4 ms·
Don't dismiss this article just because of the main image. It's a image of an EmDrive that is another impossible device that doesn't work but is totally unrelat
by gus_massa 7y ago
Don't dismiss this article just because of the main image. It's a image of an EmDrive that is another impossible device that doesn't work but is totally unrelated to the device in this article.
The main part is:
> This mass changing isn’t prohibited by physics. Einstein’s theory of special relativity says that objects gain mass as they are driven towards the speed of light, an effect that must be accounted for in particle accelerators.
In special relativity, when the charged particles accelerate and decelerate they emit electromagnetic radiation. The whole process conserve the energy and momentum. The momentum that the device provides is compensated by the momentum of the electromagnetic radiation, aka photons.
So this device should work. It doesn't break the laws of physics. It produce some photons in the intended direction and more photons in other random directions. So it is just a very inefficient photon thruster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon_rocket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon_rocket. It's like attaching a laser to the back of your starship, and then adding some lamp to illuminate in every direction to make it more inefficient. So you can dismiss this article after all.
EDIT: I copied most of this comment to other comment in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21253796 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21253796 , but the other comment was later moved here, so there is a lot of overlap. The other article at least don't use a big photo of an EmDrive.
- rurounijones 7y ago> Don't dismiss this article just because of the main image. It's a image of an EmDrive that is another impossible device that doesn't work Do you have a link for that? I haven't been following the EM Drive but a quick google now suggests that a team in Germany believe that they found the reason for the anomolous readings but I cannot find anything definitive.
- dmix 7y agoLast time it came up on HN people mentioned there was a lot of woo related to Em Drives on the internet so be wary.
- knzhou 7y agoThe problem with EM drive testing in general is that you're looking for a signal (thrust) which should be zero, while pumping an enormous amount of energy into a system, and declaring any nonzero reading as success. Physicists know from experience that this is a recipe for fooling yourself. There are a million things that could imitate the purported signal. In the last EM drive test I looked at, the "thrust" was pointing in the wrong direction, and moreover it perfectly matched the temperature curve of the apparatus, even though no theories of the EM drive say it should. That is a dead giveaway that the temperature is causing a fake signal, which e.g. could happen by thermal expansion messing up the meters. In general, the EM drive seems like a playground for sloppy experimentalists, because what anybody else would call a failure can be reported as a success.
- taneq 7y ago> declaring any nonzero reading as success And as anyone who's worked with sensors should know, if your sensor is reading exactly zero, that means your sensor is broken.
- ummonk 7y agoYeah, reminds me of this overly complicated flashlight that the media was going on about several years back: https://www.fastcompany.com/1837966/mustafas-space-drive-egyptian-students-quantum-physics-invention https://www.fastcompany.com/1837966/mustafas-space-drive-egy...