5 ms·
Violence is entertaining on some level. Even cutesy games like Mario have him stomping on mushrooms and turtles and avoiding deadly obstacles. I've also heard i
by chrisco255 7y ago
Violence is entertaining on some level. Even cutesy games like Mario have him stomping on mushrooms and turtles and avoiding deadly obstacles. I've also heard it said that all good stories involve conflict. It's a part of human psychology for better or worse. It's why we watch sports. It's why we play video games. It's why dogs play fight. It's deeply embedded in our chemistry.
- learc83 7y agoConflict doesn't require violence though. It's just that physical conflict is the easiest kind of conflict to represent.
- KirinDave 7y agoIt's also the easiest to fund, what with several western governments funding games that train basic tactical skills that mimic modern urban small-scale warfare.
- learc83 7y agoThe games you're talking about aren't particularly useful for training, their only real use if for recruiting. And the number of games being funded by militaries is so small compared to the size of the market, that it basically has no impact as far as ease of funding goes. That's not to say that violent games aren't easier to fund. As I said, they are certainly easier to make, easier to market etc...
- KirinDave 7y ago> Violence is entertaining on some level. Even cutesy games like Mario have him stomping on mushrooms and turtles and avoiding deadly obstacles. Sure, but so are lots of things. It's just a cultural artifact of the west's love and expectation of violent solutions to conflict that we glorify this activity over others. For example, a game of Go is surely a conflict between two people, but unlike a game of Overwatch or the like it involves a lot fewer guns, bombs, and patchy plots about world governments authorizing unilateral violence. > I've also heard it said that all good stories involve conflict. This is a cultural lens. Lots of stories don't have an external conflict and they can be great. You know what's a great example of this? The Moive Jacob's Ladder. It was about someone reflecting on their life with pride and regret, not actual conflict. People frame this, unsurprisingly, as "Man vs Nature". But we might as well also define it as "Human Overcomes Hardship." And that line seems much more natural. Surely much of our hardship is inflicted by our peers, but is it a deliberate "versus" scenario? I suspect not.
- learc83 7y ago>Sure, but so are lots of things. It's just a cultural artifact of the west's love and expectation of violent solutions to conflict that we glorify this activity over others. For example, a game of Go is surely a conflict between two people, but unlike a game of Overwatch or the like it involves a lot fewer guns, bombs, and patchy plots about world governments authorizing unilateral violence. I don't think this really has anything to do with the west. Non western cultures have been producing violent art before the west even existed, and if you look at modern non-western movies and games, they aren't less likely to involve violence. As for Go, people in countries that play Go also play plenty of games that are violent, and plenty of people in the west play Checkers.
- KirinDave 7y agoI can't work out what this post is saying. What do you mean? My point about Go was that Go is still a game of conflict, but it's not a game where we murder one another or try to anthropomorphize the pieces to make it more like actual killing.
- learc83 7y ago> It's just a cultural artifact of the west's love and expectation of violent solutions to conflict that we glorify this activity over others. The implication to this sentence is that the west is unique in this regard. The only non-violent exemplar game you presented being a non-western game strengthens this implication. The point of my post was to make an argument against that suggestion. If you didn't mean to imply that, then it really has no point. However, if that was the case why mention the west at all? Particularly when the OP gave a non-western example (Mario) in the first place.
- KirinDave 7y ago> The implication to this sentence is that the west is unique in this regard. The only non-violent exemplar game you presented being a non-western game strengthens this implication. Unique? No. Distinct in character, yes. > The only non-violent exemplar game you presented being a non-western game strengthens this implication. Minecraft. Night in the Woods. Slenderman. Kerbal Space Program. SpaceChem, TIS-80, InfiniMiner, InfiniFactory, a huge portion of Stellaris's gameplay. Untitled Goose Game. Online Go. Candy Crush. Many many subgames in Roblox. Can you stop this line of questioning now? It's boring.
- bilbo0s 7y ago>Violence is entertaining on some level... a part of human psychology So is sex, but I'd wager there are people who would be against schoolkids playing video games simulating it. I think that's the same sort of argument that HN user 'kirindave' is making with respect to violence. I make video games. Violent ones. But it's fair for people to question whether we, as an industry, can come up with something other than death as a metaphor for success. Particularly as we try to grow the tent and move games from being just video games to more, sort of, cultural artifacts.
- KirinDave 7y ago> I think that's the same sort of argument that HN user 'kirindave' is making with respect to violence. Not quite, but it is an interesting one. Folks are very comfortable with games depicting repeated fatal violence. Would they feel the same way about a game involving repeated rape? Surely not, at least in the US, surely?! But then again, Pick Up Artist games that evaluate your ability to emotionally manipulate people into sex are popular enough that they've broken into the world of big youtubers and The reason these are different is because of the way our culture normalizes conflict and normalizes different kinds of dominance. We've seen games that challenge this (even when they're by people who clearly aren't). Night in the Woods, Slenderman, Minecraft & Roblox, every racing game, Kerbal Space Program and Untitled Goose Game? All of these games are famous and made a major impact on the gaming social structure and they don't focus on pulling triggers or capturing points.
- chrisco255 7y agoMinecraft involves hiding from things trying to kill you at night. Roblox has guns and violence, it's just not bloody or realistically depicted. It's cartoonist violence. Slenderman is a survival horror game so by definition it's violent. Mario Kart takes the fun of racing games to a higher level by enabling you to attack other racers with weapons. Kerbal Space Program is a good counter example. It's a sim game. I think sim games are fun. But if I'm with a large group of friends I'd pick Smash Bros. over Kerbal.
- 7y ago
- asdfman123 7y ago> Violence is entertaining on some level Maybe more generally, I learned through improv training that changes in relative status are entertaining to humans. It's interesting when a peasant pulls one over on a king. Maybe we are inherently interested in things that threaten to change social hierarchy. Observing changes in it is important!
- arrosenberg 7y agoPsychologically, I think this boils down to the fact that our brains like novelty and surprise. A King punching down on a subject isn't novel, but a subject punching up on the King (and living to tell about it!) is.