2 ms·
"Obviously this is a very small set?" Nobel Prizes, by definition, are given for groundbreaking results. Almost by definition, most "groundbreaking" results ar
by mcguire 7y ago
"Obviously this is a very small set?"
Nobel Prizes, by definition, are given for groundbreaking results. Almost by definition, most "groundbreaking" results are wrong. Even given everything else as equal, it is unsurprising that Nobel-winning results are rejected at least once.
- throwaway_law 7y agoTo the best of my knowledge 8 papers were rejected that ultimately won the prize...over 500 Nobel Prizes have been awarded so I am not sure why you expect papers to get rejected at least once. Again the basis of these rejections were not on the merits (or results) as you suggest, rather, because of issues with names of the papers, backlog, and deferring to other journals which may be better fits for the topic.