3 ms·
Maybe not, but we can bound the number of people they kill at much lower than other forms of power generation.
by mlyle 7y ago
Maybe not, but we can bound the number of people they kill at much lower than other forms of power generation.
- pvaldes 7y agoAt this moment talking about how few people has killed nuclear versus other energy sources is BS. We can compare both values only if we forget that we talk about a stuff that will remain lethal for thousands years, in a world that is getting unstable at a fast pace, with politicians even more unstable that act in totally random ways. We will not have a trustable nuclear body count value until many generations in the future. Is not over until is over.
- mlyle 7y ago> only if we forget that we talk about a stuff that will remain lethal for thousands years, But rapidly becomes less lethal, with the vast majority of the risk removed in tens of years. Vs. many kinds of chemical waste which are potent effectively forever.
- brazzy 7y agoWTF? That is pretty much the exact opposite of reality.
- mlyle 7y agoElectricity Generation and Health, Markandya & Wilkinson, The Lancet, 2007. It finds a death rate of 0.074 deaths per terawatt-hour for nuclear, compared to 24.5 for coal, 18.4 for oil, and 2.8 for gas. The edges of the nuclear and gas confidence interval get somewhat close to each other but do not overlap. While there was not enough data for the author to estimate the rate for solar and wind, subsequent estimates are about 2 for solar and 10 for wind. Of the 0.074, 0.003 deaths are non-occupational from accidents; 0.022 are total deaths from accidents. The vast majority of this 0.022 is not radiological, but instead ordinary industrial and mining accidents where people are in traffic accidents, asphyxiate, are killed by hot steam, or crushed to death. The rest is from various kinds of air pollution impacts in the nuclear fuel and transportation chain. Even if we have a horrid accident that has 1000x the impact of previous accidents, we will not reach the death rates associated with other sources of power.