8 ms·
What IBM Pays H-1B Software Engineers and Developers
- learc83 7y agoThe article concludes that it pays H-1B employees fairly, but the data shows that the median H-1B engineer at IBM makes below the median salary for Software Engineers in the US. Clearly if IBM can't find enough US talent, it's because they aren't willing to pay the market rate. H-1B is supposed to be for highly skilled employees. You don't pay highly skilled employees less than average.
- tbyehl 7y agoIt's more interesting to sort the source data by salary, ascending. IBM has quite a few more "developer" titles than Software Engineer and Software Developer, and many of them pay quite poorly. The median for "Application Developer" is $77K with a low of $48.5K. https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=IBM&job=&city=&year=2019 https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=IBM&job=&city=&year=2019
- selimthegrim 7y agoI can tell you exactly where that low is, because that's what they offered my Canadian cousin in Baton Rouge with an American CS degree before he told them to pound sand and went back to Canada to get his MSCS in Alberta. He has a much better job with Warner Music in Toronto now.
- RonaldDR 7y agoI realize this is not exactly a community that is friendly to being called out, but I have to simply say that it is inherently immoral to not only pay H1-B holders the same, tax them the same, let alone not make corporations that want to hire H1-Bs to sabotage indigenous populations in order to profit more, not pay massive penalties that only increase over time for the privilege of hiring a foreign national they poach away from another society, in order to compensate for systemic and fundamental mismanagement and failure at national governance at every single level.
- belltaco 7y ago>tax them the same What? They are taxed the same. In fact, they are taxed more. They pay for Social Security and Medicare even if they never get to use them. They also have to pay state unemployment insurance but they cannot claim the benefits from it. Not to mention the food stamp program etc. I am confused with your wording and the use of double negatives, are you saying they shouldn't be charged for things they won't use?
- ganeshkrishnan 7y agoCorrect. Majority of the social security is never used by h1b. Also need your own insurance, cannot claim any benefits, have to leave the country in 24 hours if h1b lose the job, cannot claim business expenses...
- screye 7y agojust saying, h1b usually have about 2 months of unemployment since being fired. Not great, but not a single day either. your statement about social welfare is reality for Indian h1bs. They will never be able to get a green card, and yet pay all the taxes for them. 8% of your salary is pretty steep for something you can't touch, ever.
- belltaco 7y agoIt's 16%. Employers have to match it, so it's an additional 8% on top of the 8% that the employee pays.
- ganeshkrishnan 7y agoIt probably changed with the Obama administration but when I was on H1b it was said that we had to leave as soon as possible. Maybe you are right because we could never find a legal source of truth for this info. The point is, we have to leave everything. If you have kids, car, school for kids, house everything goes out.
- RonaldDR 7y ago
- mfer 7y agoIt is really useful to compare a company to itself. If the company as a whole pays less than others and they are self consistent that says two notable things.
- wikiman 7y agoDepends on your definition of highly-skilled. Compared to an au pair? Very highly skilled. An H-1B requires application of specialized knowledge and a bachelor's degree or the equivalent of work experience. So it's all a matter of perspective, but the highly skilled formulation talks about the skills required to do the job, not the competency within that specialization. Beyond that, I agree though, that visa status is a despicable reason to pay people less than what they're worth
- x0f1a 7y agoThe simplest and effective way to solve the immigration problem is to give H-1B full job mobility and rights. This would benefit them and very quickly would bring the correct market value for everybody’s work. On the top side there will more genuine visa applications for real talent.
- Richard_East 7y agoThat will still put immense downward pressure on American wages. The simplest way to solve the H1B problem is to scrap it and allow open immigration for skilled professionals from the top 20 most developed countries. The reality is that someone from India will accept much lower wages and poorer conditions than someone born in Australia, Sweden or Switzerland.
- belltaco 7y agoAnd watch as IT companies move entire offices offshore, to Canada and India, resulting in mass layoffs in the US.
- xoail 7y ago> The reality is that someone from India will accept much lower wages and poorer conditions than someone born in Australia, Sweden or Switzerland. People on H1-B live in the US and maintain a good standard of living as per the city they are in and hence end up demanding for the same market salary as locals. This has been proven every-time people brought up cheap labor issue. The likely issue (for American jobs) here is when whole IT/Software teams shift to India or China through outsourcing companies and American workers are laid off as cost measures. This happens a lot in non-tech companies very easily where they want to stay ahead in tech but not take the ownership of it.
- ganeshkrishnan 7y ago>top 20 most developed countries Which 20 "developed" countries? Why would they come to US? If they could they already would as US pays much more than even "developed" countries. Australia has 23 million people (almost half of California) and almost zero IT. Sweden, Switzerland: Really? Not everyone's ideal destination is US. It's funny how most Americans think the world is falling over their head to move to a country where gun nuts have the right to mow down people but you don't have the right to get medical for it.
