4 ms·
You can architect an agnostic solution there, but AWS messaging is firmly aimed at lock-in.
by bdcravens 7y ago
You can architect an agnostic solution there, but AWS messaging is firmly aimed at lock-in.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd when you do “architect an agnostic solution” you now have the worse of both worlds. You’re spending more on hardware than bare metal and you’re spending just as much on management and development time”. Just because AWS spent years both creating an alternative to Oracle and millions migrating, doesn’t mean that your company is. No matter how often some bushy tailed developer tells the CTO that they used the “repository pattern and standard sql”, they aren’t going to move away from their six figure+ Oracle installation. The risk of regressions are too high and the benefits are usually not worth it.
- bdcravens 7y agoI was responding to the parent comment, which said nothing about Oracle or any specific implementation.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m more responding to the sentiment of “avoiding lock in”, at a certain scale, you’re always “locked into” to your architectural choices where it doesn’t make sense to spend the time or effort to try to avoid it.
- golergka 7y agoCan you please explain how exactly am I having worse of both worlds here? Not trying to prove you wrong, genuinely curious: if I have a generic NodeJS app with PotgreSQL hosted in RDS and, say, use AWS-specific services like S3 and Cloudwatch, am I doing something wrong?
- scarface74 7y agoNo. I’m saying just the opposite. You see patterns like this from “architects” who want to avoid “lockin”: - A DBFactory that creates an instance of an OracleRepository that they access through an IGenericRepository interface just in case later on they decide to use a different database and then they don’t take advantage of any Oracle specific features for fear of “lock in”. - A StorageManagerFactory that you call to create a S3StorageManager that implements an IStorageManager just in case later they decide to move from S3 they can “migrate easily” You’ll find people who will spin up a bunch of EC2 instances and host their own logging, queueing, messaging servers to avoid using AWS specific services. Now they are spending more for hosting than just going to a colo and spending just as many man hours babysitting infrastructure. I’m saying that once you choose your foundational infrastructure pieces, no matter what they are, it usually makes sense to go all in instead of creating layers of abstraction.