48 ms·
In Germany we do not have this problem (neither voter suppression nor voter fraud), for a multitude of reasons: 1) everyone has a government-provided ID docume
by mschuster91 7y ago
In Germany we do not have this problem (neither voter suppression nor voter fraud), for a multitude of reasons:
1) everyone has a government-provided ID document: a passport, for German nationals the ID card Personalausweis also works, and for EU nationals (who can vote in municipal and EU elections) their country's ID document
2) the legal requirement to register at the city/region office ("Meldebehörde") where you live, and you have to prove this with a copy of your rent contract or property deed
3) everyone getting a document ("Wahlschein") by mail a couple of weeks prior to election date. If you don't get one but should have gotten, you can contact the election authority to investigate, and if you lose/misplace it you can easily look up where your voting place is, go there and have them locate you on the voter roll.
4) if any piece of official mail goes returned by the post as "undeliverable", the Meldebehörde will investigate and de-register you (thus also removing you from the voter roll)
The only real vote fraud in the last years was from a politician who had seasonal workers register at a company and apply for mail-voting, but that's it.
- thinkling 7y agoYeah, from the European perspective the American situation is hard to understand. In the U.S., requiring everyone to register their address is going to be met with cries of Big Brother and small but vocal resistance. This is despite the fact that the vast majority of people have to declare an address to file their tax return and/or to have a driver's license. The other piece is that the constitution, written before direct elections were common, explicitly leaves the execution of elections to the states, which makes it hard for the federal government to set standards or require this kind of registration. And it's politically intractable to fix these silly things in the constitution.
- crooked-v 7y agoIt becomes much easier to understand when you realize that the modern Republican Party opposes centralized voter ID at the national level and supports stricter but wildly patchwork voting ID requirements at the local level for the same reason: it makes it harder for demographics they don't like to get acceptable IDs for voting. For example, in 2015, North Carolina's Republican state legislature literally looked up the forms of ID statistically most likely to be used by black people for voting ID in the state and banned those for use in voting, while leaving the forms of voting ID most used by white people as valid. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/07/29/the-smoking-gun-proving-north-carolina-republicans-tried-to-disenfranchise-black-voters/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/07/29/the-s...
- mschuster91 7y ago> And it's politically intractable to fix these silly things in the constitution. Which is why I had originally hoped not for Warren or Sanders to end up as Democrat candidate but Biden (which is very unrealistic at the moment)... the general idea was having a left-moderate candidate like Biden get enough votes in 2020 to have a strong Congressional majority in order to fix voter suppression, gerrymandering, electoral college, campaign finance and media ownership (e.g. breaking up Sinclair, re-establishing something like the Fairness Doctrine). Then in 2024 a proper leftie candidate could compete on fair and even terms against whatever the Republicans put up. But since Biden is pretty much toast now thanks to the Ukraine scandal it will probably be Warren who ends up as Democrat candidate and I fear that the Republicans will launch an all-out anti-communist war campaign, aided by Fox, Sinclair and "conservative" rags - pitting 'Trump vs "Communism"' in the 2020 elections may yield a victory for Trump in the current situation...
- maze-le 7y agoOh well you know, stuff like this also happens: https://wahlen.sachsen.de/LW_19.php?wahlkreis=51&_cp=%7B%22tabs-wahlen-accordion%22%3A%7B%220%22%3Atrue%7D%2C%22previousOpen%22%3A%7B%22group%22%3A%22tabs-wahlen-accordion%22%2C%22idx%22%3A0%7D%7D&_ptabs=%7B%22%23tab-wahlbeteiligung%22%3A1%7D&gemeinde=14628210 https://wahlen.sachsen.de/LW_19.php?wahlkreis=51&_cp=%7B%22t... ----- State elections in saxony this year. Look at the table underneath the map: Wahlberechtigte -- eligible to vote -- 1 722 Wähler -- voters -- 2 083 -- 121,0 %
- fsh 7y agoThis has been debunked in the German media a million times. Absentee ballots are not necessarily counted in the district where the voter is registered, which makes the number of votes cast exceed the number of people egligible to vote in some districts. The website even says that the district was collecting absentee ballots for five other districts as well.
- lefstathiou 7y agoAll of this makes perfect sense which is why we don’t do it. For the same reasons one party favors aggressive purging in urban areas, another party is hostile toward implementing voter ID requirements in those same districts.
- neuronexmachina 7y agoFor reasons I don't entirely understand, there's a pretty huge bipartisan opposition in the US to distributing national ID cards.