4 ms·
I've heard plenty of people on HN say password managers should ignore autocomplete=off and I agree with them. Because that setting is mostly applied by organisa
by michaelt 7y ago
I've heard plenty of people on HN say password managers should ignore autocomplete=off and I agree with them. Because that setting is mostly applied by organisations like banks who incorrectly think they're making things more secure by doing so.
IMHO there are cases where autocomplete=off should be respected, and other times when it shouldn't be - it's certainly not as simple as saying always do or always don't respect it.
- kalleboo 7y agoPassword managers should ignore autocomplete=off in login screens, but not in administration screens where you’re editing other people’s credentials. IMO the distinction could be made to not automatically fill when the autocomplete=off but instead add a button to let the user initiate it
- rhizome 7y ago>not in administration screens where you’re editing other people’s credentials <input type="password" name="other-users-password" id="other-users-password">...
- kalleboo 7y agoThat was recommended by Google 3 years ago, but there are a bunch of reports in the bug reporter thread that that doesn’t work now. And credentials go beyond passwords - names, usernames, ID numbers
- Rapzid 7y agoWell, all major browsers now ignore it on password fields so the browser ship has sailed on that one: > This is the behavior in Firefox (since version 38), Google Chrome (since 34), and Internet Explorer (since version 11). - MDN
- Osiris 7y agoI recently received a ticket from or security team to add "autocomplete=off" to all our password input fields. I was pretty sure that it wouldn't do anything except make the security team feel better.