4 ms·
Most IQ tests only go up to 145. Anything very close to 145 may mean you "ceilinged the test." In other words, your IQ could be even higher, but the test can't
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Most IQ tests only go up to 145. Anything very close to 145 may mean you "ceilinged the test." In other words, your IQ could be even higher, but the test can't measure it beyond that.
Very high IQs can only be accurately assessed at an early age by a qualified professional. So many people will never have an accurate score.
- lonelappde 7y agoHow is it possible for anyone to have a valid very high IQ, since IQ is a percentile test and there's no way to know how many very high IQ people were never properly tested? Very high IQ is fundamentally flawed because IQ is resistant to precise measurement.
- anon1m0us 7y agoSocial systems, like kindergarten, can tell if someone is smart or average or very not smart. Society generally only tests those at the outer boundaries to verify and classify them into groups. You're right, someone who seems average (or totally unknown to social systems), but is actually super genius, might not get tested. It's the "genius in the rice paddy" argument and yes, those exist. Srinivasa Ramanujan was one. That doesn't mean IQ is fundamentally flawed. You don't need to know if someone is 99th percentile or 99.0004 percentile to know they are probably the smartest in the average room of a hundred people and that's what we use IQ to determine.
- confidantlake 7y agoSorry to be nitpicky but this stuff is interesting to me. I would think someone in the 99th percentile would have a 99% chance of being smarter than another random person. In a room full of 100, to be smarter than all 99 other people would be .99^99 or only around a 37% chance of being the smartest in the room. I may be off on this, as I am definitely not in the 99th percentile.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- imgabe 7y ago> Most IQ tests only go up to 145. Anything very close to 145 may mean you "ceilinged the test." In other words, your IQ could be even higher, but the test can't measure it beyond that. This has always bothered me about IQ tests. I mean, how smart is the person who comes up with the test? If your IQ is 120, how could you come up with a question that verifies someone's IQ is 180? Maybe the 180 IQ person would have an answer that is different than yours for reasons that you didn't think of.
- jlawson 7y agoLots of ways. Simple ones: 1. Time. Each test question have 1 minute to answer. The test author took 4 hours to write the question (before having an organization put it through a battery of tests and analyses to validate it). 2. Group effort. Test authors work in big teams; many brains makes for easier insight. 3. Children's IQ is normalized to their age scale; a 7-year-old with IQ 140 isn't cognitively equivalent to a 35-year-ld with such IQ.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoSo, when I was involved in this stuff, this was my best understanding: 1. Tests are tools. By themselves, they tell you nothing of real value. They are useful in the hands of a qualified professional. 2. Tests are game-able. They try to keep questions and tests under wraps because studying for the test or memorizing answers invalidates the test results. 3. Bright kids are horrendously hard to assess, especially if they are 2xE. They have trouble giving the canned "correct" answer. This is something my son calls "guess the teacher's password." In other words "what inane thing do I need to parrot word for word to get the teacher off my back." Example from email list discussion: "Who discovered America?" Teacher's password: Columbus. Gifted kid's reply: "I'm not sure. Columbus was trying to find India and thought he had, which is why Native Americans were called Indians. But it wasn't called America until years later when Amerigo Vespucci traveled to the continents now named after him...(blathers on about more history)...um, what was the question?" 4. Only certain tests can be used to assess IQs above 145. They were having trouble developing and validating an updated test for the higher IQs. 5. You basically can't be accurately assessed by someone with a lower IQ. Smart kids are routinely given hell by adults of more average intelligence who interpret their behavior as bad behavior and can't accommodate them.
- hinkley 7y agoThey have different tests with better accuracy in different ranges. I didn't know this until relatively recently and never understood why I was given 3 tests in as many months. If they think you're slow instead of bored to death they may start with a test looking for developmental delays.
- agumonkey 7y agoare there vetted IQ tests ? anybody can come up with questions and print a figure at the end but how can we know it's worth anything ?
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Most IQ tests only go up to 145. Per Wikipedia, most IQ tests have a highest-reported standard score of 160 [0]; that's also consistent with the highest range for Stanford-Binet 5th Edition and Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children topping out at 160 (the SB5 top range starts at 145.) [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_classification https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_classification
- dan_mctree 7y agoEven if that's the highest achievable, IQ tests designed to be usable for everyone tend to start getting really unreliable above 135 or so. Above that level, you're getting into the territory where test takers basically answer almost all of the reasonable questions right and where those few wrong answers necessarily start having much larger effects on the final score. Because of that, other issues start dominating the results. Random variance, sloppiness, mechanical issues in timed tests, how well you slept, whether there's slightly bad/ambiguous questions, whether you've seen that type of question before, whether you're good under pressure, cultural differences, etc. For example, one serious official test I did included a timed test where you had to decode a string of symbols to text based on some key. I ended up being fast enough at decoding that I was effectively limited by how fast I could scribble down the decoded texts and turn the page back to the code, not by the mental calculations. I imagine others would have had similar issues, making this particular test at best capable of indicating a wide possible range of mental ability, a range which should be particularly inaccurate around the higher ranges as the ratio mentalTime/mechanicalTime decreases. There also just aren't enough high IQ people to really effectively study the accuracy of these tests above those levels. There are no good baselines to compare these people and no real ways of checking whether the differences actually matter in any meaningful way.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> IQ tests designed to be usable for everyone tend to start getting really unreliable above 135 or so. Afaik, that's not a “designed to be usable by everyone” thing; there's test-retest consistency gets progressively lower beyond that point on IQ tests, period. > There also just aren't enough high IQ people to really effectively study the accuracy of these tests above those levels. If that was true, we wouldn't have reliable information that accuracy breaks down in that area, which we do. We can study the accuracy in that range, we just haven't found a way to fix it.