3 ms·
If you are bouncing the photos (like in a solar sail, aka a mirror attached to the back of the starship) then the minimal power is 150MW/N. If you are generati
by gus_massa 7y ago
If you are bouncing the photos (like in a solar sail, aka a mirror attached to the back of the starship) then the minimal power is 150MW/N.
If you are generating the photons (like in a photon rocket, aka laser attached to the back of the starship) then the minimal power is 300MW/N (and you need a generator).
I didn't notice before the 165MW/N in the slides, but their device is not bouncing the photons, so the theoretical minimum is 300MW/N, so it is impossible to use only 165MW/N. So they must have an error (numerical or conceptual) in the calculation.
In the slide, the energy is used to accelerate the particles, and then the energy is recovered when the particles return. So the article claim more efficiency, but let's ignore that part.
I think the main problem is that the particles will emit a lot of energy in the sharp turn at the top, something like the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyclotron_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyclotron_radiation This radiation is what really push the device. In the sharp turn at the bottom the particles are going more slowly, so the radiation and push is smaller.
I don't understand why the calculation using a mix of classical and relativistic formulas give almost the correct result. The error is only in x2 (in the impossible direction), a x2 is not so off. I guess the main problem is assuming that the particles will have the same speed during all the turn???