3 ms·
The users agreed to publish their details publicly on LinkedIn. It’s normal that anyone can access those details and use them however they like.
by Nextgrid 7y ago
The users agreed to publish their details publicly on LinkedIn. It’s normal that anyone can access those details and use them however they like.
- kovek 7y agoWhat if there could be a robot.txt kind of setting that users could use to prevent being scraped?
- jakeogh 7y agoPointless unless you want a one world governement to enforce a law monoculture.
- smohare 7y agoThere is a broader ethical discussion of how to treat data, nominally public, that is increasingly collected, persisted and analyzed indefinitely by adversarial agents. It seems clear to me that a more nuanced categorization is required. This data is not public in the same sense as an uttered word was in a town square a hundred years ago. Imagine being denied job opportunities because some company has analyzed the careers of the last 25 generations of your ancestors and deemed your lineage to be inadequate?
- pergadad 7y agoYou mean maybe for your LinkedIn general profile info to be public, but not for the old profile data or the metadata of when your changed what to be public. It's not per se secret or hidden but it's also not intended to be kept and processed. This is also a clear case where GDPR would come in. This is personal data, whether intentional or not, and the scraper is obliged to conform to EU laws if they scrape data on EU citizens - including eg information rights and deletion.
- lucb1e 7y agoThere are privacy settings though, and recruiters used to be able to see more than other non-contacts. I'm not sure if that is still the case, but so what is being shared is not always exactly obvious to the user.
- alkonaut 7y agoI don't agree to republish them. Just because they are publicly accessible on SiteA doesn't mean I have agreed to have them be published on SiteB does it?
- mmcwilliams 7y agoThat isn't what's really being ruled on here, though. Republishing the data is still restricted via copyright, but the data may exist in an internal database that SiteB uses to do X. The question at hand is whether or not SiteB (or more appropriately CompanyB) is able to automatically download the content on SiteA or have to make an intern manually copy and paste the data into a spreadsheet.