qualifications. They’d have accepted
by gnicholas 7y ago
> The philosophy department of a community college in rural Tennessee was interested until the administration balked at my qualifications. They’d have accepted a degree in religion, but not one in law.
The author has a Juris Doctor, not a PhD. Presumably the issue was not with the subject of study, but with the level of the degree. No offense to JDs (I have one also), but it's not the same thing as a PhD.
IMO, the author tells this anecdote in a way that could be read as stereotyping Southern/rural colleges: "they love their religion, but not lawyers". In reality, it was probably just a PhD requirement. But that doesn't make for a seemingly-counterintuitive anecdote.
- Pfhreak 7y agoSurely the two demonstrate an equal ability to understand entry level philosophy, which (in my experience) is about constructing philosophical arguments in a sound way? I remember doing a lot of proofs, boolean logic, exploring fallacies, etc.
- gnicholas 7y agoActually, I would say that one could easily make it through a Religion PhD program without touching on any of those subjects. It would be harder to navigate law school without dealing with logic and fallacies, on the other hand. (Source: I went to law school, and my wife is a Religion professor.) But my point was more that it's very reasonable for a college to require that all instructors have PhDs, and JDs (3 yrs) are not PhDs (5 yrs). I have always found it odd that one can graduate from a law school and then immediately turn around and begin teaching law students. This is true also for PhDs and PhD students, but there is more temporal separation between first-year students and just-graduated professors because the degree typically takes 5+ years.
- nkurz 7y agoI didn't assume that "a degree in religion" meant a PhD in religion. I thought the more likely parallel was that the school would have considered him if he had a ThD (Doctor of Theology) or a DMin (Doctor of Ministry), or possibly even a DD (Doctor of Divinity, usually honorary in the US but academic in the UK). I wonder though --- why do you think it's reasonable that a college would require a PhD from all instructors? Why not simply consider the degree to be a plus, but not a requirement? Do you restrict this to "all" instructors in fields where a PhD is common? Would you eliminate artists or authors from teaching creative courses with (or without) an MFA?
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Presumably the issue was not with the subject of study, but with the level of the degree. No offense to JDs (I have one also), but it's not the same thing as a PhD. The level? Sure, a JD isn't the same thing as a PhD, but it explicitly is at exactly the same level -- they're both doctoral degrees. The letters stand for Juris Doctor ("doctor of law") and Philosophiae Doctor ("doctor of philosophy").
- RHSeeger 7y agoI was under the impression that a JD is at the same level as a professional degree, which places it at (or slightly below, depending on who you ask) the level of a master's degree. There is a Master of Laws (LL.M.) degree, but it's more academic.
- chadash 7y agoA medical degree also gets you the title doctor. The difference between a PhD and a JD or MD is that you generally write a dissertation to get the former, which means you have advanced academic research under your belt. You likely also have at least some teaching experience. As far as I can tell, The only place where a JD can teach in most universities is in the law school.
- jdkee 7y agoWith a JD you can likely teach in the political science department as well.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> As far as I can tell, the only place where a JD can teach in most universities is in the law school. I don't understand what you're trying to say here. Assuming JD was universally acknowledged as a higher degree than PhD, this would still be true -- it's a subject matter restriction. if you have a PhD in history, you're probably stuck teaching in a history department -- it will not qualify you to teach in the math department, or in the law school.
- MikeTheGreat 7y agoIn at least two states (Washington and Massachusetts) I know first hand that _community_ colleges only require a Master's. As far as I know this is normal across the US - I don't know of any community colleges anywhere that ask for PhDs (since community colleges focus on teaching, not research)
- gnicholas 7y agoCompletely agree that 4-year institutions are more likely to have a PhD requirement than 2-year institutions. But given the current oversupply of PhDs, many community colleges can impose requirements like this and still have plenty of applicants. Also, they may be measured on metrics like "percent of classes taught by instructors with PhDs".