5 ms·
It's not really that generalized as you can pick 1 or more majors and focus on what you want to learn most. Not to mention each MBA school has different charact
by airstrike 7y ago
It's not really that generalized as you can pick 1 or more majors and focus on what you want to learn most. Not to mention each MBA school has different characteristics, attracting different candidates and campus recruiters. Stanford and Booth couldn't be more different if they tried.
MBA graduates are also not fit for running literally any business. The only thing employers know is that if you come from a top 10 MBA, you probably check the box on being pretty smart (the GMAT is a tough exam) while also possessing soft skills, being personable, ready to meet with clients or manage people and probably well-connected. It's a pedigree that allegedly excludes the dumb rich kids
Now your claim about Wall Street is just uninformed FUD. Most people on the street do not have an MBA, let alone one from a top school, particularly on the Sales & Trading branch of Wall Street that is usually what people associate with poor ethics and exploiting Main Street
- notfromhere 7y agoFolks on the trading side definitely don't. Folks on the PE side definitely do, especially the decisionmakers
- semiotagonal 7y agoTrading seems to have people from a very wide variety of backgrounds and capabilities. I think it's the result of random events being the most significant filtering mechanism. Anyone can get burned on a trade at any time, so staying in the game doesn't really depend on anyone's qualifications or abilities.
- notfromhere 7y agoFeel like for trading you either have it or don't, and no pedigree will save you on a bad trade.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- airstrike 7y agoAnd, if anything, people from less secure socioeconomic backgrounds may feel they stand to lose less by pursuing a riskier career path (and I mean "risk" in the real sense of a broader range of outcomes) than, say, PE or Corporate Law, so they are a larger share of S&T
- iamasoftwaredev 7y ago> It's a pedigree that allegedly excludes the dumb rich kids Yeah, it's exclusively for the smarter rich kids.
- airstrike 7y agoI don't know. As the son of a High School teacher and an unemployed father from a third world country, I'm probably not what you call "smarter rich kid" yet I went to a top 5 MBA. Many of my classmates came from equally diverse backgrounds and nationalities. I think 30%+ of my class were foreigners. But go on, it's easy to hate on MBAs. It's the one bigoted view everyone is seemingly allowed to have.
- iamasoftwaredev 7y ago> I think 30%+ of my class were foreigners. Because foreign born people can't be rich? What income percentiles are Harvard MBA students coming from?
- airstrike 7y agoMany of us weren't. You claimed MBAs are exclusively for rich kids. I provided data to refute that baseless claim. The point on how many foreigners there were is just a freebie. I don't know about Harvard MBA students, I didn't go there. But you can go ahead and google each school's class profile. Maybe that info is out there.
- eastWestMath 7y agoThe plural of anecdote is not data.
- airstrike 7y agoThat phrase stopped being witty ages ago. These days it's mostly a low effort comment. I don't need a plurality of data to counter his claim that MBA's are "exclusively" for rich smart kids.
- bertjk 7y agoI can accept the pretty smart part (I've never seen the GMAT but I'll accept it for the sake of argument) but what part of getting an MBA filters for "possessing soft skills, being personable, ready to meet with clients or manage people and probably well-connected"?
- airstrike 7y agoThere are multiple in-person interviews, your resume has to be pretty balanced (you can't just be a math wiz), you need to show a track record of performing well on the job for 3-5 years prior to your MBA, usually in the form of multiple promotions, which signals you're not terrible to work with. Also helps to have a broad range of interests (including things you like doing for fun) because admission committees don't want to exclusively admit kids who just like to golf and play poker (though many of those do get admitted). TL;DR Admissions for top MBAs are very holistic, and schools will try their best to create diverse classes made up of well-rounded individuals. Some schools do this better than others, but then again each school is trying to solve for a different outcome and just like hiring, admitting students isn't an exact science.
- chrisfinazzo 7y agoHonest question: Do you think this disadvantages people who have basically followed a traditional path? By that I mean, if you are a finance major from Harvard, Yale, etc who goes to work at a large firm (say Goldman). Is there a chance they might get looked down upon because of the emphasis on the "whole person" or finding "interesting" candidates. Poets & Quants MBA odds doesn't talk about those kids, yet they will freely admit many of them end up at a top program for their MBA. (For the record, this is not me personally, but still I wonder how these kinds of candidates get evaluated, given the current environment)
- alasdair_ 7y ago>Is there a chance they might get looked down upon because of the emphasis on the "whole person" or finding "interesting" candidates. There is a deliberate admissions emphasis on ensuring the class is as diverse (in terms of viewpoint and experience) as possible. An MBA class full of only people with finance degrees would be a poor experience for everyone.
- vincent-toups 7y agoEveryone I've ever met who went to one of these schools strikes me either as a straight-psychopath or someone who really wants to be one.
- kajecounterhack 7y agoA different anecdote: everyone I've ever met who went to one of these schools is decidedly comp-driven when it comes to career, but a pretty average person otherwise.
- sedachv 7y ago> the GMAT is a tough exam It might work ok as a way to filter out people who had a poor quality undergraduate education, but it is not a tough exam. I got a 700-something score (95th percentile) in 2011 on my first try with less than 6 hours of preparation. The math portion of the GMAT was primarily about doing mental arithmetic, and did not involve any mathematical concepts past the middle school level. The language portion was primarily about English reading and writing skills.
- EB66 7y ago> but it is not a tough exam Ideally you don't want a test that's too easy or too tough. You want a test whose results form a normal distribution bell curve.
- snagglegaggle 7y agoSuch logic leaves you with no idea if the top X% is qualified or not, just that they are the top X%. You need to enumerate requirements and test against them. Same thinking leads to weed out classes that just pointlessly limit the number in some profession. Saying "wow, everyone passed calculus, that can't be right" and making the test harder serves no one.
- EB66 7y ago> Such logic leaves you with no idea if the top X% is qualified or not, just that they are the top X%. That's what MBA schools want. They want to know who are the top students on the GMAT: how does XYZ candidate compare to their peers? If you don't have a normal bell curve distribution and the results are skewed hard to the left (very difficult test) or hard to the right (very easy test), then you lose the ability to discern the relative aptitude of the test takers. > You need to enumerate requirements and test against them. That's beside the point. The GMAT is just one of many criteria that allow schools to determine who is a qualified candidate for admission into their MBA program. > Saying "wow, everyone passed calculus, that can't be right" and making the test harder serves no one. You're talking about something completely different altogether. Sure, for classrooms (i.e., a small sample size) there's a valid argument to be made against curving calculus tests or any other kind of test. After all, in a classroom the goal is to evaluate who understands the course material -- not to necessarily to rank the students. However, the GMAT is a whole different ball game. The purpose is to provide a relative ranking of the test takers. Additionally, hundreds of thousands of people take the test every year -- a massive sample size. You should expect to see a normal distribution if your test effectively serves it's intended goal of ranking the aptitude of the test takers.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]