6 ms·
As far as I'm concerned, cars have no place in Manhattan, and should be banned from all but a handful of designated roads. Maybe give out special licenses to th
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
As far as I'm concerned, cars have no place in Manhattan, and should be banned from all but a handful of designated roads. Maybe give out special licenses to the disabled, or anyone else who physically requires a car—that way, they'll actually be able to get around at reasonable speeds, too.
- chongli 7y agoIf you're disabled, wouldn't it be better to use a motorized wheelchair? Then you can go anywhere that's wheelchair accessible, without creating any risks for pedestrians.
- phoobahr 7y agoThat doesn’t work for the visually impaired, for those with epilepsy, for the extremely short of stature, for persons without hands, for those who are aged or living with progressive impairments who shouldn’t drive but for whom a $10k-$50k power chair is not an appropriate solution. Not to mention those who could not afford them even if they wanted them. I won’t even touch social issues related to hierarchies of disability. You know what works for everyone though? Dropping the pretender that everyone “needs” personal transport and embracing accessible transit and the infrastructure that requires and offers.
- chongli 7y agoWhen I said disabled people, I meant disabled with respect to walking, not driving. Most of the groups of people you mentioned are capable of walking on their own and so would be just fine in a car-free, walkable neighbourhood. For those who cannot walk but also somehow cannot use a motorized wheelchair but can use a car? I am not sure who would fall into this group of people, but it has to be extremely small. We should be able to find some form of accommodation for them. As for people who cannot afford a wheelchair or other accessibility device? I think we should fund these for people, using public funds. It's the most humane thing to do, as it provides for the greatest potential autonomy, which I think everyone has a right to.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> For those who cannot walk but also somehow cannot use a motorized wheelchair but can use a car? I am not sure who would fall into this group of people, but it has to be extremely small. We should be able to find some form of accommodation for them. Something to keep in mind, the New York City subway is by and large not wheelchair accessible! They're trying to improve it, but there's just a lot of old, small stations. I've also seen wheelchairs physically unable to fit into train cars when it's crowded. NYC right now is just a really bad place to live if you're not able bodied. I actually think giving partially-exclusive access to the roads might be the best solution.
- ses1984 7y agoI think Manhattan is way to big to ban cars from the entire island. They could do it gradually and add public streetcars to main thoroughfares, but the way things are now, it would not work to straight up ban cars today.
- adjkant 7y agoThe entire island is well covered by the subway except for going crosstown past the 100's which is served solidly by buses for that use case. Not to mention the many buses that most wealthy people ignore. No need for public streetcars when you already have buses that will be running quite ahead of schedule, as seen with 14th street :) I'm for gradually removing for other reasons, but the size is not the prohibitive factor.
- cheschire 7y agoThe benefit of street cars is the centralization of power generation away from the population. The downside is having to build rails into the roads. An alternative could be running power lines over the roads and making buses electric.
- adjkant 7y agoVery fair for longterm, I'm thinking for immediate turnaround. I think with an aggressive enough plan (which isn't going to happen in reality) you could do this without any notable spending increases in 2-3 years by just stopping cars and maybe buying a few more busses as the main cost. After that if it continues to work out, streetcars absolutely make sense. Basically just doubling the subway lines at that point. Probably ideal to cover crosstown first across places like 14th, through Central Park, 34th, 116th, 125th, Canal, and Houston, and then you can sure up the avenues with streetcars, probably starting with Harlem through the upper east side. What a fun project to imagine honestly wow.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoLong term, I would rather we build more subway lines than powered rails (or similar) for streetcars, even though subways are more expensive. Even without cars, we want that above ground space for pedestrians and cyclists.
- thebradbain 7y agoInstead of an outright ban, I'd love to see price-prohibitive congestion pricing and street-parking pricing (prohibitive in the sense that it wouldn't make financial sense to drive a car as the primary mode of transport, not that if someone needed to occasionally use a car they couldn't) within Manhattan, with the aforementioned provisions carved out for those who demonstrate a need for a car. That way, for any of those stubborn and wealthy enough who refuse to use public transit, we can direct all funds generated to improving public transit -- not just reliability and frequency, but also line expansions and remodeling the deteriorating stations and upgrading train/bus interiors to create a first-class transit experience for the rest of us and to finally prioritize public transit correctly in the US. Singapore already operates a similar (but stricter and broader) scheme: https://www.cnn.com/2017/10/31/asia/singapore-cars/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2017/10/31/asia/singapore-cars/index.htm....
- clairity 7y agoi'm a big fan of mixed-use streets. for example, on a 6-lane street, you'd have sidewalks for foot traffic, 1 grade-separated lane each way for bikes/scooters, 1 protected lane each way for buses, and 1 lane each way for cars, with the car lane being progressively congestion-priced (by income/wealth so that you don't completely shut out the poor from driving into the city when necessary). for efficiency and traffic calming, narrow the car lane to 9-10 ft wide (rather than the typical 11-12 ft in the US), but leave 11-12 ft wide lanes for buses (and emergency vehicles). 6-8 ft bike lanes allows 2-abreast biking/scootering. widen sidewalks and plant trees along all of them. there should be no free street parking, except for the disabled (and maybe temporary commercial use), limited to side streets rather than major thoroughfares. i'm cheering for LA to do this, with it's awesome weather, endlessly-wide streets, and bad and worsening traffic.
- ascagnel_ 7y agoI love this idea — it really just needs to be expensive enough to make commuting by public transit a better option than by car. There are too many one-off cases where you’d need a car (for one anecdotal example, having to drive a family member home after surgery was an uncommon case where I drove into Manhattan, instead of taking public transit) to make a total ban workable without seriously disrupting people’s lives in other ways.
- msla 7y agoThe problem isn't so much people who require a car to get around as people who can't get around and therefore rely on deliveries. It isn't really feasible to supply them with any reasonable amount of groceries and other stuff by bike or bus. And I'm assuming, possibly over-optimistically, that "no cars" doesn't include ambulances and police cars and fire trucks and so on. And I'm also assuming, almost definitely over-optimistically, that people who have jobs where they may get called in for emergencies at all hours of the day or night will get ultra-special Manhattan driving licenses. After all, medical people don't live at the hospital when they're on call, and they're not going to.