3 ms·
I wonder, do the DDG people use the `!g` things as a way to further-refine their search algorithm? For example, if someone does the !g thing, after searching f
by tombert 7y ago
I wonder, do the DDG people use the `!g` things as a way to further-refine their search algorithm?
For example, if someone does the !g thing, after searching for the same thing without !g, that implies the DDG search didn't give them what they wanted. Conceivably then DDG could run that search themselves and use that for training their algorithm a bit more, mooching off of Google's results.
There's probably some kind of horrible implication there that I'm not thinking of.
- lucideer 7y agoANECDATA: on one hand, as a dedicated user of !g on DDG for many years, my urge/need to use !g has gone down almost exponentially (despite being firmly in muscle memory) on the other hand, when I do turn !g, I find more and more that I still don't find what I'm looking for this is either down to: (a) Google's results getting worse over time (b) my searches getting more obscure over time (c) selection bias due to DDG solving for my less obscure searches I suspect (c)
- thfuran 7y agoAs a frequent user of google, I think a is not to be underestimated. Google has gotten more aggressive with stemming and other forced "corrections" to your search. This (I assume) helps in general but can frequently result in undesirable search results if you are attempting to search for words like in spelling but unrelated to common words or uncommon senses of common words, both of which seem to occur somewhat frequently in technical jargon. There's something to be said also, I think, for the ever expanding mountain (of 90% shit) that is user-generated webcontent that must be sifted through by any search engine: The problem of searching the internet is itself getting harder and harder by the day.
- Kiro 7y agoThey don't have a search algorithm. They're using Bing for the search results.
- ComodoHacker 7y agoThey have multiple providers and choose one based on query text and region. IMO this counts as an algorithm.
- biztos 7y agoThe horrible implication is something like searching for: > "is satoshi nakamoto really tombert from hacker news?" Logging the searches back at the Duckquarters is exactly the kind of privacy invasion you use DDG to avoid. Also they would have the burden of proving it's not PII for GDPR purposes even if they don't log any IPs etc.
- tombert 7y agoGah, I didn't think that this is how I'd be outed :) DDG actually says that they track queries, just no identifying data to them.
- jddj 7y agoI only really find myself consistently needing to g! for super recent results, like breaking news or a sports score. Admittedly some of Google's advantage here is the sheer scale of the compute resources they throw at their crawlers, and I don't know if DDG actually maintain their own index, but I'd love it if they noticed and slowly added those sites to some kind of more-frequently-updated list.