6 ms·
And how much has it cost Microsoft? Apple was able to successfully take the base of MacOS and port it’s operating system to a much lower spec phone back in 2007
by scarface74 7y ago
And how much has it cost Microsoft? Apple was able to successfully take the base of MacOS and port it’s operating system to a much lower spec phone back in 2007 and came to dominate the smart phone market (in profit they only thing that matters), the tablet market where MS failed repeatedly, not to mention it was able to port the base OS to everything from Watches and TV set top boxes - all things that Microsoft tried and failed at.
MS being so concerned with backwards compatibility has slowed down its ability to move fast into new markets even compared to Google.
If you are “building your software” for desktop PCs (or Macs) , you’re building on top of market that is becoming less important every year. There is no energy or investments going into desktop computers besides games and even that market is small. The only companies making real money in computer software are Microsoft and Adobe and even they are pivoting more toward browser based software and mobile.
Do you think that Apple should still bundle a PPC emulator with modern Macs? A 68K emulator?
Not being willing to drop legacy code comes with its own costs in maintenance and increases the vulnerability surface. Just the fact that there are over a half dozen ways to represent a string in Windows has led to security vulnerabilities, not to mention all of the other legacy cruft.
- pjmlp 7y agoApparently people keep forgetting that laptops and 2-1 hybrids are desktops as well. Microsoft is doing pretty well there, to the point that in many shopping mall shops in Europe, Android tablets have been slowly being replaced by hybrid laptops running Windows 10.
- scarface74 7y agoMicrosoft Surface sells are estimated to be 20% of Mac sales. https://www.zdnet.com/article/surface-by-the-numbers-how-microsoft-successfully-reinvented-the-pc/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/surface-by-the-numbers-how-mic... Apple sells about 20 million Macs a year and even that pales in comparison to mobile sells. The total sales of computers is estimated to be around 63 million last quarter according to Gartner. Compared to 310 million cell phones (https://www.androidcentral.com/phone-sales-continue-decline-while-huawei-increases-sales-50 https://www.androidcentral.com/phone-sales-continue-decline-...)
- catalogia 7y ago> "Microsoft Surface sells are estimated to be 20% of Mac sales." I'd say hardware sales like that are impressive, coming from a software company. Apple's original core competency was creating hardware, with the software existing to drive hardware sales. (That there is a "hack" in "hackintosh" suggests that this should still be true today. They don't want you to buy their OS and run it on your own hardware, but they're fine with you buying their hardware and running your own OS on it.) Microsoft's core 'competency' has always been software. (I am of course abusing the term 'competency' in this case...)
- scarface74 7y agoApple’s Mac sales are minuscule though in the grand scheme of things and only a small part of their revenue.
- catalogia 7y agoTheir other products, while locked down to forbid running third party operating systems, are still nevertheless hardware. With the exception of itunes and safari on Windows, virtually everything Apple does involves selling hardware to consumers.
- coldtea 7y agoThe surface line is still very much behind in sales compared to Apple.
- pjmlp 7y agoThere are plenty of other options to buy Windows 10 devices from, including Android vendors like Samsung and Huawei.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd all together they sell less than a fifth of the number of mobile devices being sold. There is a reason that MS is running away from Windows and that they put .Net Framework in permanent maintenance mode. They don’t even want to spend money supporting their own browser engine.
- pjmlp 7y agoApp store gold rush is gone. As for the .NET remark, you seem to be really pissed off about something, always bitching about MS stuff. .NET couldn't be better.
- scarface74 7y agoI’ve never said that .Net wasn’t great. I said it would be dumb to tie your career to .Net Framework that is Windows only and is maintenance mode instead of .Net Core. I’ve had enough conversations with you on HN that I know you know the difference. And I’ve said that most of the energy is going toward mobile, the web and services. No one outside of game makers are making money selling mobile apps. But they are making money selling services that users interact with over the web and mobile - not the desktop.
- pjmlp 7y ago.NET Framework and .NET Core are .NET. Windows is doing pretty well across 80% of desktop, laptop and 2-1 hybrid devices. As mentioned, I spent the last 5 years doing Forms/WPF/UWP, and there is plenty of work there. Just as there is for anyone wanting to bother with either Qt or macOS. At least in Europe no one starves by focusing on being a desktop developer.
- Pmop 7y agoMicrosoft did manage to port Windows to mobile platforms, with success to some extent. Notice that it's Windows for Desktop that maintains support for legacy software. Support for legacy software isn't necessarily detrimental to success. Microsoft's lost battle in phone market has nothing to do with it. In addition, Microsoft seems to be doing just fine in the other markets, and it's been growing on cloud, which we may consider to be a new market. The whole 'support legacy and risk being stuck on the past' argument makes no sense.
- scarface74 7y agoWhat “success” was that? Sure it had some modicum of success with Win CE/Win32/and .Net compact framework but success was fleeting. The development environment was nice but they ended up completely killing backwards compatibility with the newer versions and abandoned all of the enterprise/ruggedized devices. The last version of Visual Studio that supported then was VS 2007 while there were plenty of $1000+ ruggedized devices and kiosks that still ran Windows CE - I developed for them back in the day.
- threeseed 7y agoWindows on mobile was a mess. You couldn't just take any Windows app and run it. It had to be a specially designed UWP one of which there weren't many. And then there was different OSs depending on whether it was on ARM or not, running UWP exclusively or not. I am a developer and even I couldn't understand the rules. It's unquestionable that Microsoft's decision not to encourage developers to rewrite their apps (or at least offer a Carbon solution) really hurt them in the mobile space.
