4 ms·
This happened to me, in the early 1990s. I spent months writing a very capable MIDI driver. In those days, writing a MIDI driver was a truly non-trivial exerci
by ChrisMarshallNY 7y ago
This happened to me, in the early 1990s.
I spent months writing a very capable MIDI driver. In those days, writing a MIDI driver was a truly non-trivial exercise, as you had to have a MIDI adapter that fed back a 1MHz clock, which you would then program their UART to clock down.
That UART was also a pretty hairy bit of hardware. You had to program it with ASM, and the chip was set up so that a 16-bit address range corresponded to various control states. Setting control states for the chip meant a LOT of homework.
MIDI drivers basically were about as difficult as you could get, as you needed to step down an external clock, and set up things like ring buffers that were large enough to not trip over their own feet during an intense session.
Anyhoo, after a couple of months of working on the driver (and buying a DX-7 as a test bed), I was just about to announce it, when Apple came up with a package of OS utilities that included...a MIDI driver.
I don't think that theirs was as good as mine, but that was beside the point.
I open-sourced the driver, but the OS community wasn't particularly well-established back then, and I believe that it's lost in the sands of time.
- crtlaltdel 7y agoThe linked article states that Apple actively researched their products. Is this what happened with your MIDI driver?
- scarface74 7y agoDo you really think that Apple couldn’t come up with the idea for SideCar without Luna? You could already use AirPlay to create a second monitor from your Mac and use AirPlay as a second display from iOS. It was completely logical that the next step is to send video from your Mac to your iPad as a second display.
- seandougall 7y agoIndeed, Apple had already implemented something similar with Target Display Mode on the iMac back in 2009, so it's hardly a stretch to figure they've been planning something like this for essentially as long as iPads have been around.
- opless 7y agoAnd air display was around shortly after the iPad was launched, yes including touch-mouse features. For me, the novelty quickly wore off. Amazing how long Apple took to replicate THIS VERY OBVIOUS FEATURE.
- tpmx 7y agoDo you feel any resentment against Apple from this chapter of your life?
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoAnswer 1: I did not have any kind of relationship with Apple, except for the standard Developer agreement. I don't think they copied anything from me, so it was not, truth be told, exactly the same. Answer 2: Not especially, but those of us that have been programming Apple since the 1980s (I've been at it for a loooong time) have learned a rather cynical outlook. Apple has a long, long history of stepping on its developers; often accidentally (but we still got stepped on). I've taken OpenDoc and QuickDraw GX courses, because they were the future. Anyone remember Copeland, and the enormous push behind it? I still love programming Apple devices. I'm writing an open-source Bluetooth driver, right now.
- tpmx 7y agoOf course lots of us remember https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copland_(operating_system) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copland_(operating_system). At least I hope there's at least a small amount of other 40+ devs on here. :) I think your attitude is healthy btw.
- erichocean 7y ago> I'm writing an open-source Bluetooth driver, right now. Link?
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoIt's still very much a WIP. I just burned the first iteration to the ground, and replaced it with a ghastly chimera that uses adapters to abstract the transport: https://github.com/RiftValleySoftware/RVS_GTDriver https://github.com/RiftValleySoftware/RVS_GTDriver I expect to have it to the same level as the original version in the next few days. After that, I will be working on a BT Classic transport adapter. I learned the hard way that it's a royal pain to try sniffing BLE.
- logicallee 7y agoYou say you were just about to announce it, so doesn't that mean nobody saw your work yet? If so it sounds like it doesn't fit the definition of sherlocking, just an unfortunate coincidence.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoYes, you are correct. Not the same. Just great minds thinking alike. I suspect the feelings (on my part) were similar...
- luftfield 7y agoSo in other words embedded hardware programming hasn’t changed a bit.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoYeah. I worked on an embedded Android project a few years ago (Intrynsic board). It was fairly gnarly.
- bobowzki 7y agoEmbedded programming usually change bits :-)
- wil421 7y agoWhat’s your point? Two entities working in silos don’t tell anyone what they are building and the bigger one releases it first leaving the other one feeling jaded.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoNot really "jaded," per se. I hadn't really worked out what I was going to do with the driver, anyway. I tend to write stuff like that because I enjoy doing it. In the aggregate, it all worked out for the best. That was my first open-source project, and most of what I've written since, has been open-source.
- IanCal 7y agoIt seemed like a relevant story given the article, and I quite enjoyed it. People don't always have to be making a point or arguing something.
- arthurcolle 7y agoI just came across UART in the context of one of my side-projects related to the DJI Matrice 100 and have zero hardware related experience and seeing it in this context gives me some XKCD 979 vibes.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoBack in the days before fire, before USB, and before the Internet, UARTs were everything. One couldn't call oneself an engineer until one had programmed a UART. You kids with your USB have it easy these days.
- JediPig 7y agowrote com driver with 6501, it happens no matter if its apple , ibm, or micrsoft. I found out years later they copied the asm code and "reordered" it to make it look they done work.