4 ms·
Interesting concept. Btw a bit of spin, presenting them as about the same as modern Homo Sapiens. They killed and ate their neighbors when times were tough; th
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Interesting concept.
Btw a bit of spin, presenting them as about the same as modern Homo Sapiens. They killed and ate their neighbors when times were tough; they had a very hard time mastering crafts more complex than 'break a rock'.
- PhasmaFelis 7y ago> They killed and ate their neighbors when times were tough So have modern humans.
- mistrial9 7y agoreference, please
- nocut12 7y agohttps://arstechnica.com/science/2019/03/climate-change-may-have-driven-a-band-of-neanderthals-to-cannibalism/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/03/climate-change-may-h... Certainly not unheard of for modern humans though...
- nocut12 7y agoAs far as technology, modern humans weren't really too different at the time (in Europe at least). And of course, modern humans and neanderthals were similar enough that we were willing/able to interbreed, which certainly says something. I do think people overstate how similar we were though -- we don't have any super clear examples of neanderthal artwork (people make arguments, but this stuff isn't exactly Chauvet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neanderthal#Art https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neanderthal#Art). To me, this seems to indicate that their brains might have worked pretty differently.
- benj111 7y ago"we were willing/able to interbreed, which certainly says something" Does it? Men like to spread their seed, and I'm not sure what the rules were regarding giving women a choice in the matter. I'm guessing rape wasn't in their vocabulary though.
- AlotOfReading 7y agoThe ability to produce viable offspring is generally considered the primary differentiating characteristic between species and subspecies. That's one of a number of arguments in the debate over whether Neanderthals should be named H. neanderthalensis or H. sapiens neanderthalensis.
- benj111 7y agoI was addressing the willing rather than the able.
- ncmncm 7y agoThat criterion has had to be abandoned, replaced with "forms reproductive groups with practical boundaries". Sometimes a river is that boundary, or a preferred prey species, a mating strategy, or odor preference. Otherwise, we cannot distinguish bear, dog, or great-cat species.
- derefr 7y agoIsn't there already a separate word—subspecies—for "isolated reproductive groups, with different phenotypes, which could still interbreed if the opportunity arose"? My understanding was that every phenotypically-distinct isolated reproductive group was considered a subspecies until its genetics diverged enough to have speciated, at which point it was now a species. It seems to me that if e.g. American black bears and Asian black bears can interbreed, then we could call them all one species—black bears—and put all their subspecies together in into that taxonomic category. Maybe with some optional taxonomic level between "species" and "subspecies" for describing their phenotypic groupings. But I see, looking at various sources, that those two types of bears are indeed considered separate species. Why do we do that? What's better/more useful about drawing the species boundary there?
- ncmncm 7y ago"Species" is an organizational convenience for biologists. Nature doesn't have such a boundary. It just has varying degrees of reproductive compatibility, inclination, and opportunity. "Subspecies" is a concession to what lumpers call splitters.
- trhway 7y ago>Btw a bit of spin, presenting them as about the same as modern Homo Sapiens. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/02/neanderthals-arent-grunting-club-wielding-idiots-stereotype https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/02/neande... (and there is link in the article to the study itslef) "After careful study of archaeological records, scientists in the Netherlands found evidence to suggest that Neanderthals were just as advanced in culture, weaponry and hunting as our human forebears. According to those scientists, the misunderstanding came about because people had been comparing Neanderthals to their successors, who had more advanced tools, rather than their contemporaries. Which is rather like assuming I am more advanced than my parents because I know how to work an iPhone. But this doesn't make my parents any less intelligent … just obsolete and unable to function in this modern, fast-paced world."
- ncmncm 7y agoI find elsewhere an assertion that what distinguishes neanderthal behavior from modern humans' most reliably is a total absence of trade networks.