4 ms·
With all due respect and affection, Miyazaki-san (and/or the people now in charge at Ghibli) is just being a stubborn old mule here. There is no practical diffe
by toyg 7y ago
With all due respect and affection, Miyazaki-san (and/or the people now in charge at Ghibli) is just being a stubborn old mule here. There is no practical difference between homevideo and streaming, and homevideo copies of Ghibli films are everywhere (whether official or otherwise). They have been on TV multiple times in Japan and elsewhere.
Maybe it's a way to push reluctant distributors to continue these mini-festivals they have been touring for a few years. Maybe they are trying to raise the price for when an agreement is inevitably found. Maybe they are waiting for the streaming wars to be over so they can talk to one distributor rather than five. Whatever it may be, I am sceptical that it springs from some deep reasoning about the way people consume this type of media.
- metamet 7y ago> There is no practical difference between homevideo and streaming, and homevideo copies of Ghibli films are everywhere (whether official or otherwise). There very much is. Ghibli is preserving the "value" of the film by not allowing it to be made into a commodity. He wants people to want to decide to watch the films and have them in physical possession, rather than decide to pull it up amongst the hundreds of thousands of other options at their fingertips. "I don't want to do it because the films would be treated as cheap commodities." [1] Their approach to merchandising might shed a little bit of light into why is doing this. > "With regards to merchandise, we resolved not to make more than 10 billion yen. If we surpassed that number, we would gather all the associating companies and berate the person in charge in front of the whole group. Really. One time, everyone got on our case about it, saying, 'You've got to sell more.' Someone from one particular company even said, 'We could raise the sales to 200 billion yen just by ourselves.' It's not a joke. If they did that, then Ghibli's characters would die instantly. I want Ghibli's characters to have a long life. They see more to their characters and IPs than dollar signs, and they're taking active steps to preserve it. Which is why the collectors editions of their films (Spirited Away coming Nov 12) are finely tuned and have well thought out art books. The feeling and memories they're creating are more than just the runtime. [1] https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/interest/2019-04-13/ghibli-co-founder-toshio-suzuki-discusses-why-studio-did-not-seek-growth/.145563 https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/interest/2019-04-13/ghibli-...
- criddell 7y agoThey're being a little precious about it all. They don't want their movies treated like cheap commodities, but in the end that's what they are. They can't deny that all of their movies are available in high quality for free online. If they are truly worried about making too much money, then maybe they are fine with that.
- WilliamEdward 7y agoAll of these statements just made them one of the greatest companies in my book.
- novok 7y agoI think there might be a cultural/home market component too. When I was visiting japan, I was somewhat surprised about how many book stores, record stores and so on were still around and busy. And when I looked up the stats, japan does have more CD sales than most markets too: https://qz.com/711490/why-japan-has-more-music-stores-than-the-rest-of-the-world/ https://qz.com/711490/why-japan-has-more-music-stores-than-t...
- toyg 7y ago> Ghibli is preserving the "value" of the film by not allowing it to be made into a commodity. I guess I disagree in the sense that it already is, and this restriction is actually devaluing the material. Ghibli DVDs are everywhere; a lot of them are not official, and make money for pirates rather than for the studio. You can only artificially restrict demand for so long, in the digital world, and that boat sailed for Ghibli productions a long time ago. IMHO making the movies easier to distribute wouldn't impact the quality of presentation or remove the space for artistic and sentimental engagement with the material. The fact that mainstream movies are on dvd and streaming did not destroy the market for film festivals - the opposite is probably true, in fact. One can go about "not being greedy" and enhancing experience of the material without being precious for preciousness' sake.
- romwell 7y ago> Ghibli DVDs are everywhere; a lot of them are not official, and make money for pirates rather than for the studio. See, the point is that it's OK. You are thinking about money, Miyazaki is thinking about what you'd call the UX. It's better that someone picks a pirated DVD off the shelf, inserts it into the player, and watches the DVD deliberately, in their perspective, than mindlessly clicking on a "suggested next movie" button on a streaming service, and abandon the film half-way. Even pirating the movie is better, since it's a deliberate action, a choice, and an effort. >IMHO making the movies easier to distribute wouldn't impact the quality of presentation Well, that's where you and Studio Ghibli disagree. The idea of getting more satisfaction from getting something if it's a reward for an effort, however minor, is not new. That's why games have achievements, for example.
- open-source-ux 7y agoHe might change his mind...eventually. For a long time he was adamant he would never make a computer-generated film, but in 2018 Ghibli released his first ever short CG film: Boro the Caterpillar. Although the film is computer animated, it mimics the hand-drawn aesthetic of 2D animation. (The film is only available to watch in the Ghibli Museum in Tokyo.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gfaHiPtYWTc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gfaHiPtYWTc