3 ms·
There's a vitally important lesson in this for all startups - pricing is about value, not cost. It might cost a billionth of a cent for a network to handle an
by jdietrich 16y ago
There's a vitally important lesson in this for all startups - pricing is about value, not cost.
It might cost a billionth of a cent for a network to handle an SMS, but that's largely irrelevant. If you're running late to meet a friend, ten cents to send a message of apology is a stone cold bargain. If you're a hypersocial teenager, $10 a month is a small price to stay in constant contact with everyone you know. Rates charged for SMS aren't set relative to their cost, but relative to the price of a voice minute - for a short message it is invariably cheaper to text rather than talk, which seems more than fair to most customers.
There's a whole class of high-margin products - SMS, soda, razor blades - that people regard as overpriced when it's pointed out to them, but buy anyway. You could call that a scam, but I just see it as an artifact of the complexities and contradictions of how we think about price and value.
All too often I see startups charging what they think is fair rather than what their target customers are willing to pay. From the perspective of a geek who likes tinkering with technology, any price is too much for something you could hack together in a couple of hours. The average end-user neither knows nor cares whether a piece of software was a trivial bit of scripting or an epic production of Duke Nukem Forever proportions. Their sense of value is calibrated completely differently, based on what they are used to paying for products and services. In many industries, the worst possible mistake is to charge too little. The value of your work bears no correlation to the effort or technical sophistication that went into it. The multi-billion dollar value of SMS is proof positive of that.
- morrow 16y agoI agree with you, but I think the "overpriced" label still has real meaning for the high-margin products you mentioned. A company's ability to charge higher margins can be for several reasons, whether they be legitimate competitive advantages: first to market, superior products, better marketing, better image, vertical-integration, etc. Or less legitimate/illegitimate: monopolies, oligopolies, collusion, anti-competitive practices, underpaid labor, etc. For SMS in particular, the only way they get away with charging so much is consumers don't have much choice in the matter, as all the major US carriers charge for SMS, and the cost is minimal to them for the reasons described in the link. Their justification for doing so then seems to fall on the less legitimate side of the scale. For Coke, since their value is based in some part on their recipe, you could argue their justification for their margins is, at least in part, due to the exclusivity and superiority of the product, rather simply relying on collusion or being a member of an oligopoly. This isn't to say that companies shouldn't charge whatever the market will pay, but charging high margins for the wrong reasons hurts the brand's image, erodes customer loyalty, and most importantly means they probably aren't innovating -- leading to more problems down the road. Apple's strategy vs. Microsoft's, $17 CD sales vs. $1 digital downloads, and iphone users lamenting being stuck on ATT (and possibly now switching to verizon) are all examples of this having an effect. That said, I doubt any startups are capable of or willing to rely on illegitimate methods to maintain high margins, I just wanted to argue that there can be negative consequences for existing companies who choose to do so without legitimate justification.