- anandsubra 7y agoThe last section is eye opening for me. This is what the total compensation looks like for entry-level software engineers: Apple: $160,548 Microsoft: $155,775 Google: $188,086 IBM: $95,857 The IBM total compensation does not even have 6 digits! No wonder they have a hard time attracting talent. It would have been interesting to see the numbers for Amazon, Facebook and Netflix too.
- mbreese 7y agoThat’s a pretty big difference, but it would also be interesting to know where these positions are located. The cost of living differences between SV and outside of the Bay Area is pretty substantial, making these absolute number comparisons a bit harder to interpret.
- sndean 7y agoQuickly putting Apple's (assuming Bay Area) $161K into a cost of living calculator says that's equivalent to $82K in Cincinnati, OH. (You'd need to make $82K in Cincinnati to maintain your standard of living.) So yeah, I'd say that adding locations is required. I'm not sure where the majority of the IBM software engineer jobs are?
- ganeshkrishnan 7y agoIBM is all over the US (much much more locations than others mentioned here) and it's also split into two: product and consulting. Consulting get paid less and bring down the average but people choose it for location and project variety
- freehunter 7y agoYeah, a significant chunk of IBM's workforce works remotely. So they don't have to pay cost of living for Seattle or SF. Much of their American workforce that does report to an office is in much lower COL areas like North Carolina or upstate New York.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- southphillyman 7y agoHonestly......it's higher than I was expecting.
- throwaway981211 7y agoThrowaway account. I’ve been with Amazon as an engineer for about 7 years now. We call ourselves diverse but really all we have are Asian (Indian and Chinese) devs... in some engineering orgs, white people outside of management are a minority (although it’s not just white managers, there’s tons of Indian managers too). We have very few black people in engineering roles. I don’t know a single black engineer at this company to be honest and I’ve been here 7 years and interface with lots of other teams. I don’t think the Indian or Chinese devs get paid less. The one data point I do have (anecdotal) is that every Indian dev I’ve met is generally on a spectrum between unhappy to extremely unhappy, and they’re only in their role because it’s very difficult to find another company that will sponsor you. So you either keep your mouth shut or risk getting let go and have to leave the country: Amazons work culture is pretty shitty in many orgs - very cut throat. I’ve never seen the more horrific examples from the NYTimes article years ago about people crying at their desks, but I’ve been in enough contentious meetings and have seen people purposely set up to fail by their managers so they could be managed out because politics.
- immigrant-h1b 7y agoYes, Indian and Chinese devs are unhappy because the H1B system unfairly exploits them and makes them wait for > 10yrs to be allowed to permanently stay. Of course, American companies are getting richer on their labor and their citizen co-workers get away with doing less while making more money. However, anytime there is a discussion on wages, blame them for everything. Learn to respect the guys on whose work Silicon Valley is what it is today.
- tbyehl 7y agoUS immigration is racist and broken. But can we stop kidding ourselves that H-1B holders seeking permanent status are innocent victims? They're exploiting a loophole (dual-intent) to immigrate where they otherwise would have a difficult time qualifying for an immigration visa. They've willingly accepted the trade-offs.
- NTDF9 7y ago
- jfasi 7y agoI’ve always believed that if you want to see a person’s true colors, look at how they treat people poorer or otherwise socially weaker than them. In other words, if your date is charming to you and nasty to the waiter, run like hell. The same applies to companies: there’s no better way to cut through the recruiter nonsense like checking out how treatment of H1-Bs compares to treatment of citizens and green card holders. A personal anecdote: a friend of mine who is on an H1-B works for a bank. This bank talks a great game about culture and working conditions and liberal social programs and opportunity and whatnot. How do they treat my friend? She makes forty percent below market rate for our area, and their policy is she has to work for them for five years before they even start the green card process for her. Meanwhile complained like Google and friends typically start the green card process immediately upon hire. Anyone who looks at their promotional material (who isn’t already disinclined to trust a bank) would come away with the impression that this institution is some sort of paradise of opportunity and career advancement. Meanwhile anyone who’s worked for them for any appreciable length of time knows that isn’t true.
- paxys 7y agoCompanies like Google, Microsoft, Facebook etc. pay H-1B workers extremely well. I'd expect IBM to be somewhere in the middle of the pack (and it seems like they are). If you want to find actual abuse, look up all the "consulting" companies that file tens of thousands of applications every year at the tech equivalent of minimum wage - TCS, Cognizant, Wipro, Infosys, Deloitte, HCL, Accenture, Mahindra.
- engclass 7y ago> If you want to find actual abuse, look up all the "consulting" companies that file tens of thousands of applications every year at the tech equivalent of minimum wage I've seen it first hand while working in Telco's who hire those types of companies.
- tbyehl 7y agoLooking at Google's lowest-paid H-1Bs, I gotta wonder, why are they importing Data Center Technicians? How does that even qualify for H-1B?
- bobloblaw45 7y agoWowzers...I should have majored in H-1B Software Engineering. Any good tutorials out there?