4 ms·
How would those lobbyists find out, if it were so secret? We can look at other projects, like Bussard's Polywell. Either all of these lobbyists could figure ou
by eesmith 7y ago
How would those lobbyists find out, if it were so secret?
We can look at other projects, like Bussard's Polywell. Either all of these lobbyists could figure out that it wouldn't work out, so didn't fight the development, or there isn't a major lobbyist effort as you describe it. I strongly suspect the latter.
Or, consider nuclear power during the 1950s, when the fossil fuel worker union was far more powerful than now. What lobbying effort was there, and it doesn't seem that effective.
Or, consider whale oil, which once a major industrial oil. Despite the number of people involved in whaling, and the money involved, it was replaced with other oils. (Wikipedia says it was used in transmission oil until the 1970s!)
The strategic effort you mentioned are essentially the same as those used in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Army_Nuclear_Power_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Army_Nuclear_Power_Program . Mining requires more than just electricity - look at how much work the Gotthard Base Tunnel took, and those were all electrically powered. Where do the spoils go? Where are the ventilation shafts?
As for "there are very few people that know where the United States keeps any of it's various strategic stock piles" - what are you talking about? The strategic oil reserve locations are located at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Petroleum_Reserve_(United_States) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Petroleum_Reserve_(U... , the National Helium Reserve is listed at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Helium_Reserve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Helium_Reserve with lat/long even.
Again, the benefits of secrecy you mention are far, far outweighed by the benefits of it being public.
- ryanmercer 7y ago>How would those lobbyists find out, if it were so secret? In a situations here this is rolled out for use to replace power plants and not for classified military applications, thus the various civilian industries and their lobbyists mentioned. I thought this was pretty obvious given I mention a laundry list of civilian industries that the bulk of which are comprised of private and publicly traded companies that are not defense related industries. >As for "there are very few people that know where the United States keeps any of it's various strategic stock piles" - what are you talking about? Stuff like the SNS which is 1 (more likely than not there are multiple locations with only public acknowledgement that 1 warehouse exists given a natural disaster or nuclear attack to a single region could effectively destroy the only stockpile) plain, unmarked, warehouse that the location to is a closely guarded secret due to the fact that someone simply driving a tanker full of a flammable material, then igniting it, through one of the doors of the warehouse could destroy the government's strategic stockpile of antibiotics, vaccines, chemical antidotes, antitoxins, PPE equipment, respirators and other critical medical supplies making it a highly valuable target to both foreign governments and terrorists. And the things that simply aren't public knowledge at all. I mean, every few years someone stumbles upon Cold War stockpiles that had been forgotten like back in 2006 when stockpiles of rations and medical supplies were found in the foundations of the Brooklyn Bridge. But I'm happy for you that you can google 'strategic stockpile' and link me to a helium supply that the government has already order shut down and sold off (which has been covered by podcasts like Planet Money this year).
- eesmith 7y agoNo, it's not obvious. dangerface was talking about highly secretive projects. Your statement was only "if we had a relatively small fusion reactor". Nothing in what you wrote marked the transition from having a highly secretive small fusion reactor to one which was being 'rolled out for use to replace power plants'. Please don't be so snide. I'm not completely ignorant. I mentioned those strategic stockpiles because they were the ones I knew about, from years ago. I also know about Quebec's maple syrup reserves because of the theft a few years back. And, the "any" in your statement "any of it's various strategic stock piles" typically means all of them, not some of them. Which is why I asked for clarification. And the National Helium Reserve is still around, making it is a valid example.