5 ms·
One thing I've noticed with the culture of law-enforcement in the US is that there seems to be a mental divide of people into bins of "criminals" and "not crimi
by aidenn0 7y ago
One thing I've noticed with the culture of law-enforcement in the US is that there seems to be a mental divide of people into bins of "criminals" and "not criminals."[1] People in the second bin get treated reasonably and people in the first bin get zero benefit of the doubt.
By breaking the law, these travellers got sorted into the "criminals" bin and are now treated like shit. In addition, the high punitive nature of merely being arrested means that probable cause has replaced due process in our system. If a LEO treats you like a criminal (i.e. like human garbage) and has probable cause to do so, you are left with essentially no legal recourse.
1: There's also a 3rd bin of "law enforcement" but that is tangential to this article.
- smacktoward 7y agoIt makes more sense when you realize the two bins are also labeled “not white” and “white.” (Which also explains the shock white people experience when circumstances result in them being sorted into the “not white” bin — suddenly they’re experiencing treatment from law enforcement they otherwise would never see.)
- ASalazarMX 7y agoAlso US citizens and foreigners. God help you if you intersect more than one of the bad sides.
- eots 7y agoWhat racist drivel right here on HN.
- aidenn0 7y agoIt is more subtle than that. In most cases a female PoC in business attire is more likely to be sorted into the "not criminal" bin than a white man with a typical "white trash" look. The racism comes in when you compare reactions to casually dressed white vs casually dressed PoC. And it gets dialed up even higher if the PoC is showing any ethnic styles. If you use a model of "Random officer X encounters random citizen Y" if citizen Y is a PoC, they are more likely to be prejudged into the "criminal" bin, but this is not the only factor (gender, inferred socioeconomic class, &c. will also play a role). This is very different than labeling the bins "not white" and "white"
- _bxg1 7y ago> In addition, the high punitive nature of merely being arrested means that probable cause has replaced due process in our system. Going beyond that, border patrol has special leeway above and beyond what regular law enforcement can do. They don't need a warrant or even probable cause to search you or your property, and they've been known to intentionally mislead people about their rights and detain them without access to an attorney or a phone call. It's pretty much anything-goes.
- proc0 7y agoI may be extrapolating too much but it seems this is an aspect of American culture in general. We dichotomize things a lot it seems, from the two party system, to culture war. Even when trying to get rid of a dichotomy, like gender activist culture which tries to get rid of gender dichotomy, is ironically still putting people into two bins of being an ally or not. fixed wording
- neogodless 7y agoFirst, I think there's some trouble in your statement about irony, because you're generalizing all Americans and some perspectives on Americans and then saying they contradict each other. Contradictions aren't valid when they're based on hand-wavy generalizations. But second, to your point, polarization is studied, and it has grown in American as well as elsewhere on the planet. I've been listening to the Argument Ninja podcast [0] about the topic, as well as reading the series by Tim Urban [1] to better understand what's happening, and hopefully learn what, if any, solutions (and hope) exist. [0] https://kevindelaplante.com/podcast/ https://kevindelaplante.com/podcast/ [1] https://waitbutwhy.com/2019/08/story-intro.html https://waitbutwhy.com/2019/08/story-intro.html
- proc0 7y agoOh the irony bit was just pointing out how it even occurs in groups of people that are trying to get rid of a dichotomy (that there are more than two genders), but ironically they still form a different kind of dichotomy. (not taking sides here just supporting initial argument)
- heinrichhartman 7y agoI see this a lot in the US: The "Good Guy" vs. "Bad guy" theme is very commonly used, and portrayed news, politics, film, etc. I find this to be a dangerous oversimplification. I have never met a single "bad person". All humans are driven by desires, fears within the constraints of their environment. Some of decisions turn for the better, others for the worse. All criminal activity I have seen comes from people who have manoeuvred themselves into bad situations, from which they can't entangle. So they resort to violence or other kinds of criminal activity in order to bring themselves to a seemingly better place. I don't want to make excuses for anyone, but the idea that someone is a "bad" or "good" person, just does not make any sense.
- 14 7y agoI love your optimistic view but lets be real..there are truly evil people in the world. It makes no sense to say we are all only just products of our environment or you could excuse any action that way. Yes people get into situations and I don't think that in most cases it defines that person, like say a person who committed and assault, I think they can go on to live a good life helping little old ladies across the street, but there are just broken toys out there that truly in my mind have little use on this earth. Back in the day the faces of death videos were popular, I can't stomach that stuff but every once in a while someone would suggest I "check this out" and it would be some video of some guy being skinned alive or something. You will not convince me after seeing that, that some people are not truly evil.
- throwaway_law 7y ago>By breaking the law, these travellers got sorted into the "criminals" bin and are now treated like shit. Only its immigration law so its civil not criminal law. That's the biggest mental divide I come across, there is a certain group that is very quick to label people as "illegal immigrants" or "illegal aliens" or just plain "illegals". Of course the intent is to convey and suggest illegal = criminal. This group can't wrap their mind around the fact immigration status isn't a crime.
- beerandt 7y agoIt's only civil for a first infraction, like the people in this story. Disobeying any immigration order or being deported and then returning is civil and criminal.
- throwaway_law 7y ago>It's only civil for a first infraction No. As a preliminary matter there is no such thing as an immigration infraction. >Disobeying any immigration order... There is nothing special about an "immigration order" its a court order, the same as any other court order and has nothing to do with ones immigration status. >or being deported and then returning is civil and criminal. This 2nd part just goes to my point about mental divides, no where did you mention after deportation the vast majority of deportees have a temporary bar to return and thereafter they may return legally...again this goes to your attempted point about "first infractions." People get deported multiple time, it doesn't become a criminal case after the first deportation.
- beerandt 7y agoIllegal entry (8 usc 1325) This is/was generally waived as a matter of policy for a first offence. The status of being/remaining in the country is a civil matter, and not necessarily criminal. But crossing the border illegally is criminal. >court order It's an immigration "court" order, which is administrative/executive (under the DOJ), and which is not an article III court. So immigration order might not be 100% accurate, but it's no more wrong than calling it a court order.
- beerandt 7y agoYou only need to see a bad guy try to sweet talk the cops once to understand why law enforcement is so skeptical of anyone with a hint of possible guilt. This is doubly frustrating if you're the victim of a crime. Not saying it justifies the treatment, but it does explain the binning, to some extent.