3 ms·
This should not be something cash-strapped schools are spending $450,000 on. This is just public-private transfer into the coffers of Blizzard, Nintendo et al.
by sneak 7y ago
This should not be something cash-strapped schools are spending $450,000 on. This is just public-private transfer into the coffers of Blizzard, Nintendo et al.
If it has merit, it has merit with free software.
- soared 7y agoThere is no mention of being cash-strapped in the article, unless I missed it?
- sneak 7y agoPublic schools in the US are almost universally cash-strapped. Regardless, my point stands: no school should be spending a half million in tax money on corporate video games. There are plenty of cheap/free games that could serve the purpose just fine, if indeed there is any educational merit whatsoever to this initiative (which I highly doubt).
- CDSlice 7y agoAre there cheap/free games that kids actually want to play? It's not like this is a mandatory class, it is an elective like joining the football team. If the kids don't want to play the games the team competes in they won't join in the first place. View this more like schools spending lots of money on football teams, not as an educational experiment.
- learc83 7y agoHow is this any different than public schools buying baseballs from Rawlings (co-owned by the MLB). Or football pads, basketball goals etc... I guarantee that the district in question spends far more than $450k purchasing sports equipment from corporations. And since public schools are mostly locally funded, some districts aren't cash strapped. >my point stands: no school should be spending a half million in tax money on corporate video games. This decision is made at the district level, if the people don't like it, they can very easily vote in a different school board. The local voters are the ones who get to decide what they "should" spend their tax money on. > if indeed there is any educational merit whatsoever to this initiative (which I highly doubt). Participation in after school activities has been shown to positively impact educational performance.
- cthalupa 7y agoThis is meant to be a way to keep kids out of trouble, not teach them physics. The goal is to keep them in a controlled and safe setting until their parents are home and able to pick them up, rather than unsupervised for hours at a time. Kids don't want to play Tux Racer, they want to play Fortnite. There isn't any free software games out there that are going to attract the attention of these kids the way the AAA titles like Fortnite, World of Warcraft, and League of Legends do, and that means that without having access to those titles, the kids aren't going to join the club, and aren't going to be in that controlled and safe setting.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoMadden is cheaper in terms of liability, game day costs, and grades than real football. I don't buy the cost argument.
- sneak 7y agoNeither one has anything to do with education.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- arioid 7y agoAt just ~$7,000 per campus for an after school program that likely requires staffing, some equipment, software, etc. I don't see it as a ridiculous thing for them to justify. It provides a community like any other sports program would, at a significantly lower cost, and to a completely different audience, who wasn't participating in the other extracurricular offerings.