4 ms·
The idea of the article is to use the change of mass in special relativity. Some particles go faster in one direction (and they have more mass), and then they r
by gus_massa 7y ago
The idea of the article is to use the change of mass in special relativity. Some particles go faster in one direction (and they have more mass), and then they return more slowly in the other direction (and has less mass).
In special relativity, when the charged particles accelerate and decelerate they emit electromagnetic radiation. The whole process conserve the energy and momentum. The momentum that the device provides is compensated by the momentum of the electromagnetic radiation, aka photons.
So this device should work. It doesn't break the laws of physics. It produce some photons in the intended direction and more photons in other random directions. So it is just a very inefficient photon thruster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon_rocket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon_rocket. It's like attaching a laser to the back of your starship, and then adding some lamp to illuminate in every direction to make it more inefficient.
- m463 7y agoPatent 9000660 describes a carbon nanoring propulsion device that works by speeding up and slowing down pairs of particles.
- gus_massa 7y agoLink for the lazy: https://patents.google.com/patent/US9000660/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US9000660/en First, note that to fill the patent you don't need a working prototype. It's just a piece of paper. The patent has the same idea, but it uses other device to move the particles. It looks more difficult to implement than the device in this article. (And the patent has a weird discussion about a maximal velocity.) My previous comment applies without changes to the device in the patent too. It's just another very inefficient photon thruster. If the author forgets to consider the momentum and energy carried away by the electromagnetic waves / photons, then the device appear to break the laws of physics, like the conservation of momentum or the conservation of energy. When all the effects are considered it's equivalent to using a laser as a thruster, or worse. (It's equivalent to use a normal flashlight, but a laser is more cool.)
- roywiggins 7y agoThis sounds like another Woodward (or Mach) effect drive proposal, or is it something different? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woodward_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woodward_effect
- gus_massa 7y agoIf I understand correctly, these are different effects. The article uses Special Relativity. With Special Relativity you can't break the laws of conservation of energy and momentum. The Woodward effect uses General Relativity. So the conservations laws are more complicated to define because the space-time is curved. Anyway, the curvature is so small that if it is real it would be very difficult to measure and even more difficult to use it in a thruster.
- aeternum 7y agoThe claimed power to thrust ratio of 165 MW / N does check out as less efficient than a photonic rocket at 150 MW / N assuming the beam is reflected off the craft.
- iamgopal 7y ago165 mega watt per Newton ? Is it theoretical or practical number ?
- trhway 7y agoSun radiation is about 1.4KW/m2 at the Earth orbit and the pressure is 0.00001N/m2 - basically the same numbers as GP mentioned for the photonic drive - can be calculated as 1.5KJ (for roundness of numbers) of photons divided by c which gives 0.000005kg-m/s of momentum per second, double that for bounce and thus 0.00001N. As photons are usually the things being thrown for the thrust in the mass-less thrust schemas, then those photonic thrust numbers seems to be a theoretical limit .
- gus_massa 7y agoIf you are bouncing the photos (like in a solar sail, aka a mirror attached to the back of the starship) then the minimal power is 150MW/N. If you are generating the photons (like in a photon rocket, aka laser attached to the back of the starship) then the minimal power is 300MW/N (and you need a generator). I didn't notice before the 165MW/N in the slides, but their device is not bouncing the photons, so the theoretical minimum is 300MW/N, so it is impossible to use only 165MW/N. So they must have an error (numerical or conceptual) in the calculation. In the slide, the energy is used to accelerate the particles, and then the energy is recovered when the particles return. So the article claim more efficiency, but let's ignore that part. I think the main problem is that the particles will emit a lot of energy in the sharp turn at the top, something like the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyclotron_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyclotron_radiation This radiation is what really push the device. In the sharp turn at the bottom the particles are going more slowly, so the radiation and push is smaller. I don't understand why the calculation using a mix of classical and relativistic formulas give almost the correct result. The error is only in x2 (in the impossible direction), a x2 is not so off. I guess the main problem is assuming that the particles will have the same speed during all the turn???