5 ms·
> Is there a way to get those records expunged? Really? "Yes sir, we have entirely expunged your data and you have the US government's solemn promise that we
by einpoklum 7y ago
> Is there a way to get those records expunged?
Really?
"Yes sir, we have entirely expunged your data and you have the US government's solemn promise that we didn't make a copy of the files we're not telling you about."
Effectively, there is no such thing as expunging digital data. There's always probably some extra copy somewhere.
- mLuby 7y agoSure, don't trust them but still make it legally clear what's allowed and isn't instead of this grey area we have today. Then they'd have to do parallel construction because they can't admit there's a still secret biometrics database out there. And secrets love to be whistle-blown about so that'll happen eventually and reset their progress. There's no silver bullet, just a long battle of attrition.
- rjf72 7y agoHow would that reset their progress? The leaks have revealed that our secret organizations are pretty open (at least among themselves) about parallel construction. For instance this article [1] reveals some slides of the more harmless surveillance data on a target. Nonetheless, in a giant disclaimer at the top the NSA reminds their agents "This information is provided for intelligence purposes in an effort to develop potential leads. It cannot be used in affidavits, court proceedings, or subpoenas, or for other legal or judicial purposes." And as the leaks have fallen off the news cycle, along with an interesting rise of misinformation in social media, you gradually see people beginning to understate what was revealed and to show ever less concern over it. It's actually a phenomenal demonstration for how a secret agency should handle a leak to avoid any meaningful consequences of what is ostensibly ground-breaking information on programs that are, at best, in legally grey areas, all being released to the public en masse. Snowden no doubt felt that his leaks would change our approach to intelligence if not our entire nation. In reality, next to nothing changed. [1] - https://theintercept.com/2016/08/14/nsa-gcsb-prism-surveillance-fullman-fiji/ https://theintercept.com/2016/08/14/nsa-gcsb-prism-surveilla...
- mistrial9 7y agoyou are spreading misinformation here -- there is legal precedent, and courts do matter
- einpoklum 7y agoSure they do, because the US government obeys the law and upholds the constitution! Yes sir!
- GhostVII 7y agoSo is there no point in any privacy laws then, since your assumption is the US government will violate it? Laws give you a way to win a lawsuit, at the very least you have that.
- roenxi 7y agoA law that someone must do something that cannot be verified is more of a guideline. If the law is audited and compliance measured then that is meaningful, but the US government (particularly post-Snowden) is probably not capable of monitoring itself for compliance. If the government is not allowed to gather certain biometric data then that is relatively easy for the public to monitor. If the government collects and then promises it is going to delete the data there is a real chance that it won't get done.
- sysbin 7y agoMoney is what wins a lawsuit. Otherwise you must have huge public backlash and that doesn't happen often.
- StanislavPetrov 7y ago>So is there no point in any privacy laws then, since your assumption is the US government will violate it? Its not an assumption, its a fact that has been proven time after time in every case for the last 15 years. >Laws give you a way to win a lawsuit, at the very least you have that. That's just not true. Not only can the government spy on you with impunity, the court has ruled that the government can kill you, without any due process whatsoever, and you are entirely powerless to challenge or even discover if you are on their "kill list" as long as they invoke the "state secret privilege". https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20190924/20182043065/dc-court-state-secrets-privilege-trumps-any-citizens-right-to-know-whether-not-their-own-govt-is-trying-to-kill-them.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20190924/20182043065/dc-co... The unfortunate fact is that our legal system has failed. Instead of enforcing the law and upholding The Constitution - its most core and precious mandates - our legal system has consistently deferred to government claims about the need for absolutely secrecy and legal impunity to do whatever they deem necessary.
- cmroanirgo 7y agoI always wonder with these types of "your personal data has been deleted", especially wrt to nightly and weekly backups. If you've been "in the system" for a while and your "record" is expunged...can it really be so? Does the expunge process actually go back through backups and remove them from there too? I kind of doubt it, because backups are always "hands off" unless you're restoring. I ask this also for the purposes of GDPR and the big tech companies (FAANG). In my own stuff, I'd feel obliged to make a disclaimer: "Yes, I've deleted your stuff, and the backups of the data (which I still have), will rotate out of existence in nnn days." I would also need to keep the deletion request handy for nnn days, just in case I needed to restore data (& so that I could re-delete their data).