5 ms·
People have good reasons to be skeptical about such studies: there's like a million of possible confounders for these kind of things, and it's impossible to con
by littlestymaar 7y ago
People have good reasons to be skeptical about such studies: there's like a million of possible confounders for these kind of things, and it's impossible to control for every one of them (remember, if you control for 2 confounders which are themselves confounded by a common source, you're not controlling for anything and you're just adding bias).
People should just stop doing this kind of studies, we are just not equipped with powerful enough mathematical tools yet to deal with this kind of highly entangled phenomenons (and we often don't have the data either, collecting and curating it would be an interesting and useful research topic by itself).
- yearofthespider 7y agoI cannot imagine being either dumb or arrogant enough to suggest that people should not attempt to study problems just because they're challenging.
- littlestymaar 7y ago> Challenging Yeah, like looking for perpetual movement or the philosopher stone. BTW, I should have worded my thoughts differently: I don't mind if individual people waste their time doing that kind of pseudo-science. I do mind however that these studies get fundings instead of more down-to-earth ones. I do mind when young researchers are driven to this kind of bs by perverse insentives. And I do mind when laypersons are taught by mainstream media that this is science.
- yearofthespider 7y agoYour first sentence makes clear (again) that you think you're so smart that you can determine what research is potentially viable and what isn't, without even having any expertise in a given area. I already stated that you're ludicrously stupid and arrogant. Stop proving me correct. (or don't. no skin off my back either way.)
- littlestymaar 7y agoInsulting people on the internet using throwaway accounts, what a wonderful hobby. Good day.
- yearofthespider 7y agoFar better than being an arrogant asshole who asserts that people should only research things where you decide in advance that the answers are sufficiently trivial.
- CamelCaseName 7y ago> And I do mind when laypersons are taught by mainstream media that this is science. What is your definition for "science"? To me, this is very much science. Starting off with a hypothesis, gathering/analyzing data, controlling for what you can, and concluding your findings with a number of caveats detailing the limitations of your research. Unfortunately, not everything is a hard science, and even those sciences we consider hard sciences break down when you get deep enough. I think your suggestion is rather dangerous and implies some arbitrary threshold where we become capable of studying something. A simple example would by psychology. Whenever a psychology study comes out, people are quick to yell that it is useless, that there are flaws, etc. However, without these psychology studies, where would we begin when studying mental health issues? How many people would be left to suffer untreated if we were to wait for the biology, chemistry, neurology, etc. fields to become advanced enough for us to detect with certainty the presence of a mental illness? It's easy to belittle an study that turns up nothing or belongs to a soft science, but as the saying goes, "all models are wrong, but some models are useful."
- bigfudge 7y agoWorth remembering that astronomy is largely an Observational science. It doesn’t make it less interesting or ‘hard’
- littlestymaar 7y ago> I think your suggestion is rather dangerous and implies some arbitrary threshold where we become capable of studying something. The threshold isn't so much about when we become capable of "studying something" but more about when we become capable of claiming something. In that particular case, we have so many things at stakes, it becomes really tough to find anything useful. How can you know you're not measuring the correlation between weather and crime? Day of the week and crime? Season and crime? Because season and weather are related, you can't just “control for both” (unfortunately, many people will do it no matter what…). What if air pressure had an impact on crime? It's somehow correlated to air pollution so you could mistake it for an influence of pollution itself. When just asking the question reveals that the answer would need fancy statistics (some not being invented yet, AFAIK, or at least not mainstream). If you realize that, you should just find another problem, or maybe rescope your problem. If you don't realize that, and still go on with your regular methodology, your results are doomed from the start, and you aren't really doing more science than youtubers attempting to find the recipe for perpetual motion. [I'm not talking about this specific paper here, just answering about your remarks about threshold]. When it comes to this paper, I would say that the level of accuracy of their published result (“0.14% increase”) is dubious. In a lab with controlled conditions, such figures aren't that easy to get, in a real world observation of human behavior, it's looks fishy.
- zepto 7y agoI agree that these kinds of study lead to problematic analysis, but it seems weird to say we should stop doing them. Perhaps simply not drawing false conclusions from them would be better.
- mikelyons 7y agoThe way these tools are developed is by doing and then replicating and analyzing these studies. (maybe thats what the intent behind "collecting and curating" was?) Exposure to air pollution seems to my intuition like it lowers a persons level of consciousness, and the lower a persons level of consciousness (the further down The Spiral Dynamics model they are) the more prone they are to violence.
- littlestymaar 7y ago> The way these tools are developed is by doing and then replicating and analyzing these studies Nobody in the field of people publishing this kind of studies has the required skill-set to develop the needed tools. This is the job of mathematicians. I'm not meaning it pejoratively, it's just a totally different job. (I wouldn't trust a mathematician to build a house, you shouldn't trust an economist, a biologist, or anyone to build statistics tooling). > maybe thats what the intent behind "collecting and curating" was?) Most of the time the data behind this kind of studies isn't easily available. Sometimes you can shoot an email to the author, sometimes it comes from some publicly available data needing a lot of preprocessing before being consumable, and I wish we had a centralized database of well-formed data.
- mikelyons 7y agoI see, and agree. It seems though that we've (as a society) gotten into a habit of categorizing people. Maybe rightfully as specialization has increased, but it seems to me (perhaps wrongfully) that there were more polymaths in Ben Franklins time for example.
- anigbrowl 7y agoYou seem to be overlooking the possibility that such study teams can and do include mathematicians. I'm friends with one who does the statistical legwork for a foundation that studies the spread of infectious disease.
- littlestymaar 7y ago