- cwyers 7y agoYou can't run any Mac apps on iOS. I think Microsoft's big problem on mobile was if anything a first-mover disadvantage; they had Windows Mobile designed to compete with Blackberry and Java ME devices. The iPhone was able to basically produce a second-generation product that bested all of those things. Microsoft wasn't able to catch up the second generation by the time the market was entrenched, and I suspect that it was less an engineering challenge caused by backwards compatibility (backwards compatibility didn't hinder the NT kernel from powering the Xbox One) and more of a cultural challenge.
- afroboy 7y agoUnless you have shares in Apple your whole point is invalid, you're looking to this from Apple point of view which is very good for her business but not mine, i care about the company that give me the best solutions to my problems not the company that's can milk me the last day of my life.
- scarface74 7y agoNot having to worry about yet another security vulnerability caused by 10 year old code does impact me. It’s also nice to have other Apple products that MS could never produce because they worshipped at the alter of backwards compatibility. Running outdated code on a bloated operating system doesn’t benefit me.
- gamblor956 7y agoWhat product on the PC does the Apple have that MS could never produce?
- scarface74 7y agoHow is MS doing with phones? tablets? Watches ($15-$20 billion dollars in revenue and profitable), heck even set top boxes?
- gamblor956 7y agoI was not aware that phones, tablets, and watches were on the PC... But on that note: the Surface tablet is considered the best hybrid PC in its class, and that includes Apple devices. The XBox has sold several tens of millions of units in each generation. Oh, and here's the kicker: Microsoft's hardware is universally superior to Apple hardware in the same class. You can still use Microsoft hardware from the turn-of-the-century. Even Zunes still work (though you need to connect them as MTP devices instead of using the Zune Store). I have an HP Windows Phone that still works, and still handles call better than an iPhone. I don't know anyone who still has an Apple laptop, PC, or other hardware more than 10 years old. Apple products simply aren't built to last more than a handful of years before they fall apart because you're using them wrong.
- pmiller2 7y agoHow much has it cost MSFT? They have a trillion dollar market cap, so I would say that’s not a particularly relevant question.
- scarface74 7y agoWell Uber also has a nice market cap. Only on HN is market cap more important than silly things like profit. But MS recent success has nothing to do with maintaining backwards compatibility. They had to purposefully move away from emphasizing Windows to be successful and move to the cloud, Office on other platforms, abandoning IE, give up the idea of ever selling Windows to end users when it isn’t bundled with the computer, building IE on top of Chrome, and by announcing an Android device. Does that seem like Windows was a winning strategy?
- coldtea 7y agoBlackberry had a nice market cap too, a year or so before they went under...
- gamblor956 7y agoAnd how much has it cost Microsoft? Are we really worried about how much money it will cost to the company with the largest free-cash pile in the world? They have literally tens of billions of dollars of cash literally just sitting around doing nothing. They can afford to throw 0.0001% of that at maintaining backward compatibility.
- cpach 7y agoAs pointed out elsewhere in this thread, it’s not just about money. It’s also about path dependence – if you are dedicated to backward compatibility there are lots of changes you can’t easily do to your products. It can hinder innovation.
- stuartd 7y agoIt's worth considering the different markets here. Raymond Chen [0] posted this in 2006 - "On the importance of backwards compatibility for large corporations" [1] > Representatives from the IT department of a major worldwide corporation came to Redmond and took time out of their busy schedule to give a talk on how their operations are set up. I was phenomenally impressed. These people know their stuff. Definitely a world-class operation. One of the tidbits of information they shared with us is some numbers about the programs they have to support. Their operations division is responsible for 9,000 different install scripts for their employees around the world. > That was not a typo. > Nine thousand. > This highlighted for me the fact that backwards compatibility is crucial for adoption in the corporate world. Do the math. Suppose they could install, test and debug ten programs each business day, in my opinion, a very optimistic estimate. Even at that rate, it would take them three years to get through all their scripts. This isn’t a company that bought some software ten years ago and don’t have the source code. They have the source code for all of their scripts. They have people who understand how the scripts work. They are not just on the ball; they are all over the ball. And even then, it would take them three years to go through and check (and possibly fix) each one. > Oh, did I mention that four hundred of those programs are 16-bit? 16-bit. Ten years after Windows 95 came out. [0] A great source of backwards compatibility stories. [1] https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20061106-01/?p=29123#mainContent https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20061106-01/?p=29...
- scarface74 7y agoWell seeing how Microsoft’s profits have increased compare to Apple’s, which was the better idea? Selling to consumers or businesses? And MS’s recent successes have had nothing to do with Windows. MS’s growth has come from o365 being available everywhere and Azure - where most of the VMs are in fact Linux not Windows. Not to mention that .Net for Windows and all of the related technology (WinForms, WPF, etc) are in maintenance mode while MS concentrates on cross platform .Net Core. Microsoft is doing the same thing with Windows that SJ said he would do with the Mac “milk it for all it’s worth and move on to the next big thing”. MS is running away from Windows as it’s cash cow quickly.
- deleted 7y ago
- freeone3000 7y agoWindows runs on refrigerators and signage panels and ATMs just fine. It's not based on since inherent technical inadequacy, people just don't like MS products. Usually because they're late and don't quite align with what normal people want... But I don't think this has anything to do with backwards compatibility. From the Zune to WP10, what kills Microsoft in an area is "Also-ran", "not good enough", and "kinda clunky"
- scarface74 7y agoHow else do you define as “running just fine” than - something people actually want? Most of the kiosk/vertical market type devices are running a version of Android now. The vendors that use to sell ruggedized Windows mobile devices like Intermec have since started reflashing them to run Android.